Taking stock in industry
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
EDITORIAL The last few months have T seen a spectacular upsurge in industrial action.
The Tories' 'de facto' seven per cent pay ceiling has been decisively smashed by a series of groups of workers.
Some of them did not even have to take strike action, but merely threaten it (like the power workers who settled for 9.2% in May, after balloting in favour of industrial action); and two watershed pay deals earlier this year were reached without even the threat of industrial action. At Ford, the second stage of a two-year deal triggered an 8.9% increase, 15% was achieved while at Nissan a specin January as the first part of a two-year deal.
Settlements like these, combined with the steady rise to 8% and beyond of the price index, the increase in mortgage payments of up to £200 per month many workers, and the well-publicised six-figure salary increases of bosses like Lord King of British Aerospace and Jeffrey Sterling of P&O, have fuelled the present upsurge of wages militancy.
Workers' self-confidence has been boosted by the continuing decline in unemployment and the advent of a 'skills shortage' in engineering and manufacturing; and an explosive cocktail has been completed by a drive by several key employers for the restructuring of established bargaining machinery. In local government and on SENe railways, moves towards localised bargaining coincided with the upsurge in wages militancy to produce remarkably solid rank and file support for official disputes 500,000 local government workers began a programme of 'rolling' strikes in early July demanding a 12% pay rise with no strings. It was the first time their union, NALGO, had ever called national strike action.
At the same time, railworkers embarked upon a series of highly effective one-day strikes in protest at an imposed 7% pay increase and the break up of their national negotiating machinery. The BR Board's "tough guy" tactics soon collapsed in the face of railworkers' solidarity and the Board was forced to up their pay offer to 8.8% and withdraw at least some of the strings, in a climbdown.
The town hall bosses had to make similar concessions to halt the NALGO action.
Not everything has been on the up and up. The dockers' defeat is a serious setback for the labour movement, but it probably will not have the same generally dulling effect that the miners' defeat had.
The overall picture is one of advance for the class. Quite apart from the immediate victories that have been achieved on pay and strings', there is the less tangible but even more important knock-on effect summed up by the Financial Times: "The councils' climbdown comes in the wake of disputes at British Rail and London Underground which were also settled after considerable concessions by *The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human briacs without distinction of or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports: first post management. Taken together, the settlements are likely to encourage a growing confidence among British workers that carefully planned industrial action can achieve results."
The significance of the latest round of national disputes is best illustrated by some simple statistics: in the 12 months up to May 1988, 2,147,000 strike days were lost; in the 12 months between May 1988 and May 1989 the figure was 2,911,000; this year's NALGO action alone has lost well over 3,000,000 strike days; industrial action is now firmly back on the agenda as a fact of British industrial life, despite all the Thatcherite propaganda and Marxism Today-type theories about "the end of the working class"
This pattern is set to continue with the engineers' 35-hour week campaign and a host of wages disputes coming up. The engineers' dispute is of particular importance. Their central demand of a 35-hour week with no loss of pay counterposes the interests of the working class to those of capital. This demand should be taken up by broader sections of the labour movement and linked to a serious fight for an end to overtime and a minimum wage of at least two-thirds of the average wage.
Such a struggle would pose questions of control in the workplace and, to paraphrase Marx, represent a struggle between the political economy of the bourgeoisie and that of the working class.
It is ironic that the new militancy coincides with Neil Kinnock's new drive to make Labour a 'safe' alternative government for the British ruling class and to distance the party from extra-parliamentary struggle. After weeks of equivocation on the rail strike, Kinnock publicly called upon the NUR to accept the 8.8% offer.
Despite Kinnock's behaviour, many workers see his approach as the best hope of ousting the Tories at the next general election. What is required is a positive, working-class alternative to both Kinnock's class collaborationist leadership in the right.
That means integrating the battles inside both the trade unions and Within the unions this involves laying the foundations of a rank and file movement capable of linking up struggles, placing demands upon the existing leaders and where necessary - organising independently of them. It must be a rank and file movement that avoids the twin dangers of becoming simpv an electoral machine and stage army for 'left bureaucrats' (like the CP-dominated Broad Lefts of the "70s) and the syndicalist error of attempting simply to bypass the existing leaderships without placing demands upon them or challenging them politically.
It would take disputes seriously, respond quickly and attempt to seize the initiative. It would try to generalise action and operate to spread information and to agitate and organise for solidarity.
Where necessary it would have to act as an alternative leadership in the union. As the old slogan goes: fIf the leaders won't lead, then the phone Monday PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. NALGO's first-ever national strike rank and file must*.
The struggle for trade union democracy is a vital part of the process of building a rank and file movement. A programme for trade union democracy would have to involve, as a minimum campaign:
• All officials elected for definite terms - no more than two years. -and subject to recall;
• Policy-making bodies made up of lay members only;
• Delegate conferences to have supreme policy-making powers;
• Elections at workplace meetings or workplace ballots;
• All candidates to have unrestricted rights to circulate literature;
• No secret negotiations. Elected rank and file strike committees to control all disputes.
These demands need to be linked to policies designed to draw specially oppressed sections of the working class into the unions. For example: full support for the self-organisation of women, black people, lesbians and gay men, and positive discrimination within the structures of the labour movement.
Given the employers' increasing readiness to use the courts and the Tories' anti-union legislation to outlaw official action and threaten union funds, many militants are looking towards 'pure' rank and file unofficial action as a way of circurventing the law and the timidity of official leaderships. The eitectiveness of the unofficial London Underground strikes has added to the attraction of 'pure' rank and filism amongst many militants.
But it is a dead end for all but the most tightly knit and well-organised groups of workers. Paradoxically, the approach of totally by-passing official union structures can quite often suit the bureaucrats, allowing them to stand back from the action and evade their responsibility to provide leadership and support to the strikers.
There are two solutions to this problem:
(1) For socialists to continually press for industrial action - including action outside the law — to be made official, thus forcing the ALL OUT GO NA Worke NALGO ion important gains officials to commit themselves to backing the strikers and making it clear to the employers that they are involved in a serious dispute.
(2) Campaigning politically for the repeal of the existing anti-union legislation and for a positive alternative set of legal rights for workers, including the legally enforceable right to strike and picket effectively, for access to workplaces in order to organise, the right to stop the job whenever health and safety are in doubt, the right of unions to determine their own internal democracy free from the courts, the right to employment free from sexual or racial discrimination or discrimination on grounds of sexuality, etc, etc.
Such a response does not represent 'reformism' or 'spreading illusions in the bourgeois state': rather it represents a way of putting forward a generalising overall political alternative to the Tories' anti-union laws and Kinnock's pale-pink imitation.
This approach fits in with the classic Marxist approach to the struggle for reforms.
As Marx argued:
..every movement in which the working class as a class confronts the ruling classes and tries to constrain them by pressure from without is a political movement. For instance, the attempt by strikes etc. in a particular factory or even in a particular trade to compel individual capitalists to reduce the working day is a purely economic movement.
"On the other hand, the movement to force through an eight-hour etc. law is a political movement. And in this way, out of the separate economic movements of the workers there grows up everywhere a political movement, that is to say, a class movement with the object of enforcing its interests in a general form, in a form possessing general, socially coercive force."
Such a positive approach is the way to directly challenge the Labour leadership's strategy of distancing a future Labour government from the unions and from militant union action. GANIC The
----- pull-quotes -----
Labour party and the 'new realism' of trade union leaders, both left and
NO DEALS RING) NO STRING M INGS