Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

MURDER! 20 years on!

Socialist Organiser no. 412, 17 August 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 1,229 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

A consistent record? In fact Socialist Worker main tasks of a Marxist paper like only rule 'thre Socialist Organiser is to convince the left that it should not just shout. slogans, but first study the situation and discuss the possibilities.

Discussion on Ireland is a difficult thing to organise on the British left, though things have improved a bit lately with the setting up of "Time To Go'l The Socialist Workers' Party (SWP) is the biggest single force on the left which works against rational discussion about Ireland supported the troops in 1969 as also about Israel/Palestine, where the relations between Arab recruits to regard such an approach and Jew have much in common as a betrayal of the fight against imwith Catholic-Protestant relations, perialism. in north-east Ireland.

The SWP insist on reducing people miseducated by the SWP, everything to slogans and, against salutary, to learn the strange history those on the left who question their of the SWP on Ireland. In 1969-70 the SWP (then IS supported and sloganising. to abuse. They justified the deployment of British nounce Socialist "iso-imperialist, 'Unionist' troops in Ireland! "Zionist' and so on, and so on. Implicitly they insist that certain same policy as was then put forpeoples - the Israeli Jews, the Nor- ward by the Labour Party thern Ireland Protestant/Unionists parliamentary left round Tribune - are bad peoples, and that the - indefinite direct rule — wrapping solution to the conflicts is for the it up in a lot of militant-sounding collective identity the "bad" "demands' and 'conditions'. peoples, Jews and Protestants, to be obliterated as thoroughly as the history on this question might lead conquering Romans of old SWP members to think about the obliterated their rival, Carthage. real issues, and listen to the They sometimes come close to arguments against their own sloganopenly advocating the 'Cartage- mongering approach. For that nian' solution for Israel. They are reason, the SWP leaders lie about more circumspect about the Nor- their history. thern Ireland Unionists, but the logic of what they say is un- four pages on "20 years of repres mistakable in both cases. For sion" in Northern Ireland, opening Ireland they talk about a 'socialist with a page on "The day the troops solution' which would include Pro- went in" testant/Unionist workers shorn of their present identity as a distinct British army [was] sent... to crush a community or Irish national peaceful civil rights movement minority; but this talk has no grip fighting discrimination.. on reality. The Protestant Irish working class has demonstrated Catholic ghetto] matched the again and again that it will defend teargas and baton charges of the its distinct identity in every way police with stones and petrol bombs. In three days they fought necessary. The SWP's policy of conquest of the police to a standstill. the "bad' peoples is anti-socialist and anti-working-class; sent the troops in... Far from senyoung people are drawn towards it ding the troops to protect the sympathy with the oppressed Catholic population Callaghan and Northern Ireland Catholics and the fellow minister Healey insisted to oppressed Palestinian Arabs. They the cabinet, 'Our whole interest is are then convinced that any concern to work through the Protestant by socialists with the rights of Pro- government'." testants or Jews is a betrayal of the Catholics and Palestinian Arabs. tion solely from that page could The Marxist approach is that there is no such thing as a 'bad' people, or a people without rights. Out!' in 1969.

in conflicts like those in Ireland anc in Israel/Palestine, we advocate page is illustrated with copies of in Lenin's phrase - 'consistent democracy'. We support the oppressed in their fight for full democratic rights; we do not support any drive for revenge or sup- been in the small print.

pression of the rights of the communities which are currently oppressors.

We advocate equal rights and compromise and conciliation between the conflicting peoples - and, on that basis, working-class unity across the communal and national the Protestants.

divide to fight for socialism.

All that is a closed book to the SWP. Indeed, they educate their fists not temporary breathing space in which the defences of the Catholic community can be strengthened"

Therefore it is useful, and for declared SW on 21 August 1969.

*The breathing space provided by the presence of British troops is short but vital" , it insisted on 11 September. "Those who call for the immediate withdrawal of troops before the men behind the barIn effect, they advocated the ricades can defend themselves areinviting a pogrom which will hit first and hardest at socialists".

A big centre-page headline-read] "Fine slogans and grim reality -the contradictory role of British troops gives Catholic workers time A true account of their own to arm against further Orange atStacks"

But Socialist Worker followed up its feature with a leaflet to the "Time To Go' demonstration illustrated by SW front pages from 1969 to 1989, trying to show how consistent SW had been over twenty Last week's Socialist Worker had years in its opposition to the troops.

On page 8 this week we call John Molyneux to the witness stand, to document the reality of what SW was saying in 1969.

That page tells us that "The It is not possible in 1989, in the light of 20 years' experience, to pose the issues as they were posed in the debates in the SWP/IS in 1969.

"[In Derry] the defenders [of the Those of us who fought the protroops position of Tony Cliff, Paul Foot and others continue to oppose the troops; but we now believe that troops out cannot be proposed as simplistically as we did it then.

"Britain's Labour government Twenty years later, it seems clear that troops out without a political settlement would actually lead inevitably to full-scale civil war and repartition. We therefore advocate linking troops out to a programme of a federal united Ireland, with regional autonomy for the NorNo reader gaining their informa- thern Protestants, and voluntary confederal links between that doubt at all that Socialist Worker united Ireland and Britain. would have boldly said "Troops Marxists relate to the world and where necessary modify their ideas.

To redouble the cynicism, the and responses in the light of events.

But that is not what the IS/SWP Socialist Worker front pages from leaders have done. They posture 1969. They include no call for and sloganise in an irresponsible troops out, but - so you would fashion which, 20 years ago, was think - that call must surely have peculiar to Gerry Healy's SLL.

There is no way that Tony Chiff In fact the small print said just and his colleagues can square what the opposite. In 1989 Socialist they say now with what they said in Worker says that the troops went 1969. Every argument they gave for onto the streets in 1969 to crush the supporting the troops in 1969 would Catholics. In 1969 Socialist Worker apply ten times over today. said the troops were protecting the Nothing, nothing at all, in the last Catholics (albeit unreliably) from twenty years' experience - which includes a powerful and successful "Time is vital to bring aid to the Protestant general strike — can be Northern people. The intervention cited in support of the present of the British troops only allows a policy on Ireland of the SWP.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 412

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →