Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The real history of World War Two

Socialist Organiser no. 414, 7 September 1989 · scan p. 6 · about 1,350 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Britain has fought many, many wars. Almost all have been wars of subjugation against oversaas paoples. One war seems different: the 1939-45 war in which Brita But why were strikers jailed in wartime Britain? Why were miners who struck at Battashanger, Kent, witch-hunted? Why was so much of Britain's war concerned with defending not Britain, but Britain's For sure the Nazis had to be fought. what was Britain's Tory government fighting for? Colin Foster looks at the and fascism.

After Germany was defeated in the First World War, the British, French and US left it ransacked, bled dry and stripped of its colonies. As a result, capitalism developed in Germany with even more severe crises than elsewhere, Which drove the German bourguisie first into fascism and then into war, to gain new territories and new markets.

It was joined by Japan, the latestdeveloping great capitalist power, which wanted to challenge the USEuropean monopoly of colonies and spheres of influence in the Far East.

The biggest imperialist powers, Britain and the USA, were not prepared to let Germany and Japan expand at their expense.

The Second World War was about the rival economic interests of the big international exploiters, not democratic or fascist ideology. Britain went to war to defend the military dictatorship in Poland, not Czech democracy.

Among the Allies were Chiang Kai-Shek's China and Vargas Brazil, both extreme right-wing regimes. The goveruments-in-exile! supported by the Allies were also often very right wing: for example.. the Greeks, the Yugoslavs and the Poles. South Africa, too, was on the supposedly 'democratic' side.

Italian fascism was courted by the British and Americans - "even when the issue of the war became certain" wrote Churchill, «Mussolini would have been welcomed by the Allies" - and the US made agreements with the Petain government and worked with the Petain administration in the French colonies in North Africa.

All this time, Britain was maintaining regimes of more or less open racist military dictatorship over hundreds of millions of peoples in its own colonies. And whatever your view of the economic base of Stalin's USSR, politically it differed from Nazi Germany, as Trotsky put it, "only in more unbridled savagery.

The Allies denounced the Nazi's slaughter of the Jews. Yet they themselves refused to admit Jewish refugees.

The war was not mainly a battle between democratic and fascist powers. The USA kept out of it until Japan attacked its bases in the Pacific in December 1941; both Britain and the USA refused to open a "Second Front' until June 1944.

Up to 1943 Britain did no more than defend itself against bombing and defend its interests in North Africa and Asia - and watch with secret glee as the German army despoiled and decimated the Soviet Union.

The Nazi forces were sometimes welcomed when they first entered the USSR. Workers, peasants, oppressed nationalities, battered and famished by Stalin's dictatorship, reckoned that the Nazis could not be worse.

The Nazi's wholesale racist massacres of civilians - in the first place Jews, but also others changed that. The USSR's resistance became bitter and stubborn.

20 million Russians — including seven million soldiers - died in the fought Nazi Germany.

control of the Suez Canal?

history war. American and British casualties were much smaller: 405,000 American and 375,000 British soldiers killed.

From 1943 it became clear that Germany would lose the war -mainly as a result of the resistance of the people of the USSR. Britain and America became interested in a more aggressive strategy — not so much to defeat fascism, or even to defeat Germany, as to gain themselves a good share of the spoils of victory and suppress the danger of revolutions following on the war.

The first example of this policy was Italy. In July 1943 the Fascist Grand Council and officers led by "(The Trotskyists]...

fought for the overthrow of Roosevelt by the American workers, of Churchill by the British workers, of Hitler by the German workers and of Stalin by the Soviet workers.

Marshal Badoglio overthrew Mussolini, Badoglio bargained for terms with both Germany and the Allies. He reached agreement with the Allies, but meanwhile the German army had seized most of Italy.

In the Allied-Badoglio controlled areas, all publications, meetings and political activity were banned. Resistance partisans were disarmed. and often imprisoned; the north, where the Resistance was strongest, was left in the hands of the German army. In Germany, too, after the power under Doenitz. The Doenitz government was soon disposed of for the sake of appearances, but 700,000 German troops were kept in military formation by the British for possible use against Russian forces. In many parts of Germany the British and Americans found that spontaneously-created workers? councils had taken over as Hitler's power collapsed. The councils were dissolved, trade union organisations were suppressed and a total ban was imposed on political activity.

There was the same sort of clash between the Anglo-American armies and working class anti-fascists in Belgium. In November 1944, the Belgian Resistance, defying their Stalinist leaders, refused to obey orders from the occupying forces to hand in their arms. The Resistance leaders re-established their control only after Belgian police, supported by British troops, had shot down demonstrators in the streets of Brussels.

In Italy, too, the working class resistance had been disarmed mainly through the efforts of the Communist Party - whose preaching of "anti-fascist unity" gained weight from the prestige of the USSR. After Italian CP leader Palmiro Togliatti returned to Italy from Moscow in April 1944, the CP gave full support to Badoglio and the monarchy.

In Greece, the CP was less directly under Moscow control - and the clash between the armed anti-fascist workers and peasants and the Allied armies reached the point of open war, despite all Stalin's efforts to sabotage the Resistance.

In October 1944, 23,000 British troops entered Greece. They came not to fight the German army, which was rapidly leaving Greece, but to suppress the ELAS Resistance militias which had effective control of the country.

The setbacks for fascism which demeratic gdd intentions the to the democratic Churchill, Roosevelt and Truman. Their causes were the partial refusal by the working class to be duped into 'anti-fascist' or anti-German unity with their bosses - and the economic recovery of capitalism.

The drive for freedom of the colonial peoples had become too powerful to be suppressed.

Despite Winston Churchill's vow that he would not preside over the dissolution of the British Empire, the old empires — for whose preservation the war had been fought did dissolve, over the next 20 or 30 years. But a new colonial empire was built.

Stalin provided vital aid to Britain and the US in stifling all social revolutionary movements throughout Europe after 1943. In and 1945 were 593,000. return, the Kremlin bureaucracy was allowed to grab new territories, revenues and power in Eastern Europe.

Some British socialists still say that it was, for all that, a better outcome than the victory of Hitler would have been.

Hitler's regime was more brutal than Roosevelt's. If you can see no options beyond Hitler's domination of the world or Roosevelt's domination of the world, then maybe it makes sense to opt for Roosevelt. But the revolutionary socialists active during the war - the Trotskyists — did see another option: the revolutionary overthrow of all the imperialist robbers.

They fought for the overthrow of Roosevelt by the American workers, of Churchill by the British workers, of Hitler by the German workers and of Stalin by the Soviet workers.

They pointed out that those who opt for apparently "lesser evils' within capitalism usually end up enduring not only those "lesser evils' but also the 'greater evils' — as the French workers suffered first the betrayals of the Popular Front, then the repression of the Nazis and Petain.

The Trotskyists earned themselves the hatred of all the imperialist powers and of the Stalinists too. But they were the only people

----- pull-quotes -----

he Second World War T wasn't about democracy

Anglo-American victory, a fascist government was initially kept in

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 414

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →