[Workers discuss tactics in the fight against the…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Workers discuss tactics in the fight against the racist state's South African liberation movement.
And not just in the liberation movement. Everyone is talking about negotiations - FW De Klerk, Thatcher, Bush and Kohl, Mikhail Gorbachev and the leaders of the frontline states.
But a lot of the talk about talks is just talk.
There is a vast gap that exists between the negotiating position of the liberation movement and that of the The ANC and its allies have put down a series of conditions for negotiations that the state will find it very difficult to meet.
They include:
• the release of political • the unbanning of banned organisations;
• unconditional return of exiles;
• withdrawal of troops from the townships;
• an end to the State of Emergency;
• the scrapping or suspension of repressive laws.
For the ANC the aim of negotiations is the transformation of South Africa into a united democratic and non-racial country.
FW De Klerk is not about to accept those conditions, never mind that aim. It would mean the end of National Party rule and white privilege.
De Klerk wants to draw sections of the liberation movement into a political settlement that stops far short of majority rule in an undivided state. He wants group rights and representation (ie, code for a white veto) and some kind of consensusbased multi-racial executive.
It would be suicide for the ANC to accept such a hollow offer. Even if the leadership were prepared to (which is highly unlikely), the ranks of the liberation movement would not. So a negotiated transfer of power is not round the corner.
The motives of the two sides are somewhat different.
De Klerk wants to take some of the international pressure off his government. As the journal Work in Progress has argueg, he is more interested in negotiating the rescheduling of South Africa's foreign debt than the transfer of power. That is why he is prepared to make limited but real concessions like the release of Mandela and the de facto legalisation of the ANC.
The drive for negotíations anti-union laws represents something else for the liberation movement. In part it reflects external pressures from the frontline states and the USSR.
Gorbachev desperately wants to disengage from Southern Africa. Some of his advisors have even gone so far as to advise the ANC to accept some form of white veto. The vast amounts of Eastern Bloc financial and military aid to the ANC give Gorbachev immense leverage over the movement. To keep that support coming, the ANC must at least appear to be prepared to negotiate.
But the ANC has its own reasons, too, to do with the crisis in liberation movement strategy following the defeat of the township revolt of 1984-6.
Negotiations and the struggle to force the regime to negotiate have become a panacea thus abolishing the need for some serious strategic thinking In the mid-'80s the ANC tail-ended and then managed to ride on the back of a spontaneous working-class upsurge. It responded to events rather than really initiating them. Its strategy, to the extent that it had one, was to Make the townships ungovernable'.
The 'people' were to create the maximum possible chaos on the ground so that the state would be forced to the negotiating table to talk to the 'people's leaders'. Those who questioned this strategy ran the risk of being labelled 'enemies of the people' The powerful trade union movement ended up filing in behind the populist slogans while attempting to give them a working-class content. In fact, the most inspiring events of '84-'86 were those moments when working-class organisation was used to channel and focus the township revolt, like the Alexandra Action Committee led by Moses Mayekiso — a model of democratic and popular working-class organisation.
Nevertheless, the revolt was defeated. But the lessons of that defeat have not been assimilated.
The first lesson is that it's wrong to play with insurrectionary slogans without preparing seriously for insurrection - and not even in the heady days of 1985 did the ANC leadership seriously consider deploying their guerrillas in the township in any numbers.
The second point is that it's impossible to give a working-class content to a strategy dreamed up elsewhere to service the interests of another class, which is what the left in the liberation movement tend to do. For the leadership of a liberation movement which sees the workers as a battering ram to be used to knock down the doors of power for themselves, treating the workers and youth of the townships as a stage army is quite natural. For socialists it's anathema.
Socialists and trade unionists in South Africa now run the risk of repeating this same error in a different form by attempting to give a working-class content to an agenda of negotiations set elsewhere.
It should be possible for the workers themselves to take the initiative and advance a socialist alternative.
Firstly, socialists are not against negotiations as such, whether between trade unions and capital, or liberation movements and pressor states. What we are against is negotiations over the heads of the people and outside of their control. Premature denunciations of betrayal will not gain a hearing for socialism but only isolate those socialists who go in for it further.
The left - in particular the left associated with the non-racial independent unions - has advocated winning partial demands in the here and now to strengthen the position of the working class. The present day trade union movement was built in such a way. Extracting concessions from the state and capital was denounced by the ANC a few years ago as 'economism' and 'reformism' . What they were criticising was not the idea of negotiating with the state or capital, but the idea that the union should dare to fight for limited concessions without the permission of the nationalist politicians.
The workers' movement should use the current climate of negotiations to advance a Strategy of fighting for reforms like a minimum wage, upgrading of townships, repeal of the repressive anti-union laws etc, which could fuse with the reviving industrial and political militancy of the black workers to turn defence into offence.
And, finally, the workers" movement needs to define closely its basic goals. Moses Mayekiso, the NUMSA general secretary, has pointed towards a definition of those goals and the relationship between them and negotiations.
"We must go to the negotiating table from a position of power, with all our organisations - they have to be unbanned first.
It will be a battle to even go to the negotiating table. We will have to pressurise them (the state).
In all class struggles you will find people who are enemies but who pretend to be our friends and have their own tactics to buy the working If we want to undercut the power of the state we might be forced to make tactical alliances with other classes and other people closely linked to some state structures. But in doing so we must not compromise our principles.