Should socialists talk to Sinn Fein?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
-mocratic power of the working ess and an economy that would be tented toward the satisfaction of lective needs.
Those activists who are most adaced politically are today organisin the ranks of the Polish cialist Party-Democratic Revoluin (PPS-RD), led by Jozet Pinior, 10 was one of the national derground leaders of Solidarnosc ter the implementation of the ite of siege.
Others are operating inside the ghting Solidarity Organisation SO), in the groups of workers and dicalised youth in Gdansk that pport the anti-Walesa dissident sitions of Andrzej Gwiadza and ina Walentynowicz, in the icalised sectors of the anti-war uth movement Liberty and Peace TiP), in the Independent Union of udents (NZS), and in the Federan of Combatant Youth (FMW). Yet others can be found in such pups having dissident points of ew in regard to the Walesa line as • Regional Strike Committees KS) of Solidarnosc in Wroclaw, e Interfactory Workers' Commit: (MRKS) of Solidarnosc in Warw, or the Intercity Anarchist deration (MA).
There are also many rank and file tivists strongly committed to the fence of the interests of the orkers and of the basic principles workers' democracy, who are ace in the "official" structures of lidarnosc, which follow the valesa line.
The radical dissidents tended to Dup themselves around two cenI demands in regard to the alesa line and the roundtable Teement: the defence of the imdiate interests of the workers and • fight for full democracy.
The socialists of the PPS-RD raised more advanced slogans — concerning the plan of construction of a Self-Managed Republic (a state based on workers' democracy) that had been adopted by Solidarnosc in 1981.
They confronted illusions in the possibility of a democratic reform of the system of bureaucratic power by raising the alternative of a democratic workers' revolution. To the re-privatisations and the openings toward capitalism, they opposed the slogan of "the factories to the workers"
The slogan (put forward by the socialists as well as by other diverse radicalised currents) of full state democracy is tightly linked to the demand of full democracy in Solidarnosc itself. All these currents share the sentiment that those who have accepted 65 percent of bureaucracy and 35per percent of democracy in the state will also try to impose a line establishing 65 per cent of bureaucracy and 35 per cent of democracy in Solidarnosc.
To point the way forward, socialists must build a party of the anti-bureaucratic revolution, of workers' democracy, and of international socialism - counting on the programmatic and political support of socialists of the entire world.
Walesa, Kuron, Michnik, Geremek, and others who today monopolise the Solidarnose leadership say "no" to revolution. It is necessary instead to dare to say "yes" to revolution. This is what members of the PPS-RD already have done - with admirable courage.
Abridged (US).!
VIORITHLANND The response of the British left to Sinn Fein is strange thing to see.
When Gerry Adams spoke to the Socialist Conference in Sheffield in June most of the audience appeared to idolise him. He received a standing ovation before the speech!
There is a rare psychological condition at work here — it's called revolution by proxy! It happens when the most cautious and routine of British socialists are exposed to contact with the leaders of real physical-force nationalist revolt. Normally these people consider it 'ultra-left' for local councils to refuse to make cuts or increase their rates but under the effects of this exposure they become gooey-eyed advocates of armed struggle.
But Adam's presence in Sheffield provoked another response. There was much pressure from the Labour Party leaders and the local press to prevent him from attending- The organisers were attacked for inviting 'a spokesman for terrorism' This attitude was not confined to opponents of the Socialist Conference. One group involved in the event Independent Labour Publications (ILP) took particular exception to Adams presence. Gary Kent of ILP sent an open letter to the Socialist Movement strongly deploring the invitation to Adams which "wrongly identified socialists with those who justify the murder and maiming of opponents." I would share many of the feelings expressed in the ILP letter. The ILP condemn Adams for telling British socialists to mind their own business rather than worry about the fate of the Protestants or what will happen after a troop withdrawal. They assert the right of socialists to comment on and think about international affairs.
try Adams We were certainly not part of the standing ovation. From our own standpoint however, it is importani to reject the ILP's outrage and stress the importance of dialogue with all forces working for a just settlement in Ireland, including Sinn Fein.
Firstly if socialists refused to talk to anyone in Northern Ireland who justified the use of violence against opponents they would have few people to talk to. The ILP advise us to look to the Workers' Party. The Workers' Party's sanctimonious attacks on IRA violence are a standing joke amongst Catholics in Northern Ireland coming from a group which could teach Vito Corleone a thing or two about how to deal with opponents!
Aside from the Workers' Party's record in treating opponents, past or present it is their policy that Catholics should give their support to the RUC! If ever there was a bunch of murdering, skull-bashing thugs in Northern Ireland this is the original.
None of this leads me to reject discussion with the WP - but the idea that you can single out Sinn Fein as the party of violence really is a dangerous concession to government propaganda. The IRA is a violent reaction to a brutally violent, irreformable state.
Secondly, Sinn Fein represents a sizeable part of the people of Northern Ireland. It's vote is falling slowly, but it does represent the most deprived and oppressed section of the population, the nationalists of the urban ghettoes like West Belfast, Bogside, Cregga etc.
The idea that we should not listen to such a force is an insult to those people whether it comes from the Thatcher government, Neil Kinnock, or the ILP.
You don't have to accept Sinn Fein's particular strategy to see that many nationalists bitterly dislike any reformist solution, coming from London or Dublin and want to rapidly gain freedom to shape their own destiny. Sinn Fein reflects the besieged fear and determination of that section of the population. Hence they are fiercely nationalist, they are socially radical (many are socialists) and they are reluctant to abandon what they see as their one prestige weapon — a relatively efficient armed wing.
I think there is a big gap between the aspiration of self-determination and the current strategy of Sinn Fein and in Socialist Organiser we have made it plain that we think the armed struggle should be dropped — but the last way to make progress on any of these points is to denounce any dialogue with Sinn Fein, to cut them off from any contact with British socialists. This would be especially shameful when the state has censored that organisation and the left should be championing their right to be heard.
There are two simple and silly assumptions made about our attitude to Sinn Fein.
1. The IRA are terrorists therefore we condemn and shun them. This makes no more sense than saying the same of the ANC or PLO - it is to accept the one-sided view of a state under attack. In fact they are revolutionary nationalists - they use violence, though nothing like the scale of violence against them -but more important they represent and reflect the consciousness of the oppressed.
2. The IRA represent the oppressed and are militantly fighting their oppressors - therefore they must be supported — we must demure to their politics, their strategy, their agenda.
In fact their politics are less adequate than at any previous period in Irish history - they represent a very small portion of the Irish people.
The reality is that Sinn Fein must be part of any discussion on a solution to the national question in Ireland — but it must be a genuine discussion and that means socialists speaking their own mind, spelling out their programme for a democratic settlement. We have to sort out what we have to say in such a discussion and that isn't helped either by idolising Gerry Adams or refusing to let him speak.
hpli