South Wales miners ar battered but unbowed
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
On Wednesday 23 announced the closure of a further two South Wales collieries. Mark Organiser about the impact of the closures T Oakdale - the last pit in he two pits closed are Gwent and one of the biggest pits in South Wales, one of the largest employers of miners — and Merthyr Vale, situated in the village of Aberfan, a village that paid a high price for coal with the disaster in 1966.
These two closures have devastated the South Wales coalfield - most of the men that worked these pits are men that have moved from other pits when they've closed.
The men knew the closures were in the pipeline, but they'd been given reprieves and targets to reach. Merthyr Vale reached targets but the Coal Board just upped the targets again.
The employers steamrollered the men into taking redundancy by announcing that the big redundancy schemes would be finishing on the Saturday of the week they announced the closures!
Merthyr Vale Lodge put a policy to management to save the pit but management weren't having it. If the Lodge had gone in and said we'll work seven days week and take a cut in wages they would still have said no, we don't want Merthyr Vale, it's closed!
It doesn't matter how much of a case you put, if they want to close a pit they close it. South Wales is not even a British Coal Area as such now, it's a "Group' - They have actually closed down the Llanishen offices (the Coal Board Area offices) so we're now working under a total stranger who doesn't even know the area.
But it's not only South Wales that's under these conditions - if they want to shut a pit in Yorkshire they'll shut it. They've proved that with a number of pits that have closed.
The union is having to take each pit individually, formulate a report each time with independent assessors and so on. In the case of Oakdale they had a manager in from another pit in South Wales who did a report but the Coal Board didn't want to know. When they went into the meeting they just thanked the union, thanked the management for doing the report, and didn't even look at it.
At Merthyr Vale the vote was close over whether to fight the closure, but you're in a Catch-22 each time a closure is announced. The men are sickened by and of course you've got the stalwarts who want the pit still working, but then there's the others who would be quite happy to leave the industry because they're getting to the point that they don't know what the future is.
The older element see it as their opportunity to get out. People haven't got the will to work in the collieries any more, because management are bringing you down, day in, day out, with bully tactics and what have you, deliberately slowing down on developments, saying we haven't got a market for our coal. People in the end are getting so they don't want to go in to work any more.
The older element - boys that have given perhaps 20 or 25 years of their life to the coal industry - remember the bad times and remember the good times. Now it's bad times again they're thinking maybe now is the time to get out, thinking if I don't get another job soon I'll end up unemployed for the rest of my life. There's not many miners over 50 years of age in South Wales now.
Then you've got the diversity of men working in the collieries in South Wales now - they come in from far and wide. Tower colliery is probably the most cosmopolitan pit in the country now!
They've arrived at Tower colliery from as far as the Llynfi valley in the West to Maesteg to Gwent in the East. Now there's men probably be coming over from Oakdale collieries, Marine collieries. They are travelling vast distances to get to work. have a meeting..
South Wales is now down to something in the region of 4,000 miners. There are probably more teachers now in South Wales than miners. Prior to the strike there were twenty six or twenty seven thousand miners in South Wales.
So of course NUM membership is dwindling rapidly. It's going to come to the point that South Wales is not going to have a president. At the moment they have to pay a General Secretary out of their own funds. If it drops below 4,000 we'll have one rep on the National Executive and that'll be about it.
There's no major organisation now as far as the left caucus is concerned. After the loss of Cynheidre and other collieries that were involved, Tower now seems to be the only one leit.
The left caucuses in South Wales have died the same sort of death as the joint lodges in the Cynon Valley. There's only Tower colliery left that was taking part in the joint lodges.
There are no UDM pits in South Wales. Margam is supposed to be organised now around the UDM, but whether or not it will be, we won't know. It'll be ten years before Margam gets any coal out of the ground anyway.
The feeling of most rank and file members in South Wales now seems to be that they don't want the UDM. I still don't think we should sit with the UDM, but it's a Catch-22. If the rank and file start telling you to sit with them then we'll have to think about it, but at the moment I don't even want to be in the same room as them.
Management are trying to bring down the hardcore that want to defend the industry, but what they're actually doing is whittling out those who wouldn't fight. The ones that are left are the ones who are prepared to fight to defend the industry. So it's working against them.
For example, I've been heartened to see how people have stuck together in the various disputes that have taken place. You've had a lot of sectional disputes in South Wales. Mostly it's over management's heavy-handedness where management are ruling by the sword, threatening people.
You've had sectional disputes where they've taken money off the boys. Management are being sent in from outside the area to do a job on us.
Just making grand pronouncements and then not following it up is no use at Where branches have turned around members who scabbed, getting them to make hefty donations to strike funds, etc, and the members who took the action think that is sufficient, then that is as good a way of strengthening the union as expulsion.
NALGO's leadership didn't like the decision - Alan Jinkinson, the union's deputy general secretary, immediately went to the press to say NALGO's NEC weren't bound by the decision.
Under the union's rules, he's right. But in the real world he's doing a great job for the left by cutting his own throat as a candidate for general secretary by refusing to take any notice of the views of delegates representing over half a million of NALGO's 750,000 members!
Activists in NALGO need to keep up the pressure and campaign to make NALGO a 'real union' , nol a staff association representing the views of top council officers. The pay strikes this year have been a huge step forward to doing that. Showing the 'free riders' that we're not going to carry them any more will help even more.
But if NALGO's NEC are slow off the mark about tackling anit-union laws they're quick at getting round to the lawyers when it comes to threatening to sue other unions!
Just before the start of the TUC congress this week, NALGO threatened legal action against the General Council for ruling a motion on restructuring the TUC's leadership out of order.
The NALGO motion is better than the General Council's — it provides for a more democratic way of electing extra women members. But it's a pretty shameful way to go about it!
And, not surprisingly, NALGO's own conference never got a chance to discuss the motion that NALGO is proposing! Union democracy has to go all the way through our organisations and won't be secured by judges! Photo: John Smith (IFL)
During disputes in Tower colliery you've had men from all over sticking together. You've had men from Abernant collieries, Marine, Penrhiwceiber, Maerdy and everywhere. It's really heartening to me to see the boys are not going to be walked over. They will stick together - that nucleus is still there.
----- pull-quotes -----
Thomas, a miner at Tower colliery, South Wales, told Socialist