How not to reform party conference
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Model amendments for Labour Party Lambeth wavers on poll tax very passing day seems to bring a new tale of chaos and confusion involving the The new Environment Secretary Chris Patten may come over better on the telly than his unloved predecessor, Nicholas Ridley, but he has inherited the task of implementing the single most unpopular measure the present government nas yet come up with.
A Tory backbench revolt was simmering before the summer recess as the government became entangled in its own "safety net" proposals. Even small business people and the shire county squirearchy are up in arms now that the full implications of the poll tax are sinking in.] The registration process has been thrown into chaos in many areas because local councils are demanding information that contravenes the Data Protection Act. Hundreds of thousands of registration forms have had to be withdrawn, amended and re-issued after the Data Protection Registrar refused to allow Trafford Council in Greater Manchester, to transfer information from poll tax forms onto its computer. The Department of the Environment has confirmed that forms sent out by dozens of other councils including Richmond on Thames, Hounslow, Solihull, Watford, Epsom and Ewell, Chelmsford and Winchester) "seem to" contravene the law. This week, the first steps to prosecute 22 councils believed to have contravened the Data Protection Act will begin.
The government has been forced to admit that councils cannot insist on being provided with any information other than the idenity of household members who will be 18 or over when the tax is due to be introduced in April of next year — and no one person in any household can be committed to providing this information.
Partly as a result of these setbacks, and partly because of grassroots resistance (both organised and spontaneous) the rate of return for registration forms has been very low. In some areas as few as 40% of the forms have been returned and even in Birmingham - which is supposed to have one of the highest rates of return in England - the figure is still only 70% and that probably includes all those who sent back their forms incomplete and unsigned.
Meanwhile, in Scotland (where the poll tax has been in operation since April about half a million people have still not paid. At a recent conference of senior officials from local authorities Bill Anderson, Registration Officer for Tayside, said he had "never known a piece of legislation cause such widespread unrest, dissatisfaction and outright hostility." He was sure that "officers dealing with England and Wales will suffer similarly"
A sign of the panic gripping many local authorities came last week with the decision by Trafford Council to back off from prosecuting Labour councillor Sean Rogers for refusing to fill in a registration form. Despite the fact that Rogers offered to pay the £50 fine, the Registration Officer told him he was no longer required to fill in the form. The Department of the Environment now say that no-one is legally bound to complete the form, only to supply the information required - by writing a letter, for instance.
Of course, the battle against the poll tax is far from having been won. A particular problem is that the level of organised opposition within the unions is nowhere near as widespread as it is at community level. But the signs are that the government is in serious trouble. Those like the Labour leadership (and the SWP!) who long ago declared the anti-poll tax campaign dead, have been shown to be (in the words of Mark Twain) somewhat premature, to say the least.
Lambeth Council's ruling Labour Group is deeply divided by the recent decision to buy a poll tax computer system.
When the left recently won control of the Labour Group, they promised a real campaign of defiance against the Tory tax, which immediately meant freezing all expenditure on the poll tax - not completing the purchase of the computer system, for instance. This opposition collapsed in the face of the poll tax officers' threats and a major opportunity to mobilise support behind the coun cil's non-implementation stance was lost.
The eader, The Labour leaders hae used the Policy Review as a way to bypass the democratic procedures of Party conference. A motion to Labour Party conference from the GMB (GMW section) seeks to extend the principle.
The motion is full of fine words about "greater involvement by Party members" "more representative of all sections of the membership", "expanding the role of Conference" , and so on. Its real drift is just the opposite.
The GMB wants to change the makeup of the National Executive so that it would include representatives of Labour councillors and of Euro-MPs. In practice this would have to mean electing the National Executive piecemeal, from the Euro-MPs' caucus, the conference of Labour councillors, Labour regional conferences, and so on. All direct control by Party conference over the National Executive would be removed, Then most of the Conference would be given over to considering reports from "policy commissions" set up by the National Executive. In principle such a system of commissions could be good. In practice we can be certain what the GMB wants is a system where Constituency Labour Parties' right to propose policy will be eliminated and the Conference will have no role but to rubber-stamp a series of take-it-orleave-it packages from the Party leadership.
There is a lot of now arguing that the 'tactic" should be a "rolling programme of opposition", identifying key issues on which to fight. If councillors are "forced to concede on a particular issue, then we must be ready to go on the offensive on other aspects of the legislation."
But at no point should this opposition leave councillors open to surcharge! For Joan Twelves, fighting the poll tax apparently means making a lot of noise about how awful the Tories are, how the poll tax is a threat to civil liberties, and 'grudgingly' implementing the tax.
This retreat from the non-implementation policy has led to the split among the left in Lambeth Labour Group, with other councillors arguing GMB motion. It concludes with a call to change the balance of voting at conference, so that CLPs will control about half the votes instead of only six per cent or so. as at present.
conference To motion 114 from Wallasey CLP Rights at Work):
In lines 13-4, delete "and for unions to gain recognition'; insert "for unions to gain recognition, and for elected union workplace representatives to have facilities to do their job".
In line 15, delete "the right to stop at work": insert "the right to inspections of all workplaces by Health and Safety Executive inspectors, and the right to stop work"
In line 21, delete "by the courts"; insert "by the courts or any other state tribunal"
To motion 14 from Cooperative Coaches to the Cardiff: £6 (E4 unwaged)
Museum Steps: phone Roger Phillips, 0222 232153, Oxford: £5 (E3 unwaged) from Martyrs Memorial, Cowley Rd T&G, Swan, Cowley, Headington PO:
that the council stand by its promises and refuse to implement the tax.
These councillors also call for all Lambeth Labour councillors to refuse to register and pay, to work with local. community groups and, in particular, local trade unionists and Labour Party activists in building up the anti-poll tax campaign. They want Lambeth to organise outside the borough, to gain support for its action and to attempt to win other boroughs to their position.
We should be supporting the stand taken by these councillors and campaigning in the labour movement for solidarity from other councils and trade unionists to ensure that Lambeth is not left isolated.
The notion of giving CLPs more say in Conference is widely supported. But it's no good if it goes together with depriving Conference of any real say in the Party, Retail Services (on the Policy Review):
In line 4, delete "vote on all those sections of the Policy Review document where these conflict with the resolutions which secured majority support OT where ambiguous wording or omission in the Policy Review text could give rise to widely differing interpretations" and insert "vote where a part of the Policy Review document conflicts with a resolution which secured majority support, so that Conference may choose between the resolution and the appropriate part of the Review document"
Lines 9-10;
Time To Go demo phone Gerard Ward, 0865 779552.
Nottingham: from Salutation Inn, Maid Marion Way: phone Dave Goodfield, 0602 782925.
Birmingham: £6 (E3 unwaged) from Cambridge St, Birmingham city centre: phone Mark Mollina, 021 449 4453 or Mick Maughan, 021 384 7438.Newham: £3 approx: ring 01 7438 for details.
Edinburgh: phone TTG office for details, 01 624 7438.
Glasgow: €15 from NALGO office, Cochrane St.
Manchester: £8 (E6 unwaged) from DHSS Aytoun St, tickets from Grassroots Books: phone Dick, 061 223 4470.
Liverpool: E10 (E5 unwaged) fron Shakespeare Pub, Rose St gyratory, 6.30am: phone Mike Maguire, 051 548 0001 (w); 051 521 5887 (h).
Sheffiald: £6 (E3 unwaged) from Paternoster Row, 7.30am: phone Brian McCaul, 0742 663090.
Bristol: E4 (E3 unwaged) from Anchor Road, behind the Watershed 9am: phone Chris Murray 0272 559961.