What's wrong with Walesa's strategy?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
In Poland a coalition government is being formed in which the Stalinist organisation, the so-called Communist Party, will, for the first time in over 40 years, have only a minority of ministers.
The main other force in the government will be Solidarnosc, the political organisation based on the working class which has its origin in the great strike movement of August 1980 and the ten million strong free trade union which grew up between August 1980 and its suppression under martial law in December 1981.
This is the most important development in since the rise of Solidarnosc nine years ago.
To understand what is happening and put it in perspective we need to look at the origin of the Stalinist svstem in Poland and elsewhere in Eastern Europe. What is happening in Poland now has many parallels with what happened at the birth of Stalinist power in Eastern Europe in the mid '40s, except that the evolution may be in the opposite diretion, from Stalinist power and pervasive Stalinist state monopoly in society to capitalism - what Lech Walesa mistakenly calls the first ever journey from socialism to capitalism.
In 1944 Stalin's Russian army beat the Germans and overran the countries of Eastern Europe. By 1948, a hard-line Stalinist system built strictly according to the Russian model had been installed everywhere.
In the years between 1944 and 1948 coalition governments ruled in Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria, etc. In all these coalitions a Stalinist party - under varying and changing names - was the dominant partner, surrounded by other parties, or splinters of other parties, mainly old Social Democratic and peasant parties, which increasingly became mere satellites and puppets of the Stalinist organisation.
Invariably the Stalinists in the coalitions controlled certain key ministries, those which controlled the army and the police - in other words, the ministries which controlled the State. The Stalinists used the state machine as a private monopoly, chopping away at and manipulating their opponents and their coalition partners. Rakosi, the Stalinist boss in Hungary, described the process as the 'salami tactic', taking the opponent a slice at a time.
The essential framework within which such things were possible, and without which they would all have been impossible, was provided by the Russian army and by militarised Stalinist secret police forces.
According to the wartime agreements between the USSR, Britain and the USA the East European countries were within the USSR's recognised 'sphere of influence'. Yugoslavia and Albania were exceptional because local Stalinists took power there without the Russian army, but everywhere else the Russian army and KGB either were in occupation or (as in Czechoslovakia) had arranged things for the local Stalinists and then withdrawn to the borders.
The bourgeoisie had either been discredited collaboration with the German occupiers during World War 2, or pulverised and destroyed by them, or both. Vast swathes of industry were statified at the end of the war. In comparatively developed Czechoslovakia, for example, 75% of industry was nationalised in 1945.J The Russians and their allies The Russians
commanded both great prestigate
and great power to terrorise and control. The local Stalinist parties were weak except in Czechoslovakia and (partially) East Germany: stronger parties were quickly created by the occupying forces and their local agents and collaborators, clustered round the new state apparatus.
Not only old Communist and Stalinist militants joined these new ruling parties. So did careerists, splinters from old socialist parties, and people who had served the prewar dictatorships or even the Nazi occupiers By 1948, all industry had been nationalised. Agriculture had been forcibly collectivised, and Stalin's system of rule had been replicated everywhere.
As soon as the process of Stalinisation was complete, in the late '40s, the newly-forged ruling Stalinist parties were purged. Public trials, modelled on the Moscow Trials of 1936-8, were organised, in which CP leaders confessed to be. ing "imperialist spies' or 'Zionists'.
Invariably the victims of these trials were the people who had been in the old Communist Party, before the Russian police reforged it as an instrument of Stalinist state power. The secretaries of the Hungarian and Czech parties, Rajk and Slansky, for example, were tried, confessed and were hanged.
The new political regime in Poland looks from a distance very like what the Polish government looked like in, say, 1946. The coalition prime minister is not a Stalinist, but the Communist Party will hold the key state-controlling ministries, as it did then. The Stalinists still hold state power - a monopoly of the legal means of violence against the people.
The civilian state apparatus is still held by the CP, as are the key positions in running industry. And the might of the Russian army still gives the Kremlin the right to say to the Polish government: thus far and no further.
But it is the differences between now and the beginning of Stalinist rule in Poland that will determine what happens. Then, the Stalinists were confident in their statemonopoly system, saw the historic future as theirs. Now the rulers of that system have had their self-confidence shattered everywhere from Moscow to Beijing, and, looking for solutions to their impasse, turn to market mechanisms.
In Poland, ( both the Stalinist bureaucrats and the leaders of Solidarnosc are in agreement that the economy must be subjected to 'market discipline'. As long ago as 1970, the Polish bureaucracy, which then ruled almost unchallenged, opened up the economy to the capitalists of the West and tried to use huge, and ultimately crippling, loans from Western banks to develop it. Twenty years later they have drawn the full conclusions and want to internalise the They do so in a political climate determined by Gorbachev's attempt to shake up the Soviet Union. And the Polish Stalinists have been publicly rejected and humiliated in the June election.
It was far from fully democratic. But the Polish people took the chance to show what they feel about their rulers - even despite the deal the Stalinists had made with Solidarnosc.
And then, much to the surprise of the rulers, their long-time puppets, the Peasant and Democratic Parties, took on a life of their own and combined with Solidarnosc to form a government in which the Stalinists were reduced to a minority.
The role of Solidarnosc here has been decisive. Solidarnosc is by now not the mass union it was in 1980-1, but a smaller, more compact labour Mazowiecki at Walesa's right hand movement, a political selection of people, led by a group which is avowedly committed to the restoration of capitalism in Poland.
Lech Walesa is wrong that he is trying to organise the move from socialism to capitalism. That system never had anything in common with socialism. We do, however, have before us the terrible spectacle of a labour movement leadership deliberately and knowingly trying to create conditions for the capitalist exploitation of the working class it represents.
Solidarnosc is a labour movement which has been shaped in the pecular Polish atmosphere of bitter resentment at their national oppression by the Russians, who 50 years "Lech Walesa is wrong that he is trying to organise the move from socialism to capitalism.
with socialism' ago next month joined the Nazis in an almost genocidal war to invade and partition Poland. That resentment expresses itself in an intense renewed commitment to Polish Catholicism as the expression of Polish nationality.
Solidarnosc came into being in a Poland, in 1980, where previous working-class struggles had largely benefited other classes. As a result of the movement spearheaded by the workers' revolt in Poznan in June 1956, agriculture had been decollectivised, recreating a powerful independent peasantry. The Catholic Church had been given a great deal of freedom at the same time, and so had the intelligentsia. But the working class still felt the heavy hand of Stalinist police-state dictatorship, under which it was forbidden to organise free trade unions or political parties.
Then, in 1980, the great mass strike wave welled up and broke the banks of the Stalinist structures, forcing the bureaucrats to legalise Solidarnosc for 16 months. The working class found itself at the head of a great Polish national resurgence.
At the same time, everythingits nationalism, its Catholicism, its hatred of its rulers and of the Russians standing threateningly behind them, its unfamiliarity with genuine socialism after decades of Stalin's counterfeit socialism- conspired to bring that working class under the influence of a powerful block of priests and intellectuals who were fundamentally in favour of restoring capitalism and were also willing to do deals with Moscow's Polish satraps, trading working-class militancy across the counter.
Lenin wrote long ago: "To say that ideologists (conscious leaders) cannot divert from its path the movement created by the interaction of the environment and the (material) elements is to ignore the elementary truth that conscioasness participates in this interaction and creation. Catholic labour unions are also the inevitable result of the interaction of the environment and the material elements. The difference, however, is that it was the consciousness of priests... and not that of socialists that participated in this interaction".
One does not have to have sympathy with or illusions in the Polish Stalinist system to find the behaviour of Lech Walesa and his friends obscene and disgusting. Socialist Organiser, which has always vehemently supported Solidarnosc and never hesitated to call obscene the Stalinism of Arthur Scargill (Walesa's mirror image in the West) or the letter from Tony Benn's Labour Party to "comrade" Gorbachev, has a right to call Walesa's behaviour obscene now.
The Stalinists have given Solidarnosc and its friends a majority in the government. But Solidarnosc has agreed to give the Stalinists its active support in ramming through a viciously anti-working-class programme.
On behalf of a sort of vast international Grand Coalition, which ranges from the international bankers to the Polish Stalinists to the Kremlin, Walesa and his friends have undertaken to get the Polish working class to accept a savage programme of economic reconstruction which is likely to decimate the working class itself. -Most likely the Stalinists expect to use the credit Solidarnosc will bring to the government in order to push this programme through, and then also to benefit from discrediting of Solidarnosc's leaders that must follow this collaboration in economic reconstruction at the expense of the working class and especially at the expense of the steelworkers and miners who have been the heart and soul of Solidarnosc.
It is good that the Stalinists political monopoly is broken. The Polish working class must learn from its own experience and from the mistakes of its leaders.
Right now it is paying the price for the years of Stalinist rule which pushed sections of the working class into the politics now articulated by Walesa. In a way the best place for the leaders of Solidarnosc is where they now are, trying to push through policies which will bring them into conflict with sections of the working class base of Solidarnosc - and thus allow those workers to learn from experience that capitalism is not the answer to Stalinism.
Socialists in the West must continue to support Solidarnosc against the Polish state, which is still Stalinist-controlled, and against the always-present threat of Russian intervention - that is, support against the Stalinist state Solidarnosc's unconditional right to exist and function, as distinct from supporting the policies and activities of its leaders in goverment and in support of the government.
Solidarnosc is no monolith. It contains socialists and others who condemn Walesa, as socialists in the Labour Party condemn Kinnock, or Wilson or Callaghan. Their influence will grow in the period ahead.
Scan page 6
6 LEBANO
----- pull-quotes -----
That system never had anything in common