Teach yourself honest politi accounting
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
arguments, and now we don't Your then accepted trust we have the right to change our minds.
Comrade Foot also wanted to know what these people were doing with sophisticated arguments about agitation and propaganda when the matter was really quite simple, ie. for or against pogroms. If the matter is really that simple perhaps comrade Foot could tell me why when, before the debate, I asked comrade Cliff what our current are for withdrawal, of course" (meaning at the propaganda level, of course).
No, the agitation/propaganda arguments were raised not by us, but by comrades Harman, Marks, Palmer, etc. In fact on the basis of what he said, comrade Foot's position can only be interpreted as one of support for the troops, while his whole speech was delivered in tones of righteous indignation.
Comrades Harman and Cliff were not much better, Harman's main points were that it is not enough to just repeat the ABCs of t Marxism over and over again, and that to call for troop withdrawal is 'petty bourgeois' heroics.
But in fact the opposition were not arguing the formalist case that since we oppose imperialism, and since we are for a workers' republic, we must raise the withdrawal slogan, the opposition was arguing that this slogan could have played a progressive role in the struggle, and that failure to raise it leaves IS in a position of confused and ambiguous tailism.
It is the ABC of Marxism. The "petty bourgeois heroics' point was highly misleading for no one on the opposition side indulged in heroics, or in any accusations of cowardice. Comrade Cliff used the "cups of tea' argument, ie. the families of Derry and Belfast welcomed the troops so we cannot call for withdrawal. If one applied this argument to such questions as immigration control, the First World War, or in times past to were treated to in the debate. Firstly that the Catholics needed a breathing space in which to arm themselves, which was provided by 'the troops.
This argument was dishonest because it was very obvious that it was extremely unlikely that the Catholics would succeed in arming: "themselves. It was also obvious that the presence of the troops, tar trom facilitating this, would make it very difficult.] workers would only get arms were there an immediate and urgent need for them, ie. a struggle going on. IS never answered the question of how arms were to be obtained but put forward the slogan "Open the Southern arsenals", knowing full well that this was merely a propaganda demand which could not be realised.
Secondly, there was the agitation/propaganda argument which was explained at great length. Much has been written on this and I do not intend to go over old ground.
What I will say is that I accept the distinction between agitation and propaganda as an abstract argument but would argue that its concrete application in this case has led to a failure not just to agitate against the troops but to make any propaganda against them.
Lam aware that the early articles in Socialist Worker contained escape clauses in the small print as it were, and we have often used such phrases as "socialists never had any illusions about British imperialism and its objectives in Ireland" ', but the fact remains that over the months we have completely failed to carry out any systematic propaganda against the troops.?
Until the issue of 2 April [1970], Socialist Worker carried no articles analysing the concrete activities of the troops. The Marks/Palmer reply to Workers' Fight in the Internal Bulletin carried no analysis of the current situation, or of what sort of things the troops have actually been doing, nor did comrade Palmer's report at Conference which in fact did not even mention the troops. Thus we have not even at the propaganda level made any preparations for the struggle with the troops which must come sooner or later. In this we have failed not merely our Irish contacts but also those British workers who read our literature. Is this failure accidental, or is it due to a desire to the troops question?
So far I have dealt with the way in which our position on the troops has been defended rather than with the basis of that position itself. Has our fundamental analysis of the situation in Northern Ireland when the troops went in been right or wrong?
I believe that is has been wrong and that the crucial error has been, when dealing with the question of the troops, to argue as though Northern Ireland were a separate isolated country. An analogy used by both Marks and Palmer neatly illustrates this way of thinking. If a group of our comrades, they say, were set upon by a much stronger force of fascists and the police intervened, we would not call for the police to withdraw. However, to apply this analogy accurately to Ireland our small group of comrades would have to have a much larger force of friends, asleep just round the corner who might well be roused by the sound of battle.
Had the troops not gone in there was surely the possibility of volunteer forces from the south coming to the aid of the Catholics in the north, thus not only practically raising the question of a United Ireland but also completely undermining the regime in the south. Unless we take the position that Ireland is one country there is no possibility of workers' power there in the forseeable future. Once we take the position that Ireland is one country in relation to the troops it is clear that there is a third alternative which can be counterposed to the troops or massacre dichotomy.3 In the light of this perspective the argument that trusted PD comrades* weren't calling for withdrawal of the troops so we shouldn't either is not very impressive precisely because from the outset PD has had a tendency to Thursday 14 September Leeds SO: 'Labour's Policy Review". Speaker Alan Johnson. Coburg pub, 7.30 Friday 15 September "Labour's Socialist Alternative' . Pre-conference rally at Sheffield City Po ly, Totley Hall Lane, Sheffield, 7.30 Organised by CLPs Conference and supported by Campaign Group. Saturday 16 S-F regard Northern Ireland as a separate unit. This has manifested itself in a number of ways.
There was PD's reluctance to take a position on the border (we didn't on that question say our comrades aren't opposing the border so we can't, there is the naming of their newspaper 'Northern Star', and there is the position taken by Mike Farrell in 'Struggle in the North' on Southern Irish, troops as an alternative to British troops. Farrell seems to suggest that this extremely unlikely eventuality would be even worse than British troops, which I think is tantamount to recognising the border this side of socialism.
The main disadvantage of our position is that it puts us completely in a tailist position, in particular talling the IRAS , and makes it impossible for us to play an educative leadership role on the nature of the troops. In addition to this we end up never quite saying what we mean. It is also becoming abundantly clear that regardless of who was right or wrong last August, or even at Conference, that we must change our line soon. 1 The "Trotskyist Tendency' in IS/SWP was a political forerunner of Socialist Organiser. 2 John Molyneux writes here as an IS/SWP loyalist. In fact SW carried systematic propaganda for the troops, in the form of repeated attacks on the for their withdrawal and repeated insistence on how vital they were for the defence of the Catholic areas. The support for the troops was, of course, critical, but support it was.
Molyneux's point about IS/SWP in 1969 treating Northern Ireland as a separate unit, apart from the whole of Ireland, is valid. But this argument aboutSouthern Catholics rallying to defeat the Protestants in the communal conflict in the North was not endorsed by the Trotskyist Tendency then, and still less does it make any sense today - though versions of it are now widespread on the left. 4 PD — People's Democracy - was then linked politically to the IS/SWP. In 1971 it swung over to becoming a sort of auxiliary propaganda unit for the Provisional IRA. S In 1969 the (pre-split) IRA did not call for troops out.
Pre-Conference Briefing for CLP delegates. Sheffield City Poly, Totley Hall Lane, Sheffield, 10.30. Contact. CLPs Conference, Lol Duffy, 11] Egremont Prom, Merseyside L44, Friday 3 November History Workshop Conference 1989. Salford University. Contact Helen Bowyer, 51 Crescent, Salford M5 4UX (061-736 3601)
Saturday 11 November Socialist Conference 'Building the Left in the Unions'. Sheffield Poly Student Union, Pond St, 10.30. Credentials £6 waged, £4 unwaged from Socialist Conference, 9 Poland St, London W1
----- pull-quotes -----
What is more, as the Trotskyist tendency! pointed out, the Catholic
AIC TIMISTS® DIARY