Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Digger' hidden hidden depths

Socialist Organiser no. 414, 7 September 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 790 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

1o can beiteve, witnessing the thousands of / East Germans fleeing across the border into Hungary en route to the West, that East Germany is any kind of socialist country?

For 27 years, East Germans were shot trying to cross the Berlin Wall. Now, as Hungary has dismantled the protective fence along its borders with Austria, providing a way of escape, East Germans are flocking to get out.

What they will find in the West will be another story. The people of Eastern Europe, oppressed by Orwellian bureaucratic regimes that call themselves socialist, often conclude that Western capitalism -with its democratic institutions - is a far better place to live. On average, it probably is.

Just how bad the East Germany system is for the working class was shown dramatically a couple of years ago, when the normally sluggish West German trade unions protested vehemently against the use of East German contract labour on jobs in West Germany.

The union officials complaint was not that these workers from a "socialist" state brought revolutionary ideas or "unrealistically" high expectations with them. Just the opposite! They complained that the East German workers had no union representation and worked in conditions that no West German trade unionist would accept, thus undermining the conditions of the West German workers. East Germany is not socialist, never has been. It is, like the West, a system where a minority ruling class exploits the workers for its own profit.l West Germany, like the West generally, is also a land of relentless profit-seeking, exploitation, mass unemployment, housing shortages, slums, misery, racism and witchhunts. The East German refugees will learn that in time, and some will conclude that the answer is no illuEast German workers flee Stalinism sions in either East or West, but a struggle for workers' liberty East and West.

Hungary's border decision is part of a general policy of liberalisation - that is, extension of the market and closer integration with Western Europe.

Hungary has been the pioneer of Gorbachev-type perestroika for many years. It scrapped central economic plan directives in 1968. While the official government policy is not to encourage people escaping from East Germany, the Hungarian media is full of stories of Hungarians helping Germans to cross the frontier. The Hungarian people, it seems, are wholeheartedly sympathetic.

The German refugees are another dramatic symbol of the decay of the Eastern European systems. The new Polish government, and the fierce nationalist explosion in the USSR itself indicate a deal pert of truly historic importance: the collapse of the Russian empire.

Gorbachev is trying to hold it together by pragmatism. But the crisis of the whole system is visibly deepening almost every day. And for Gorbachev and the various Eastern European despots that depend on him, there simply is no answer to their problems.

They can't continue to bottle up all the tensions in their societies without risking a huge political explosion. But each step they take towards reform only creates new problems, unleashes new forces, and runs new risks.

Socialists should support the right of the East Germans or whoever else to leave their country and live in Western Europe. We would prefer East German workers and intellectuals to stay in their countries and fight their bureaucratic oppressors. But they have the right to leave.

And we should press home the lesson, that these systems have nothing at all to do with democratic, working-class socialism.

Rupert Murdoch, as the hard-nosed, moneygrabbing, union-busting, multi-media mogul, I can just about stomach.

But Rupert Murdoch's new-found persona as philosopher/ moralist of the media is simply too much.

I refer, of course, to the Digger's now famous McTaggart lecture at the Edinburgh Festival. Did he really believe all that stuff he was spouting, about the need for a more politically independent and investigative media? Can he have been serious when he held up Watergate and Irangate as the jourmalistic models he aspires to?

Admittedly, the Digger was talking more about than newspapers (though it seems to have escaped his notice that it was the American press and not the TV that exposed Watergate and Irangate), but even so, the spectacle of the owner of the Sun and the Sunday Times berating the ITV and BBC for their excessively cosy relationship with the government was a bit rich, to put it mildly...

By contrast, Daily Telegraph editor Max Hastings' recent appearance on Channel 4's 'Three of a Kind' was refreshingly candid. Questioned about the Telegraph's notorious Page 3 where sexual innuendo, scandal and other forms of naughtiness are dressed up as •court reports), Hastings admitted: "It's basically News of the World stuff, but presented in a style more acceptable Lou could say it stands in the pros 1 supposi

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 414

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →