Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Lebanon is falling apart

Socialist Organiser no. 413, 31 August 1989 · scan p. 6 · Clive Bradley · about 1,050 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The religious divisions in Lebanon were enshrined in a political system, called the National Pact, in 1943.

Seats in the Assembly were allocated to religious groups supposedly in proportion to their numbers.

Particular positions were reserved for repicocutatives of a particular religious community. For example, the President was to be a Maronite Christian.

Much praised as a paragon of democratic virtues by Western liberal commentators, this system was in reality a farce.

It guaranteed for the Christians a majority of six to five and discriminated against the various Muslim communities which by the 1960s were a majority of the population.

By deciding politics on a religious-sectarian basis, it reinforced society's sectarian divide. Political parties on non-sectarian lines were more or less impossible.

Traditional leaders vied with and allied with each other to maintain control over their respective communities.

Such control was organised in an elaborate system of patronage based on traditional family or clan lines, and reinforced by mafia-like gang leaders.

In this situation the Lebanese state was extremely weak and regularly broke down.

In 1958 US Marines intervened to protect the Maronite Christian government of Camille Chamoun who was eventually replaced by President Shihab. Shihab attempted to strengthen the state apparatus, largely by strengthening the secret police, the Deuxieme Bureau.

But with a weak state, real power tended to fall into the hands of various sectarian leaders.

The capitalist class itself spanned the religious divide, but its power depended on the preservation of the old traditional loyalties.

LEBANON/ HH Mediterranean Sea ISRAEL EGYPT /JORDAN Jounieh Mediterranean Bar Two main factors caused the collapse of this system. First were the internal contradictions, the extremes of social and political inequality upon which the system was based. There is no doubt that the civil war which got underway in earnest in 1975 was an expression, in a confused way, of the deep class divisions that exist in Lebanese society.

Lebanon was the financial centre of the Middle East, dominated economically by banks. Its beaches were the playground of the region's rich. Yet on the edges of Beirut were appalling slums known as the belts of misery". . Financial growth did not bring social equality.

Second was the presence of nearly a million Palestinian refugees, and in particular the Palestinian guerrilla movement based on those refugees.

The Cairo Accords in 1969 gave the guerrillas the right to possess arms and control their own camps and after 1970, when the Palestinian resistance was driven out of Jordan, Lebanon became the major base.

The resistance developed close links with some of the more radical mainly-Muslim Lebanese political groups that had been influenced by the rise of Arab nationalism after World War Two. These groups were trained by Palestinian guerBillas.

Politically, Lebanese society polarised on the issue of the Palestinian presence. The Christian Maronites tended to be opposed to it, many Muslims were in favour of it.

In addition, many of the social tensions were increased by an influx of Lebanese Shi'a Muslims fleeing the Israeli raids in the South.

By 1975 the economic crisis and social unrest were deepening.

The causes of the outbreak of violence included the suppression of a fishermen's strike in Sidon by the army, and shortly after, a revenge attack by Phalangists on a Palestinian bus. By July 1976 the situation had worsened to all-out civil war in which some 50,000 people were killBaalbek ed.

To maintain their political base, sections of the Muslim leadership identified with the revolt and attempted to gain control of it.

Amongst the Christians it was the Phalange who were most effectively seen to be defending Maronite independence, as they saw it, against pan-Arabism.

The Lebanese National Movement, founded at the peak of the Civil War, grouped together Arab nationalists, Communists, and right-wing organisations such as the Syrian Social Nationalist Party. So from the outset it had a sectarian overtone. By 1976 the LNM had dropped its secular anti-sectarian programme in the face of the communal degeneration of the conflict, from which it saw no way out.

The conflict had degenerated into a sectarian bloodbath. People were often shot only because their names betrayed their religion (the Maronites tended to have French first names as result of their historical connection to French colonialism).

Nevertheless, by 1976 the LNM was on the verge of partial victory. The neighbouring Syrian regime saw a victory for the LNM as dangerous possibility, a destabilisation that might provoke Israeli attack.

It intervened to curtail the LNM and the more radical Palestinian organisations. It did this first by proxy through the pro-Syrian Palestinian groups and then directly by occupying parts of Lebanon.

Lebanon had been rapidly divided between competing groups - an Israeli-dominated south, a Palestinian-dominated centralsouthern area, the Syriancontrolled east, and various areas under Maronite control.

This situation persisted until Israel's invasion of Lebanon in June 1982. Israel had been bombarding Lebanon in an effort to destroy Palestinian bases since 1968, and had launched a full-scale invasion in 1978. By 1982 Israeli leaders had decided that their only option was to smash up the guerrillas in Lebanon once and for all.

The invasion caused untold havoc, as the Israeli army swept up to Beirut, imposing a ruthless seige in order to starve the guerrillas into submission. Eventually, thousands of Palestinians agreed to leave Beirut and the siege was lifted. Shortly after, Israel allowed Phalangists into the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Chatilla, where they massacred thousands of unarmed Palestinians.

As Israel withdrew to the south, and a US-dominated 'multinational force' went in to 'protect' the Lebanese people (which it did by In an underground shelter in Beirut its past self. The current Maronite between Shi'as and Palestinians, nationalist government of General between these two Shia groups. Aoun, which came to power in a was the Shia militias that force military coup, represents a break Israel to reduce massively from the old factions (part of presence in the south of the count Aoun's philosophy is to unite the (ostensibly withdrawing, after ve Maronites, mainly against Syria). high casualties; in fact Israel co But perhaps the most striking dif- tinues to control the south by pro ference is the role played by and through frequent military i Lebanese Shi'a Muslims. In the cursions).

Aoun's anti-Syrian nationalist

----- pull-quotes -----

•Tripoli LEBANON

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 413

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →