Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Trotsky's theory was temporary

Socialist Organiser no. 413, 31 August 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 641 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

ETTERS In no.411 you carried a page article with the weary "orthodox" Trot case, accusing you of failing to understand basic Marxism.

While assuredly constant repetition of the fallacy gets boring, a new reader might be taken in by the superficially authoritative case.

Your "orthodox" correspondent, as is usual, made significant omissions. He quoted from 'Permanent Revolution' but neglected to state that the arguments quoted were an attempt to show that Stalinism could not last a full generation; and that Trotsky made it quite clear that he was producing a temporary theory to meet a temporary situation and that if Stalinism did last, then his theory would have been proved to be wrong, and should be thrown in the dustbin of history.

Your correspondent also omitted all reference to Trotsky's view in 1938 that Stalinism would be overthrown in the course of a world revolution at the end of the war then beginning, and that, if it were not, this would prove that the analysis that he had produced as a temporary assessment of the class nature of the USSR had been wrong and must be abandoned.

But it is not only Trotsky whom your "orthodox" comrade revises. The term a workers' state, and the associated concept of a state that is neither capitalist nor socialist, but is transitional between the two (a state short-lived) had for Lenin a very definite meaning.

Lenin's initial coining of the term was spelt out in detail. He described Russia (on several occasions) as "workers' dominated (through the soviets) state capitalism in transition to socialism" — adding at the time of the trade union controversy - "but with severe bureaucratic deformations"*.

That was a conscious reference back to Marx's favourable comments on Lassalle's "Qu'est-ce que c'est qu'une Constitution?" in which the latter said that it is possible during a revolutionary situation when the citizenry is armed and overawed and a transitional society be imposed. If the transition is not completed, rapidly; if the citizenry lose their vigilance and their power to impose decisions that conflict with the underlying class system; then inevitably the ruling class will reimpose its power.

Does your "orthodox" comrade really believe that the Soviet citizenry did retain through the Stalinist years the power to overawe the controllers of industry? If so he revises both Marx and Lenin. If not his argument is meaningless.

Laurens Otter Wellington, Salop to be able to develop. politically. The right of the workers to organise freely in clubs, groups, currents and political organisations has to be defended. Open politicisation of the workers' movement, based on clear principles, can only strengthen it.

Attempts to smother this process, under the pretext that it weakens the union' is "factional' activity, or 'provocation' on the other hand, can only undermine the movement, or in fact divide it and they involve all the characteristics of provocation. 8. Self-determination Understanding the class character of social relations in Poland involves rejecting the nationalist imagery that reduces our fight to a struggle against the Soviet Union for independence. The basic dividing line in our nation is not a schematic opposition between patriots and traitors but one of opposing interests among different class to assume economic power.

Joint work by radical worker activists with a view toward forming a workers' opposition to the bureaucracy is essential to draw up programme for the Polish workers' movement and to gain support for the revolutionary struggle aimed at establishing a system of self-management, a self-managed republic in the full sense of the term.

By establishing coordination among the organisations, or in the future by building revolutionary parties, we are not opposing ourselves to the workers' movement in the broad sense.

On the contrary, we want the revolutionary current, which is component of this movement, to be consolidated within its own struc-

----- pull-quotes -----

11. Workers" opposition

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 413

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →