How many frame-ups?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
For tes West Midlands ollowing the disbandment police's Serious Crimes Squad, official plans are to reinvestigate cases dealt with by the squad - but only back to 1986.
This conveniently will not include the case of Martin Foran, framed by the West Midlands force for robbery on two occasions, and now chronically ill in Frankland Jail and_being denied medical treatment.
It will also rule out the Birmingham Six, and the four men jailed in 1979 for the killing of Carl Bridgewater on very suspect evidence.
The police investigation will have to include Detective Sergeant Michael Hornby, named by the Guardian as one of the officers facing disciplinary hearing for the attempted framing of Ronald Bolden. Hornby is also named by Chris Mullin in his 'Error of Judgement' work on the Birmingham Six as being behind the obtaining of a 'confession' from Hughie Gallaghan of the Birmingham Six.
Furthermore, Hornby can be linked to the conviction of the Carl Bridgewater men. One of the prosecution witnesses against them was a local criminal, Anwar "Spider' Mohammed, who had worked closely with Hornby. (See Paul Foot's book, Murder at the Farm').
Martin Foran named Hornby as long ago as 1983 as one of the officers behind his first false conviction. Douglas Hogg admitted to Chris Mullin recently that Hornby had been the subject of 'many' complaints over the years, though only once had he faced disciplinary hearing, and that was in 1980.
The inquiry should also deal with Detective Inspector Paul Matthews, who as a detective constable at the time of the Birmingham pub bombings of 1974 claimed to have got a statement from Paddy Hill of the Birmingham Six, one Paddy Hill has always denied. Martin Foran named Matthews as the main officer behind his second false conviction — and one who was also involved in the first framing. Socialist Organizar stands for workers' liberty East and West. We aim to help organiss the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitaliam with workng class serialiam.
We want public cams stip of the major entarprissa and a planned economy under ESIUBISICRIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post. Rates (UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for year.
Name.
Address.
Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E..... Send to: Socialist Organises, PO Box 823. London SE15 4NA Paul Matthews was a Detective Constable in 1977 and had risen to the rank of Detective Inspector by 1984. He has gone missing from the force since 1986, following allegations of pyramid selling.
It is hard to predict exactly how the whole affair will turn out. Possibly a few officers will be made examples of, while many others will escape notice. Perhaps Hornby will be scapegoated.
The disbandment of the squad was forced by a growing weight of evidence. There had been a whole wave of allegations of police malpractice, especially in altering statements which suspects have made in police custody.
In June Reginald Bolden, who had spent 22 months on remand, was acquitted of robbery when it transpired that a 'confession' he was meant to have made had been altered by detectives. In July Keith Parchment, who had been sentenced to five years imprisonment in 1987, had his conviction quashed.
Again it was found that a confession' he had signed had been altered by detectives.
Chief Constable Geoffrey Dear has confirmed that a number of key documents concerning a number of disputed convictions have gone missing. The Independent covered Reginald Bolden's case and, in an article printed on 23 June, gave details of eleven cases of police malpractice in recent years which could be traced back to members of the Serious Crimes Squad. Clare Short MP has said that she has received letters from 50 prisoners and ex-prisoners alleging that evidence against them had been contrived and altered by police officers from this force.
But the police will oversee the inquiry into the activities of their fellow officers. So far four officers have faced disciplinary hearings, but the police are quite simply setting the terms of any investigation themselves.
Meanwhile the prison system is using its usual tricks on Martin Foran. At first they said that Martin could stay at Frankland Jail and receive treatment from an outside specialist. The governor admitted to me and Valerie Foran that Martin's health had suffered from being moved around all the time. As soon as Martin finds a specialist to treat tary much let than workers' We want the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected repressntativas recallable at any time, and an end to bursaucrats' and managars' p-i-ilag37 Smaliam can never be built in one country alone. The workars in every country have more in cemmon with workara in other countriss than with their own espitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support natical liberation struggles and workars' struggles a-orldwide, including the struggle of
----- pull-quotes -----
WHERE WE STAND