Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Stalin allied with Hitler

Socialist Organiser no. 413, 31 August 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 656 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The extraordinary sight of millions of people joining arms across the Soviet Baltic republics in protest against their annexation by Stalin forty years ago, was a dramatic reminder of the Stalin-Hitler pact that precipitated World War Two.

On 23 August 1939, the governments of the USSR and Germany signed a non-aggression pact (and later a friendship treaty, following which the USSR annexed Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia, and invaded eastern Poland, while Hitler invaded from the west. The treaty with Stalin had given Hitler the cover he wanted, and he was able to force the hand of his European enemies. War began.

The Stalin-Hitler pact (also known as the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact) inevitably had dire consequences on the pro-Moscow Communist Parties. In the British Communist Party there was a fierce faction-fight, party leaders like Pollitt and Gallacher opposing both the pact and the soft line on fascism that followed it. They were ousted by R Palme Dutt, a pro-Moscow doctrinaire.

Eventually, in 1941, Hitler invaded the USSR, and Stalin had to change sides.

The whole episode is obviously very embarrassing for the pro-Moscow Communist parties. Fifty years on, they accept that the pact was a mistake, but without drawing any conclusions (the Morning Star comments wisely that people make mistakes) and by continuing i to warp the history of that period.

The Stalin-Hitler pact was just one of numerous dramatic shifts in Moscow's policy. In 1928, the Communist International declared a 'third period' in which social democracy was "social fascism' (worse than ordinary fascism) and the Communists could make no alliance with it.

The Morning Star (25 August) claims that "throughout 15 years of the Weimar Kepublic social democracy] rejected all Communist proposals for a united front against the rise of fascism" . In fact, from 1928 to Hitler's victory in 1933, the German CP opposed any united front with the social democrats except as a purely propagandist recruitment technique. The united front was a policy advocated by Trotsky and his movement, denounced as "Trotsky-fascists' by the Kremlin.

The Morning Star does admit that the 'third period' line isolated the CP...But why no conclusions about the people who said so at the time?

Moscow not only changed its line continually (after Hitler's rise to power, it launched 'popular fronts' with bourgeois parties), it demanded blind obedience from its different national sections and the individual members of them. Anyone who criticised was purged. Trotskyists - during the Spanish civil war of 1936-39, for example — were shot in the back of the neck.

The Stalin-Hitler pact was not an isolated error. It was signed because the Moscow bureaucracy put its own interests (and even then is interests defined narrowly and nationalistically) before the interests of the international communist movement. What it got out of the pact with Hitler was not freedom from a war with it; it got the Baltic states and half of Poland. And that is what Stalin wanted.

The pact confused and disoriented the workers' movement. Until 1941, the Comintern line was that both sides were imperialist, which for them in practice meant a soft-peddling on Nazism. Then they became fervent advocates of the Allies' 'anti-fascist' struggle, opposing strikes - including in such paragons of democratic values as Sound their third period" policy allowed Hitler to come to power in the first place.

As the documents published revealir of the Nazi-Sovier movement must it, and not allow & the grim truth act, the labour deed remember the pro-Moscow Stalinists to squirm their way out of it. And we must support the right to self-determination of the Baltic KIRGOTA publics, while also supporting e rights of the Russian and other norities in those regions. ment needs to find its own way of dealing with the coca ine barons, rather than rely on the : US-backed government. And a re al economic alternative is needed to lift the Colombian people out of the poverty they are in.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 413

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →