Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The oppressed can become oppressors

Socialist Organiser no. 415, 14 September 1989 · scan p. 4 · Martin Thomas · about 1,164 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Charity begins in the palace...

In average of 16 people A are deported from Britain every day of the year, seven days a week.

The figure has multiplied more than four times since the Tories took office in 1979, and it is ten times what it was in 1974, although Britain's immigrant population has not increased particularly and new immigration from Asia, the West Indies and Africa has been tiny.

According to Searchlight magazine, quoting the Refugee Forum, over 6,000 people were deported in 1988. In 1979 there were only 1,300 deportation orders, and in 1974 only 500.

One hundred and sixty to the average household for the Tories' privatisation programme.

Figures released this week by Labour front-bencher Gordon Brown show that the total paid to advertis ing agencies and City bankers in the sell-off programme is over £2 billion from the poll tax, accord ing to calculations by local authorities.

Private tenants' rents included an element for rates, but they didn't get any reduction when the landlords stopped having to pay rates and the tenants started having to pay poll tax.

The same thing is likely to happen in England and London Labour coun cils reckon that the windfall for Jandlords in London alone could be. over £90 million.

wish we were wrong. One the tat separates Socialist Organiser from the rest of the left is our adherence to Lenin's principle on national conflicts: "A struggle against the privileges and violence of the oppressing nation and no toleration of the striving for privileges on the part of the oppressed nation".

The argument has focused around Israel/Palestine and Ireland. Like most other leftists, we support the Palestinian Arabs and the Northern Ireland Catholics in their struggles against oppression. But we also say - in line with the bit of Lenin's summary to which I have added italics above - that a socialist and democratic policy must include guarantees of the national or communal rights of the Israeli Jews and the Irish Protestants. It must propose consistent democracy not revenge for past atrocities.

Many people on the left reckon that we are thus insulting and betraying the oppressed peoples. The problem in Ireland and Palestine, they say, is imperialem and the Catholic Irish and Palestinian Arabs are not imperialist. Socialist Organiser is giving comfort and succour to imperialism, or its allies and agents.

If only it were so...lf it were so, then we would not have had the sickening series of proofs over the last few weeks that we are right. Anti-imperialist' peoples can become oppressors too.

For centuries the Poles have been the most oppressed, carved-up and bullied people in Europe. Yet Cardinal Glemp, leader of the Catholic Church in Poland, has denounced Jews who asked for the removal of a new convent set up on the site of Auschwitz in the most vicious antisemitic terms.

—The Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were taken over by Stalin through a deal he struck with Hitler, and for 49 years since then have suffered Russian domination. Now the local rulers talk of immigration controls against Russian workers moving to their areas.

They talk of making their local languages the sole official language, thus discriminating against the very large minorites of Russianspeakers.

The same demand has been raised by nationalists in another fringe republic of the USSR, Moldavia. The Moldavians have had Russian imposed on them as their official language, and the Cyrillic (Russian)

nian). Now they want to turn the tables, In the south of the USSR, longoppressed Azerbaijanis are venting their anger not on the rulers in Moscow but on Armenians. Georgians are demanding more freedom from Moscow - but also stamping down on their local minority of Abkhazians.

These problems arise in Eastern Europe more than anywhere else because Eastern Europe has such a complex patchwork of small nations and scattered minorities. But they are not unique to Eastern Europe. There is a Western example of the same pattern which we should have learned from long ago, in Quebec, the French-speaking province of Canada.

The French-speaking Quebecois were oppressed for centuries under the rule of England and then of English-speaking Canada. AngloCanadians held prejudices against the French-speakers quite comparable to anti-black racism in Britain.

In the late 1960s a big Quebecseparatist movement emerged. The old separatist groups - small, very Catholic, traditionalist and rignt wing — were replaced by a big new party, the Parti Quebecois, social-democratic in tone, and eagerly supported by militant trade unions.

Quebecois started talking about themselves as the 'white niggers' of North America, and linking their cause with a world-wide fight against racism and colonialism.

Most leftists were jubilant. The revolution was on its way.

Twenty years later, the Parti Quebecois has become a regular capitalist party of government in Quebec. There is no strong drive to make Quebec independent: instead Quebec nationalism has focused on issues of language rights.

Since 1969 the federal government of Canada has given the French language spoken by 30 per cent of its people absolutely equal status to the English language spoken by 70 per cent. Quebec naWar nies from same sort of approach in Quebec -giving the English language preferred by 20 per cent of Quebec people equal status with French would just mean continued English domination.

To redress the balance, it was necessary to make French the sole official language. This meant, for example, that it became very difficult for English-speakers to have their children educated in English.

The reaction of Quebec's French speakers like that of the Moldavians, was understandable. But its results were to increase bitterness and divert the Quebec labour movement into a blind alley. Those who suffered were not just the racists and the fat cats, but also ordinary English-speaking workers, and migrants from countries like Italy and Poland, who had generally made English rather than French their second language, It is a sad story. What makes it sadder is that much of the left continues to support the demand for French-language domination Quebec - and Socialist Worker for example, last week, supported the demand for local-language domination in Modavia. "To argue for...keeping both Russian and local language as official does nothing to redress the years of discrimination. The current strikes by Russian speaking workers are reactionary..."

For sixty years or so after World War 1, national conflicts were overwhelmingly battles between colonial peoples, fighting for liberation and oppressive great powers. Today we have many more complex conflicts.

It is time the left stopped trying to cram every national conflict into the mould of a colonial liberation struggle, and returned to the Marxist classics, learning from what Lenin and other Marxists wrote about the complex national and communal conflicts in Eastern Europe in their day.

----- pull-quotes -----

cottish landlords have had Strom the pal tax, co

workers! fight

alphabet imposed on them for their own language (a dialect of Ruma-

tionalists, however, felt that the occupettendl

Gears a We Demand the independent Gene

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 415

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →