Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Trotsky 1 right

Socialist Organiser no. 411, 10 August 1989 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 3,238 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Some time ago, carried a series of articles by Vladimir Derer on the nature analysis of them was fundamentally flawed.

Trotsky, the USSR under Stalin was neither socialist nor capitalist. He defined it as a degenerated workers' state.

What does that mean? For Marxists, a 'workers' state' is a state where capitalism as a dominant state machine and mode of production has been smashed, and where a society based on collectivised property is created. Trotsky saw the USSR as having degenerated to the point where the political power of the workers had been lost, but where the usurpers Stalin's bureaucracy - had not formed themselves into a new class over a new kind of society.

There is another phrase Marxists use instead of workers' state - it is *transitional society'. It is this phrase, and theory that Trotsky linked to it, that Derer tried to disprove.

The transitional society was not just a phrase thought up by Trotsky. The phrase and the theory were both expounded by Marx, Engels, Lenin and others before Trotsky wrote down his analysis of the USSR in "The Revolution Betrayed' (1935). The transition is the period between the smashing of the old capitalist state and - after the capitalists and the remnants of their economy and ideas have been cleared away - stateless communism.

The prerequisite for the transition is working class power - the "dictatorship' by the majority, the working class, over the capitalist minority. That power is then used to wipe away the old conditions of production and government.

For such a struggle to succeed, the workers need democratic control over their organisations, and a new state that represents the power of the workers themselves. The transition also needs the building of international working class power - through support to revolutions over the world.

The working class in state power has many tasks; the political destruction of the capitalist class; the economic expropriation of the means production by the workers; and the construction of organs of direct democracy. To build and solidify the workers' state it may be necessary to use "capitalist' methods — wages for in. stance. In the transition, the workers can only be freed by their own activity, and their fight to construct socialism.

In the USSR, the fight of the workers to defend and extend the gains of the revolution, and to eradicate the remnants of the old society was blocked by the rise of a conservative and Bonapartist bureaucracy.

Conservative because of its nature as a layer of Great Russian nationalist, ex-Czarist bureaucrats, who wished the transition and the world movement By the conly 30s they had halted. By the early been able to achieve that through destroying the remnants of democratic control and purging the party.

But they were also Bonapartist in the same sense the French Bonapartists excluded the French bourgeois from political power while presiding over and protecting capitalist property relations. Similarly the soviet bureaucrats took political power from the workers while at the same time defending the collectivised means of production - against the workers on the one hand and the fascists and capitalists on the other.

The bureaucrats in the USSR defend the stability of the nationalised economy because it is their bread and butter they live off the surplus of goods and services made by the workers. And they can only extract that surplus precisely because the economy is nationalised and they control it!

So the loss of political power by the workers to the Stalinist bureaucracy did not mean the restoration of capitalism. The bureaucracy was not the old ruling class reformed, running nationalised economy because it happened to be the best way to make profits. Rather, the bureaucracy is a layer of parasites that depends on the nationalised economy, but is unable to exist without it.

In terms of its basic make-up, the USSR is an unstable not natural formation. It was able to duplicate itself because of the weakness in the late '40s of both the working class and the imperialists.

And as we have seen many times, it produced not a cohesive stable structure, but an unbalanced, contradictory kind of society which has exploded time and time again.

The USSR is a society trapped between capitalism and communism. The bureaucrats fight hard to keep it away from revolution and counter-revolution. The fact that they have half-way succeeded in keeping that balance does not mean that there must have been some massive change.

People who argue that the length of time the bureaucrats have held power means that they are now a capitalist or other form of stable class argue against both Marxism and reality!

A relationship between time and change does exist. But it is not the only determinant. Imagine all the things that can happen to a tree during a period of time: it can rot or it can continue to grow; it can be chopped down or burnt; or it can fossilise or turn to oil.

What is the best way of telling what actually has happened? Looking at the tree or looking at your watch? The answer is clear. The same point is true of the Soviet Union. A state blocked in transition does not automatically turn into another form of society just because of time!

Trotsky argued (in "The workers' state and the question of Thermidor and Bonapartism', 1935) that the nature of the USSR could only be determined by its substance — "its social foundation and economic tendencies". The nature of a state remains the same until something happens to make it change - until a revolutionary force, either the capitalists or the workers, take The way to tell if the class nature of the Soviet Union has changed is to look if its foundations have fundamentally changed. They haven't, at least in the 65 years since the Soviet thermidor began.

To argue that the Soviet state has undergone some massive change since then, is to argue an idea that does not hold together - because the USSR clearly has the same ruling elite and mode of production. The weakness of the argument can go further. Some argue a counterrevolution happened, some date it to 1928, but some argue a gradual unter-revolution happened Look at the first argument. By 1928, the position of the bureaucracy had been fairly secure for a few years. It was engaged in Leon Trotsky methodically eliminating threats to its rule. It smashed the Left Opposition in the Bolshevik party, and then the Right.

In 1928 it took on the 'kulaks', the rich farmers, by seizing their property. It was a bold move, But was it a revolution? The state, the holders of power and the nature of the economy all stayed the same. It was a change — but to argue it was a revolutionary transformation is to argue nonsense.

Equally wrong are those who argue that a gradual revolution has happened. Again, all that has happened is that time has moved on. But without some qualitative change in the substance of the Soviet state, how can there have been a counter-revolution? Point to it!

More to the point, how can you have a gradual revolution? The experience of the past and of Marxist theory is that the workers cannot take . Power through capitalism growing peacetully over into socialism. In fact socialism can only be built through our class, weapons in hand, smashing the repressive machine of the old ruling class.

As Trotsky wrote, "how, in that case, is the imperceptible, gradual, bourgeois counter-revolution possible...feudal as well as bourgeois counter-revolutions have never taken place 'organically' but they have invariably required the intervention of military surgery...

"He who asserts that the soviet government has gradually been changed trom proletarian to bourgeois is only, so to speak, running back the film of reformism." ("The class nature of the Soviet Another charge is that Trotsky predicted wrong about the war — so his whole theory must be incorrect. Trotsky believed that a protracted world war had to lead to an end to the bureaucrats' power.

Not just because there was a war, but because of the effects of the war — in potentially weakening the hold of the bureaucracy, and strengthening the working class, and perhaps imperialism too. Trotsky also thought the war would regenerate the Marxists in the USSR, and an upsurge of workers' activity in the east and west would lead to revolution.

At the end of the war the situation was not too far away from that. European capitalism was weak at the end of the war. There was an upsurge in working class activity. But all over Europe - France, Germany, Greece - that upsurge was crushed by the 'Allied' and Soviet armies. A central reason for that was the decimation of the Trotskyists during the war and the unObjectively speaking, Eight Men Out' may not be the best film in

Scan page 10

town, but who's objective these days? I think it's the best film this year.

It's a sport movie, but don't let that turn you off. It's only a sports movie the way 'All the President's Men' was a movie about journalists.

The sport is baseball, the time is 1919, the place is Chicago, and it all really happened. The team we meet, the White Sox, are the champions, all set to win the World Series, the annual contest between the top two teams in the rival American baseball leagues.

In 1919 players barely got a living wage; this is way before the get-rich-quick days of sponsorship and endorsements, and the players are pretty disgruntled with the team's owner, Charlie Comiskey, a tight fisted skinflint, who beggars his players while downing champagne with fawning sportswriters.

When a cash offer to throw the series comes the team's way, some of the players jump at it.

That's the starting point for director John Sayles's story. The film shows what happened to the men who took the money and to the ones who didn't, and it's never less than involving.

W flows through a wire, hen an electric current heat is produced. This is due to a property of the wire called resistance.

The greater the resistance, the more the heat. Sometimes this is useful (electric heaters, cookers, etc). Often it is a waste of energy and, sometimes, it can be dangerous, causing overheating and even fire. If only this heating could be eliminated...

Well, it can! At very low temperatures, resistance disappears completely, and an electric current will flow for ever without energy loss. This is called superconductions.

The potential advantages of super-conduction are out-weighed by the difficulty and expense of getting temperatures low enough. To refrigerate the wires requires liquid helium at about -269°C, costing about £3 per litre.

There is also some danger in case of malfunction. If the superconducSayles's films are never simplistic and one-dimensional. In Eight Men Out' , we get involved with a variety of characters, and even the minor ones are telling.

Arnold Rothstein, the fat Jewish American financier who bankrolls the fixing of the series, isn't just in it for the money; the fix is also his revenge on the all-American ball players of his childhood who sidelined him. He can finally look down on them with contempt; even champions go down for the money, he thinks, everyone has his price.

"Goodbye, suckers!" is his parting shot as, loaded with money, he heads for Europe on a cruise.

The team are a mixed bunch -the hard heads like Gandil and Risberg who set up the fix, Eddie Cicotte, the anxious, ageing star pitcher who's worried about the future, Buck Weaver and "Shoeless"" Joe Jackson, perfectionists who never grew out of their boyish love of the game.

But mixed or not, the team are a tremendous unit, and in the moments when they pull together on the field, they display the kind of brilliance that looks easy and effortless. The grins they wear as they lark about say everything there is to say about the high that competitive sport can give.

Seeing them at their insouciant best underlines the shock we feel later when the fix is on, and the players have to try their damndest to lose. Solidarity is gone; no-one can look anyone in the eye. We've seen how good the team is, and we can't help feeling anguish.

tor was allowed to warm up too much, it would suddenly regain its resistance. A run-away heating would take place, perhaps leading to fire or explosion.

The discovery of so-called high temperature super-conduction (HISC) in 1986 therefore caused an immense wave of enthusiasm to pass over physicists, university research departments, electronics and chemical firms.

In 1986 George Beduorz and Alex Müller, researchers. for IBM in Zurich, discovered a ceramic substance (like pottery) that would superconduct at -243°C, six degrees higher than previously obtained using metals. Then the record temperature shot up to -180°C in 1987, with the discovery by Paul Chu and colleagues in Texas and Alabama of another superconducting ceramic.

After this breakthrough, the American Physical Society, already holding its annual meeting, organised at short notice an evening session on super-conduction. 4,000 attended the session which ended eleven hours later at 6am! The New York Times called it Woodstock for physicists"

The record temperature for HTSC now stands at - 145°C, a long way short of room temperature, + 25°C, the ultimate goal of HTSC. Nevertheless, -145°C is easily achievable using liquid nitrogen at -190°C, widely available at about 8p a litre.

The promise of HTSC in revolutionising power transmission, transport, energy storage and electronics led swiftly to national initiatives, meetings of businessmen and scientists, seminars and journals.

But as David Goodstein, a physics professor at the California Institute of Technology, points out in New Scientist, these seem to have been the only successful commercial applications of HTSC. So why has the euphoria heralded little in the way of achievements? "Shoeless' Joe Jackson (left)

Sayles is interested in the people, and he makes them live for us, but he's interested in wider issues, too, in the exploitation and corruption behind the fix. Rothstein taunts the ex-boxer who works for him, "1 made twenty times what you did on theinch, Abe— and I never took Later, For one, the new superconductors are complex mixtures of metal oxides. They require many quite expensive ingredients, mixed to exact proportions and baked to just the right temperature. It is furthermore quite difficult to fashion them into usetul shapes like wires, because of the brittleness of ceramics.

For another, there are problems inherent in super-conduction that limit its usefulness, even at relatively high temperatures. And in any case, the potential savings turn out to be not so high.

Goodstein looked at the US power transmission system (similar to the UK National Grid) to illustrate these limitations. The potential savings are only some 10% of the power generated: ie. present losses through heating of Rubicon Beach by Steve Erikson. Futura (£4.50) A man is taken from prison after he repeated a joke which hanged a friend, a joke that he cannot remember the last line of. Rubicon Beach is set in a world which only has the name of familiarity; all else is strangely foreign.

It is a book which merges love with fantasy, ghosts and dreams and a haunting surrealism, beckoning to a deep longing which is the secret of darkness of the rubicon. Maybe the best novel I've read this year. Velocity by Kristin McCloy. Hutchinson (£5.95)

A girl returns home to a small town hopelessly wrong, Eddie is the one to spell it out. "Talent don't mean nothin'! Look at who's facing a jail sentence, then look where they are - Rothstein, Comiskey, and the others! Out in the back room cutting up profits. That's the goddamned conspiracy!"

He's right. The gamblers, the crooks, all made money on the overhead or underground cables are only 10% of the electrical energy passed through them. This is achieved by reducing the current and stepping up the voltage.

Since heat loss depends on the square of the current, reducing this by, say, a factor of 10 reduces heat Loss by a factor of 10 squared, or This system is only possible with alternating current as the transformers that increase and decrease the voltage only work on a.c. However, superconduction only works with direct current.

Superconduction would also require refrigeration of the entire power transmission system. When this was costed in the 1960s, it was found to be a surprisingly small proportion of the total cost of la the Southern USA following her mother's death. Father and daughter cannot face each other, let alone the loss.

Ellie escapes into a destructive passion with a half-Indian Hell's Angel, consuming herself with lust, trying to burn out the grief.

A novel that deals expertly with the empty, ill-formed and name-only relationships which come to light only after tragedy. An under-rated first novel.

Love Me Tender by Catherine Texier. Paladin (£3.99) Not another novel about New York? Love Me Tender's French author has managed to give a new glow to those bright lights, in an exploration which achieves surprise more than any of its lame predecessors.

It relies on no gimmick or fad, but something much tougher, as it seeks from the beginning to uncover more fully the harsher reality of the beautiful city.

Voices From The Plains by Gianni Celati. Serpent's series, while the players, the "suckers" who did the work, ended up losing everything. It's a parable of capitalist society. Sayles is the chronicler, but he's also on our side, against the men out there cutting up the profits.

I saw it three times in one week. You owe it to yourself to see it at least once.

superconducting. power transmis sion system. This was way before the discovery of HTSC.

The major problem though would be the instability of the system. Goodstein cites the example of a lightning strike, hardly a rare occurrence for overhead power lines. This would result in a local overheating and a breakdown of superconduction. This would lead to a runaway heating in both directions along the power lines.

Before the refrigeration system could cope, the entire power transmission system of the country could melt down. Goodstein suggests that most engineers would find this "embarrassing"

Next week, I'll look at a field where superconduction is useful but where HTSC is nevertheless unlikely to be of much use.

Tail (£6.95)

No phrase and no description is wasted. Voices From The Plains is an immaculate collection of searching stories which are part fable, recounted in the greatest of fireside traditions.

it is utterly refreshing to find a story teller whose energy is not wasted. Like water to the fire in the desert, he uses only the precise amount words to achieve the desired effect. At times enchanting, these thirty stories should be read.

Death. Granta 27 Death is the title of the latest collection of Burford's magazine Granta. The selection focuses on death, the strongest and most complete ending any story could have. There are contributions from Edmund White (The Beautiful Room is Empty), Mary McCarthy (Memories of a Catholic Girlhood, an excellent piece titled Glitches by John Gregory Dunne, and a photo-realism story.

Granta never fails to pack diversity, regularly and well.

----- pull-quotes -----

the Stalinist states, arguing that Trotsky's

Duncan Chapel continues the debate.

LES HEARN SE COLLUMIN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 411

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →