Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Day of action for framed-up prisoner

Socialist Organiser no. 414, 7 September 1989 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 2,250 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Sinn Fein aren't socialist trom real life? Or is it the other way round?

In June an American TV channel interrupted its soap 'General Hospital' to flash news of the Tiananmen Square massacre. There was a flood of letters of complaint.

"They don't rerun the soaps. If you miss something it's gone." And all for "stale news" , said the irate viewers.

Saturday 11 and Sunday 12 November Sheffield Polytechnic Students Union Pond St (opposite rail station) showing that the trade unions are "back in business' But more general sympathy for trade unions does not automatically translate into stronger union organisation. Another recent survey shows that union derecognition is accelerating.

Researcher Tim Claydon found 58 cases of derecognition in the last five years - but only 9 happened in 1984-6 and 49 in 1987-9.

ETTERS Thanks for your coverage of the Martin Foran case. We are planning a day of action calling for Martin's release on 11 September.

We want to link the call for Martin's release with the start of some serious campaigning around the issue of police framing. A press conference will be held which will hopefully involve one or two people who have recently been released from jail after recent police malpractice was exposed.

Also, some of the police evidence against Martin will be tested out. Part of their case against Martin was that they arrested him at Hurst St car park in Birmingham after holding a conversation with him. They then 'proceeded slowly' to Bradford St police station and recorded his coming into custody._ The police claim that Martin was stopped at Hurst St at 3.05pm on his way to plan a robbery with an alleged accomplice, and was booked into the station at 3.12pm. The police records, it later transpired, had been altered and the 3.12 time had been added later.

Martin maintains that he was arrested an hour earlier, on his way to see his lawyer. Martin's family want to show that the police falsified this record as the journey and the conversation they said took place could not have taken place within the span of seven minutes. The scene will be re-enacted in front of local media and timed.

In London there will be a picket of the Home Office calling tor Martin's release at the same time, starting at one o'clock, More information: for Birmngham, Martin Foran Defence Campaign, PO Box 7, Zebedees Cafe, 190 Alum Rock Rd, BirmIn the question of whether Socialists should talk to Sinn Fein (SO 412) I would like to make a few comments.

Socialists should of course discuss politics with both the Catholic and Protestant politicos on the rights and wrongs of the National Question in Ireland, but while doing so must not be seen to condone Nationalism."

We must use such discussions to further the cause of International Socialism not to give Nationalists and bigots respect or adoration for their prejudices.

The leaders of Sinn Fein should not have been invited to speak on a platform of a Socialist Conference as if they were Socialists or even left-wing. They should have been billed as Sinn Fein v Socialism, because giving them the credibility of Socialists puts the cause of Irish people back not forward.

There is no part of Socialism which says that one creed, religion or nationality is more important ingham 8, Tel: Rus, 021 327 1187.

For London: BCM/Foran, London WCIN 3XX. Tel: Louise, 01-274 0370.

For other areas: Mike Shankland, 13 East Mount Rd, York YO22BD. Tel: 0904 647253.J Mike Shankland York than another, and that I believe distinguishes it from Nationalism.

All political parties have something in common: the leaders are divorced from the rank and file. Gerry Adams is therefore not so important for Socialists to talk with compared to the working class rank and file within the party (whose numbers may or may not be small).

Let's take the arguments for Socialism to the real workers instead of the reactionary self-appointed spokespeople for them. Do we talk to Kinnock in the Labour Party or the rank and file members? I see great parallels.

Patrick Murphy's statement that Sinn Fein are among those working for a just settlement in Ireland is appalling - Catholic domination is not a just settlement, total equality is! To say "many are Socialist" is a great error and to describe them as "revolutionary Nationalists" is a prostitution of the English language When you study their overall Christopher Barnes Newcastle

Scan page 5

Martin Thomas discusses the prospects for the Solidarnosc-led government in Poland Only Solidarnose in union with the Catholic Church has enough spiritual power to convince the people that patience is necessary and that hardships will pay off in the end," says Josef Ruszar, former personal secretary to Poland's new Prime Minister, Tadeusz Mazowiecki.

The comment is an index both of the disarray, discrediting and demoralisation of Poland's ruling class, and of the real meaning of Solidarnosc's move into a coalition government with the Stalinist United Workers' Party (PUWP).

Poland's rulng bureaucracy is in a mess. Its foreign debt to Western banks stands at $39 billion. This imposes a strain on the economy similar to that which many Latin American countries have suffered since 1982.

Prices are running out of control. In July they were 85% higher than a year previously. Production is dwindling. Fuel, energy, and several other major industries are turning out 12 or 11 percent less than a year ago. Meat deliveries are 20 per cent down.

Demoralised bureaucrats and managers try to push exhausted, alienated. ill-fed and ill-housed workers into increased production. They fail; production dwindles; inefficiency increases; the economy spirals downwards.

In 1988, great strike waves warned the bureaucracy that its attempts to crush Solidarnosc had not worked. The bureaucrats tried a political gamble. They legalised Solidarnosc and called quarter-free elections.

The gamble failed. The election results were a crushing defeat for the Stalinists. Soidarnosc won every freely contested seat bar one. The PUWP won none. Many of its leaders even failed to win uncontested seats, by failing to get 50% of the vote has pushed the bureaucrats into a further gamble - bringing Solidarnose into a coalition government. Generally, the PUWP leaders have little use for Marxism, but like any practical politician they have kept a Marxist view of the state when proposing the terms of the coalition. Solidarnosc can have the parliamentary majority and the Prime Minister's job, but the PUWP insists on keeping control of the core of the state, the army and the police.

As we go to press there is still haggling over who will get what ministries, but it looks as if a coalition will be formed.

Not only the bureaucrats' desperation, but also the evolution of the Solidarnose leadership, made the coalition possible.

In 1981 Solidarnose called for a *Self-Managed Republic" The details of this weren't clear, but the broad drift was - an economy regulated by workers' control and democratic planning, rather than by state-monopoly bureaucracy or private profit.

Defeat in 1981 drove the movement back. As martial law relaxed, the activity of the rank and file grew less fast than the links of the Solidarnosc leaders with Church dignitaries and Western bigwigs.

Lech Walesa is no longer an unemployed electrician living in a cramped high-rise flat. He is world statesman with a comfortable house in a posh suburb. When Solidarnosc negotiated with the government in 1980 thousands of workers watched suspiciously on television. Now all the deals are done in private.

The Solidarnosc leaders now call for the rule of private profit in Poland. Unemployment? Inequality? The harsh inhumanity of the free market? All necessary prices to be paid for efficiency, they say. And on that programme they have agreement with PUWP leaders, who find that bureaucratic command no longer shifts the Polish economy, and have turned to market mechanisms as the alternative.

Solidarnosc's main economic adviser now is a Harvard professor, Jeffrey Sachs (the PUWP tried to do hi Sachs, Claim to and then economic plan for Bolivia, which reduced inflation from 40,000 per cent to 15 per cent - and pauperised and almost destroyed the Bolivian working class. Wages were cut by 40 per cent in little over a year. 19,000 tin miners were sacked, and unemployment rose to 30 per cent. Workers who lost their jobs ended up growing coca plants for the US cocaine trade as the only way to survive.

Sachs says that Poland needs shock treatment. Slow, piecemeal moves towards a free market are no good. He wants the scrapping of all trade barriers and exchange controls, and privatisation of the economy, all at once. He says this will produce "six months of chaos" then recovery. And it must be done now, while the new Solidarnosc Prime Minister's credit with the people still stands high.

Despite support for Sachs from both the PUWP and Solidarnosc, it must be doubtful whether such a complete change to a private-profit economy is possible peacefully. A lot of PUP bureaucrats have been bailing out and transforming themselves into private capitalists, but there must remain a substantial core of the bureaucracy whose class privilege depends on their position in the central state machine and that state's heavy control the economy. Will they give it up peacefully?

Even if they are restrained by the interests of the central state bureaucrats - and Mazowiecki has declared that he will work with the nomenklatura, not try to dismantle Walesa wants to tie solidarnosc y market reforms, factory closures the workers let him get away wit it - the Solidarnose leaders and the PUWP will certainly attack the working class, with unemployment and high prices. The PUWP's calculation must be that they can use the Solidarnosc leaders' credit with the workers to get such measures through, then throw aside Solidarnosc, its credit exhausted, like a squeezed lemon.

The PUP's plans may well go wrong. The workers will fight back and the bureaucracy itself may split and consume itself in conflicts between rival factions. But Walesa and his friends are betraying and misleading the Polish labour movement.

Already Solidarnosc's new "statesmanlike" pro-capitalist line has kept its membership down to two million - one-fifth of what it was in 1981, and much less even than the government-sponsored union organisation, OPZZ, which has seven million members.

Walesa's promise of the Farming Ministry to the Peasant Party (long a stooge party for the PUWP, now showing some autonomy) has raised the prospect of a split by Rural Solidarnosc, the farmers' wing of Solidarnosc. Walesa's call for a no-strike agreement to accompany the new government's economic programme must raise the prospect of workers' splits from Solidarnosc.

Such splits would gladden the PUWP. They would weaken Solidarnosc and free the Solidarnosc deputies in parliament from working-class pressure. They would isolate the militants from the Jaruzelski's programme of nd unemployment. But will vocating that Solidarnose go into opposition and defend wages and conditions is adequate. Socialists should consider some such slogan as "Break the coalition! All power to Solidarnosc!"

This would mean demanding of the elected Solidarnosc deputies that they declare themselves the sovereign elected representatives of the Polish people, convene the *Self-Management Parliament" demanded by Solidarnose in 1981, and call for workers to take over the factories, offices, mines and shipyards.

The programme of a workers' government in Poland would have to start with dismantling the nomenklatura - the system whereby thousands of top jobs are reserved for PUP members appointed by the PUWP machine. Top officials, managers, and army and police chiefs, should be elected, and paid only workers' wages. The army and police hierarchies should be replaced by reorganising these bodies as democratic militias.

Economic reconstruction must start with decent conditions for the workers. A network of workers' control should be set up, monitoring production and distribution, keening precise accounts, curbing privilege and corruption, and directing goods and services where they are needed. More scope for free markets and small private traders is probably necessary in the transition from state-monopoly bureaucratism to a self-managed economy, but it must stop short of production and distribution will enable the Polish workers to decide democratically which enterprises are indeed obsolete and needing in be replaced by more modern dustries. A big programme of training and re-training at trade union wages, and a drive for needed public works like house-building will ensure that workers are not thrown onto the scrap-heap of unemployment.

A workers' government carrying out such measures should appeal to workers everywhere else, especially the Eastern Bloc, to show solidarity, to oppose any military intervention against Poland, and to follow the Polish workers' exampie. It could appeal to workers in the West to force our governments to decree the cancellation of Poland's crushing debt burden.

Such are the policies that socialists should argue for. Obviously the present leaders of Solidarnose has no intention of doing anything like that. At present, there is not even any pressúre on them from the workers to do anything like that. The workers probably are not as keen as Lech Walesa on Jeffrey Sachs' ideas, but after 40 years of being told that socialism is state-monopoly bureaucratic rule, few of them have a clear alternative.

But - depending on what Polish socialists do, and depending on what help we in the West can give them - that could change quickly in the turmoil of the coming months. Demands will become more

----- pull-quotes -----

conference the trade unior left in the trade union Socialist Conference

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 414

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →