Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fight for the right to study! Defend student unions! Defend student unions!

Socialist Organiser no. 415, 14 September 1989 · scan p. 5 · about 1,879 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

(NUS NEC, personal capacity)

The student movement faces its biggest challenge in recent years.

It faces a Tory government that is serious about introducing a system of student loans, and moving towards legislation designed to break up the National Union of Students (NUS).

The Tories seem likely to unveil precise plans for loans and voluntary membership at their conference in October or in the Queen's Speech in mid-November.

Probably loans will first be introduced through a 'top-up' system, which means that an already diminished student grant will be supplemented by loans of €12,000. Then the grant element will be gradually cut and the loan element expanded.

Already the Great Education Reform Bill has included the effective privatisation of Higher and Further Education. The move towards loans also fits snugly into the restructuring of the education system that the Tories want.

Out go notions of education as a right or education for its own sake. In comes the American model of education for industry and profit, and education regulated by market forces.

This is another piece in the Thatcherite jigsaw which already includes the conscription of 16-18 year olds onto YTS, pressure on Higher and Further Education colleges to become profit-seeking units in an education 'market' , and the horrors of the effects of the GERBill in primary and secondary education.

Britain's already discriminatory education system will become ever more discriminatory. Sections of society - working-class, women, mature, black and disabled students - traditionally excluded from Higher Education will be increasingly deterred by financial considerations. The Tories' talk of increasing the numbers of students in Higher Education by 50,000 just sounds ironic.

The loan system, and consequent pressure to repay, will push graduates towards better-paid jobs and away from professions such as teaching and jobs in the voluntary sector. So education will be harmed from another angle, too.

It is also likely that this parliamentary session will see some form of restrictive legislation Thursday 14 September Leeds SO: 'How to beat the poll tax'. . Coburg pub, 7.30 Sunday 17 September North London SO: 'In Defence of th French Revolution'. Angel & Crowr Upper St, 7.30 Monday 18 September Isaac Deutscher Memorial Lecture: 'The Importance of being Marxist", by Boris Kagarlitsky. New Theatre, LSE, 7.30 Thursday 21 September Newcastle SO: 'The Alternative the Policy Review. Moorside School, 7.30 Saturday 23 September Campaign Group of Labour MPS: or day seminar - 'Planning for Victory'. Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Road, N7, 11.30. Conference fee £2, to Jeremy Corbyn, 129 Seven Sisters Road, N7 Sunday 24 September North London SO: 'Solidarity with China's workers and students' Angel & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Thursday 28 September Nottingham SO: What is against NUS and individual student loans. The recent flurry of articles in the quality and education press, and the setting up of a Parliamentary Group of anti-NUS MPs, confirm this.

No doubt there is some conflict between gung-ho Tory MPs, such as Rhodes Boyson and Tim Jarman, whe want the complete dismantling of NUS and individual student unions, and those who take a more cautious attiude. However, one thing is certain — NUS is going to be hit.

The Conservative Collegiate Forum's (CCF) recent studentunion-bashirg document, *Perestroika On Campus' , shows that the racist, homophobic leadership of the Conservative student organisation is well organised and means business.

What kind of strategy can win? An honest assessment of the state of NUS is the first stage towards an informed analysis.| Unfortunately the student movement is blessed with a group of leaders' devoid of both ideas and the ability to formulate a fighting strategy. To beat loans and defend student unions, the hotch-potch of Kinnockites, CPers, right-wing independents and fellow travellers who dominate the NUS National Executive Committee are relying on the same strategy that has failed the student movement so many times betore: get the support of 'public opinion': get the support of dissi. dent Tory MPs; get the Labour Party and SLD to make a good parliamentary intervention; and back all this up with respectable student activity.

The support of public opinion is to be welcomed, but such an approach does not deal with what is necessary to defeat the Tories. Public opinion did not save the Greater London Council or the nurses.

But if we pursue middle-class public opinion on its terms, inevitably we end up dropping the more radical of NUS's policies. Anyway, the Tories are serious about the dismantling of the education system as it exists. A bit of back-bench lobbying will not change their minds.

Students need an alternative. Left Unity supporters are arguing for a radically different perspective. We base ourselves on student self-activity linked to labour movement support.

At the moment the Tories are faltering. They are unpopular because of the Poll Tax, distrusted on the National Health Service, and hurt by the victories of NALGC and the rail workers. The prospects socialism?'. International Community Centre, Mansfield Road, 7.30 Friday 29 September Leeds Socialist Organiser and Socialist Outlook debate: "Where is the USSR going?' Leeds Poly Student Union, 7.30 Sunday 1 October North London SO: 'Social Democracy goes Thatcherite' & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Sunday 1 October Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign: 'Sandinista Sprint' , sponsored run and dance for Nicaragua. Brockwell Park, Brixton, SW9, 11.00. Details from NSC, 23 Bevenden St, London N1 6BH (253 0246)

Tuesday 3 October Canterbury SO: 'Socialists and the Labour Party'. KJCR III Saturday 7 October Socialist Lecturers' Alliance: 'NATFHE 1989 Pay Claim Action Conference'. • New Imperial Hotel, Birmingham. Details from Barry Lovejoy.

