Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unholy alliance against science

Socialist Organiser no. 414, 7 September 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 825 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

COLUMN Research on human embryos has been a topic Lof much debate, much of it ill-informed.

In Britain, such research is now banned after 14 days, at which point embryos normally implant into the mother's womb, ending their independent phase. This point was chosen for largely emotional reasons.

Now, in Germany, a law is about to be debated which will make embryo research a criminal oftence, as well as making in vitro fertilisation even more onerous for the women who need it.

A particularly unsavoury feature of the campaign to draft this law has been the nature of the coalition pushing it. This ranges from anti-abortionists, conservatives and some religious groups, to some feminists, the Greens and the Social Democratic party (SPD, the German equivalent of the Labour Party).

Rightly or wrongly, any debate about research on human embryos is inevitably charged with emotion. It is easy to forget that such research has helped alleviate infertility and perhaps may help prevent repeated miscarriage. It has also resulted in tests for some devastating genetic and congenital disorders and will no doubt result in tests for others. Many Germans justify their opposition to embryo research by referring to Nazi "eugenics" programmes, which involved sterilising those considered "inferior" , followed by experimentation and extermination.

Eugenics, the study of ways of 'improving" the "quality" of the human species, is a most dubious science since what one regards as an improvement depends largely on one's prejudices. The Americans also practised eugenics, thougn not gonferio far as exterminating the But, despite the impression given by the Greens, such practices are not planned by embryo researchers. Many want to carry out in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and find ways of making it more successful. Others are trying to find tests for foetal abnormalities and genetic disorders. Such research has already led to tests for Down's Syndrome, spina bifida and sickle cell anaemia. Tests for haemophilia, Huntington's chorea, Duchenne muscular dystrophy and cystic fibrosis would also be of incalculable value in preventing suffering and early The German draft law, soon to be debated in their parliament, ignores such possibilities, merely making a set of blanket prohibitions:

• It prohibits researchers from inserting genes into eggs or sperm. Presumably, the bill's supporters imagine that it might be possible to insert genes for intelligence, film star looks or obedience to authority.

Without doubt, these fears are misconceived. More likely would be the insertion of a working copy of a faulty gene to prevent a genetic disorder in the child resulting from the cell. It is extremely unlikely that it would be worth doing this but, it it were, I can't see why it should be illegal.

• It bans cloning of humans, taking a cell from an embryo and growing another embryo from it, genetically and, while it might be undesirable to have lots of identical people, I can't see why the law should threaten an identical twinmaker with prison.

• It prohibits research which will damage or destroy human embryos, regardless of the aims or merits of such research. This would presumably ban removal of a cell to test for a genetic disorder.

• It would make IVF considerably more difficult. Only five embryos could be produced at a time, all of which would have to be implanted immediately. Since the success rate is quite low, a woman would be likely to require several goes to become pregnant. At present, extra embryos are frozen for future use. Under the new law, the woman would have to undergo họrmone treatment and an operation for each batch of 5 eggs. In any case, only married couples would be eligible for IVF.

• It would be illegal to donate eggs or sperm (how do they propose to stop that?) or to become a surare opportunities for exploitation, but why banned? And why ban donations of eggs and sperm?

The proposed law in Germany will make criminals of scientists trying to reduce the scourge of genetic diseases and trying to alleviate the burden of unwanted infertility.

Incredibly, the Greens and the SPD don't think the draft law goes far enough! The Greens have already made common cause with the Christian Democrats in BadenWürttemburg against research on babies born dead. Now they want to ban IVF completely, while one SPD MP criticises the bill for not excluding the selection of offspring with desired characteristics, since a woman could choose to be inseminated by a particular consenting male. But ordinary fertile women can do this anyway. Why should women seeking IVE be treated diferently?

The fears behind this bill are largely groundless, but also behind the bill seems to be an assumption that an embryo of perhaps a tew dozen spherical cells is a human being. Surely the next logical step is a bill banning abortion. Where will the Greens and the SPD be then?

----- pull-quotes -----

rogate mother. I accept that sur- rogacy should be regulated as there

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 414

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →