Nicaragua ten years after
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Support for tie Sand nistas wi"not continue if poverty goes (Part 1 was in the last issue)
Progress was largely halted •by the outbreak of the war the US fought by proxy against liberated Nicaragua. The US strategy was that of low-intensity warfare, in which political and economic pressure are used to support a military assault by proxy forces.
The economic and human costs of the war have been huge, and between 1983 and 1987 Nicaragua survived on a siege basis, with massive military spending and the US. organised economic blockade preventing any recovery taking place. Even now the ruined economy continues to cause havoc to the possibilities of post-revolutionary Nicaragua.
The collapse of the Nicaraguan economy intensified throughout 1987, and by early 1988 inflation was running at an annual rate of 2,000%. An economic package was introduced in February 1988, which included a change-over of currency aimed at the momentary holdings of speculators and the Contras.
Large incentives for producers were included in the package, which also introduced the protection ot wages through a consumer price index. The anti-speculator measures were popular and led to demonstrations against speculators and attempts by UNAG farmers to sell directly to the public rather than through middle men.
These popular mobilisations didn't survive the continued fall of real wages, however, and unemployment rose to 300,000.
In June 1988 a second, more radical, economic package was launched. Wages and prices were deregulated, neighbourhood basicgoods stores (which had provided essential items at fixed costs) wound down, incentives to large producers increased, and the currency was devalued.
The net effect of this austerity programme was a further decrease in the living standards of workers and peasants, to the benefit of private capitalists. The package was similar to those imposed by the IF, but since Nicaragua is not a paid up member of the World Bank the usual IMF loan cannot follow.
The transfer of resources from small to large producers consequent on this package was an illogical move since the former are considerably more effective competitors in the export market, and more efficient domestic producers.
In early 1988, for example, milk came at 20 cordobas a litre from the small producers, at 30 cordobas from the large producers, and at 40 cordobas from the state projects. Similar considerations apply to sugar, cotton and tobacco production.
Before the June economic reforms the informal economy of Managua accounted for three quarters of household income, ie formal wages only provided one quarter, and most people had informal ways of obtaining goods and services. The informal economy was essential since salaries were not adequate to cover a minimum diet.
After June this informal economy dwindled; yet for some people now the cost of travelling to and from work is greater than the wages they earn each day.
The conservative business leader Ramiro Gurdian, a long-time bitter critic of the Sandinistas, announced that he supported and applauded" the austerity measures and did more to harm the popular image of the FSLN by this declaration than he had ever done by his condemnations. The proSandinista magazine Envio declared that there should be a "more equal charge for the right to be Nicaraguan"
While the main effect of the June measures was to encourage large private producers, shortly afterwards the government nationalised the San Antonio Sugar Refinery, which had fallen to a very low level of productivity. This reflects the pragmatic adaptation of policy by the Sandinistas which has been a trademark of their administration.
The decline in living standards for the workers did not pass without resistance. After the February reforms a construction workers' strike, led by a union affiliated to the PSN, pressed demands for higher wages and the abolition of newly imposed work regulations.
A mechanics' union, affiliated to the Maoist Nicaraguan Communist Party, also went on strike, and the ilegar. or declared both actions GROOS Workers in the CST, the Sandinista federation of unions, scabbed on the strike and physically attacked strikers.
Similar scenarios were played out in the private Tona brewery, at a sack factory, and at the San Antonio Sugar Refinery. Strikers not intimidated back work were fired, and Jaime Wheelock, the minister of agrarian reform, TalI -nounced that 'we will chop off the hands of those who raised the strike banner", Regional FSLN committees put up notices saying that strikers are "deserters from the workers' front and patriotism" and "deserve the weight of the law and the hatred of the people".
In October 1988 Hurricane Joan de-rastated Nicaragua in a way even the Contras hadn't managed. $800 million dollars virtually one year's GNP — of damage to the inirastructure was done, nearly 200,000 people were rendered homeless, and a large proportion of banana, maize and rice crops were destroyed.
The Sandinistas' rapid and energetic response to the tragedy, in sharp distinction from Somoza's money-grubbing reaction to the 1972 earthquake, gained much popular approval, as did the large and quick Cuban aid efforts. Despite the huge effort from the FSLN and Cuba, the hurricane further accelerated the economic decline.
In January 1989 the latest batch of economic measures were announced by Daniel Ortega, signalling a continuation on the road to a mixed economy. The abandonment of land redistribution, a decrease in public sector employment, and the freeing of banks from controls were the most important new measures.
Drastic reductions in numbers of government employees - including the army, education and health services - increased unemployment, and wages fell even further. In continuing with the tradition of pragmatism, the government reversed its policy on land nationalisation in June when three large farms which had been deliberately kept unproductive were taken over.
A poll carried out in Managua in mid-1988 showed that only 27% of the respondents "identified" with the FSLN, but their nearest rival the Liberals, received only 3% of such support. Elections will be held February 1990 under the new electoral law, which will not affect the standing of the already existing parties but will make it almost impossible to form new parties. It seems likely that the Sandinistas will on growing obtain the largest numbers of votes cast, but abstentions will be numerous.
If living standards for the peasants and workers do not improve the Sandinistas will not be able to rely on their current level of support for very much longer. Opinion polls show that while the war against the Contras is seen to be one reason for the dismal economic situation, government mismanagement is thought to have compounded this.
With the war virtually over, anti-American hatred will wane and the Sandinistas will be seen as more and more to blame.
The combination of US aggression, the hurricane, and economic mismanagement has reversed some of the gains of the revolution, with education, health and social services suffering severe setbacks. IIliteracy is reputedly on the increase, sporadic cases of polio have appeared, and there are diarrhoeal disease and malaria outbreaks.
The 250,000 people who turned out for the tenth anniversary demonstrated continued popular Wednosdey 30 August Cardiff SO: 'China: Tiananmen Square and after'. Speaker John O Mahony. The Comet, Moira St, 7.30 Wedesaday 30 Saptambs. Manchester SO: "Why we defend the French Revolution'. • Speaker Martin Thomas. Manchester Town Hall, 7.30 Wednesday 30 August South London SO: 'Where now for socialists?' The Two Eagles, Austra St, 7.30 Sunday 3 September Socialist Movement 'National Poll Tax Coordinating Meeting'. PCL, Marylebone Rd, London W1, 11.00 Thursday 7 Saptambar Canterbury SO: 'Gorbachev the Great?' Speaker Geoff Ward. Canterbury Tales pub, 7.00 Sunday 10 S-11-North London SO: 'Stalin's port has decreased since the first anniversary when over 600,000 - one quarter of Nicaragua's population — celebrated in the Plaza de la Revolucion. This is reflected in the decline in the mass organisations, which are no longer functioning in many areas.
An independent report conducted for the FSLN in June indicated that Nicaragua's national income was now the lowest in the Western hemisphere, $300 per capita. It is even lower than the $330 in Haiti, traditionally the poorest country in that region. Soviet economic aid delegations are reportedly holding talks with rightwing private business men, as a way of avoiding having to deal with the allegedly inefficient Sandinista organisations.
The next year is clearly going to be crucial in determining the future course of the Nicaraguan revolution. Whilst it is possible that the US will reactivate the Contras if the February elections do not produce the desired result, it is more likely that internal problems will come to the fore.
Some observers have suggested over the years that confronted by Face the Workers'. Angel & Crown, Upper St, N1, 7.30 Thursday 14 Steah, Leeds SO: 'Labour's Policy Review": Speaker Alan Johnson. Coburg pub, 7.30 Friday 15 Scre "Labour's Socialist Alternative'. Pre-conference rally at Sheffield City Poly, Totley Hall Lane, Sheffield, 7.30. Organised by CLPs Conference and supported by Campaign Group. Saturday 16 Saptambar Pre-Conference Briefing for CLP delegates. Shetfield City Poly, Totley Hall Lane, Sheffield, 10.30. Contact CLPs Conference, Lol Duffy, 11 Egremont Prom, Merseyside L44. Sunday 17 Spr-tNorth London SO: "In Defence of the French Revolution'. Angel & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Monday 18 St-t.
Isaac Deutscher Memorial Lecture: The Importanca of being Marxist' by Boris Kagarlitsky. New Theatre, LSE, 7.30 Sunday 24 SEtNorth London SO: "Solidarity with China's workers and students'. imperialism on one side, and the power of the mass organisations on the other, the FSLN would be forced to go beyond its intentions and expropriate the bourgeoisie. This now seems increasingly unlikely, as does the opposing notion that Nicaragua is moving towards (or already represents) Stalinism. The mixed economy, and an attempted advance to a breed of 'parliamentary democracy' (with continued FSLN victory), is the road the Sandinistas will continue to follow.
In May Daniel Ortega told his Swedish hosts: "we are social democrats". The tragedy of this is that his wing of the FSLN would like it to be true (the FSLN declares it aspires to be a mainstream member of the Socialist International), and don't recognise the impossibility of building social democracy in a poor part of Central America, against the huge might of US aggression.
Nicaragua's fate lies with that of Central America. Developments within the region may lead to a fresh assault on US domination. If this happens then the Nicaraguan revolution may again begin to go forward.
Angel & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Sunday 1 October North London SO: 'Social Democracy goes Thatcherite'. Angel & Crown, Upper St, 7.30 Sunday 1 October Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign: "Sandinista Sprint', sponsored run and dance for Nicaragua. Brockwell Park, Brixton, SW9, 11.00. Details from NSC, 23 Bevenden St, Londor N1 6BH (253 0246)
Saturday 7 October Socialist Lecturers' Alliance: NATFHE 1989 Pay Claim Action Conference'. New Imperial Hotel, Birmingham. Details from Barry Lovejoy, 25 Philip Victor Rd, Birmingham B20 Friday 3 November History Workshop Conference 1989. Salford University. Contact Helen Bowyer, 51 Crescent, Salford M5 4UX (061-736 3601)
Saturday 11 November Socialist Conference 'Building the Left in the Unions' - Sheffield Poly Student Union, Pond St, 10.30. Credentials E6 waged, E4 unwag: from Socialist Conference, 9 Polar St, London W1
----- pull-quotes -----
Maureen Tucker, just back from Nicaragua, continues her report on ten years of the Sandinista revolution.
support for the FSLN, but that sup- ACTIVISTS DIARY