25 Philip Victor Rd, Birmingham B20 Sunday 8 October Socialist Platform Memorial Meeting for Harry Wicks. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, London WC1, 3.00 Monday 9 October Sheffield SO: 'Stalin's heirs face workers' SCCAU, 73 West St, 7.30 'Beat 1 in a fi seem l the mi Left dent n follow defens to be NU: demar battle beyon • PI tor int FES award award It is the bi campi energ! their | The MuS!

native linked Org cupat aroun ferent focus activi arise, futur on ed Thi tain fundi tion c is fu Studi prepa Grad plem:

seem! well dards a der comi of E Labo with radic Grad Iti tivist relati attai Studi beco the Blues' student demonstration ght for the right to education m better than at any time since of iners' strike. t Unity is arguing that the stunovement should take up the ing strategy. Firstly, the sive nature of the struggles nas challenged.

S needs a positive package of ids to: leet the Tories head on in the of ideas; mobilise its membership d 'No to Loans'; ull the Further Education secto the struggle on a new basis. students need mandatory Is and better discretionary Is. ¡ the job of NUS to "integrate" attle against loans into other ugns, capturing the maximum y for the central battle against oans system. : slogan should be Fight for Right to Study - Defend NUS needs to have an alter: vision of education. But than that, this vision has to be i to action. ganising demonstrations, ocions and other direct action id the time of Tory Party Conce and the Queen's Speech will on the need and power of selfty. But other questions will for example, what will a e Labour Government's policy ucation look like? e present Policy Reviews conno commitment to adequate ng of education, and the quesif the level of the student grant dged. It seems that Labour ents' leadership are even ired to accept the idea of a luate Tax (already imented by the Labor governin Australia). Recent articles : Times imply this.

Kinnock Labour Government s certain to attack education as as working-class living stani. Raising positive demands for cent education system during ng struggles will act as a pole attraction for activists, as Students' leadership side Kinnock's denunciations of al action and plans for a luate Tax. is also essential that student acts understand the interonships between the various cks. Under the Labour ents' leadership, NUS has me increasingly irrelevant to its ON •PO embership. Calls for the defence ¡ NUS have to be linked to, and deed are conditional on, a real ruggle against loans. NUS only ecomes something worth defening when it proves it can deliver in le fight to preserve our living stanards and rights to education.

So the fight against loans is cenal to the success of the battle gainst voluntary membership.

It is not adequate to simply lump ie Poll Tax on top of the loans and bluntary membership issues. To • so without explanation or nderstanding — as groups like the lilitant do - clouds up the issues at activists must get to grips with.

Loans and voluntary membership re student-specific issues. The Poll ax is not, and its defeat will need a ruggle by the whole of the labour lovement. To see only the milarities and miss some of the obous differences between the issues tews our strategy.

A political framework which nderstands the roles of student acon and Labour movement suport, and the dynamics of camaigns, is being concretised by Lett nity. To take forward the debate n activity and action further, acvists must: • support the MANUS emonstration on 18 October; • come to the conference on oans and Voluntary Membership rganised by Kent Area NUS for 4 lovember in London; • come to the lobby of Parlialent on 20 October (the day that ›ans is being debated), also called y Kent Area NUS; • a co-ordinated wave of occupaons in response to the Queen's peech, linked to a national emonstration, is central to uilding a national campaign that is for the right to Manchester Area NUS Wednesday 18 October Manchester posters, camera-ready arty phone 061 736 3636 adequate to beat the Tories. This perspective must be closely tied to the work of building activists' networks in the colleges, links with workers in campus trade unions and the pressing task of replacing the ridiculous leadership of NUS.

All the indications are that the New Realism of Labour Students has led them to the conclusion that all they can do is wait for a Labour government to help them out, and meanwhile maybe win a few concessions from the Tories on Housing Benefits. These people have failed the student movement on every occasion.

Others on the left have also failed to understand the most elementary of ideas. Militant and their front organisation, Further Education Labour Students, have belatedly arrived at crude versions of ideas we advocated three years ago. Those ideas are not only gutted of the need to build an activist movement in NUS, but are banally repeated as propaganda tied to slogans abour future socialist Labour governments.

Militant tend to argue that students can't win anything without the help of the labour movement. Tweedledee, the SWP, don't even attempt to formulate a policy beyond 'more militant student action'. This is just student syndicalism.

Despite their inadequacies, Left Unity will be looking to build joint action with all the left groups, Greens and independent activists. MUS desperately needs a non-sectarian fighting left to save it from the Tories.

Join Left Unity: £2.50 (grant)/ 50p (no grant) - c/o 56 Kevan House, /Wyndham Road, London SES.

----- pull-quotes -----

ACTIMISTS" DIARY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 415

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →