Rail: did we win or lose?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-08-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Or by day riday 28 July: 300-strong lobby : ocks delegate meeting which vote or strike to be stepped up, Todd ta pur country. T&G drivers to be intructed not to cross pickets. T&G xec is to meet on Tuesday to conider ways of backing dockers. 9-30 July: Weekend meetings at outhampton and Hull to discuss trike. Todd refuses to attend. fonday 31 July: Dockers at all weight behind stopping nofficial strike action.
Sheerness was left to make a local cal. Indeed. Bill Morris, speaking the Scottish TUC as acting eneral Secretary talked of naonal and local negotiations. This time should have been used • mobilise dockers. It should have sen used to hammer out demands ad a strategy to win them and aild a propaganda machine to get eir case across to the rest to the bour movement.
Port bosses used this time to their Ivantage. They sounded out local pals. They put the screws on invidual dockers and began a proaganda barrage which was to ominate the strike. Churning out idless figures about how the strike as crumbling from day one. By the first week of the strike, the osses' shipping paper, the Lloyds ist could say it is understood that aborate plans were laid weeks ago y individual companies to feed tipments into the UK through orts unattected by the dispute" irms had also had 4 months teathing space to build up stocks › ride out the strike.
In contrast the T&G secured inrational support only after a ort shop stewards, delegation sited Europe. On the eve of the rike Transport House still did not ave a bank account number for the ockers solidarity fund account! T&G drivers were not instructed 1 respect picket lines. In the first eek of the strike dockers at Felixowe rejected an 8.2% pay offer vith strings). A titanic effort could ad should have been made to bring lem out alongside scheme' ports. istead they settled for an extra Southampton and Fleetwood go back under the threat of the sakc.
70 dockers at Tilbury rejoin the strike.
Tuesday 1 August: T&G Exec votes by 18-12 to call off national strike. Bristol, Liverpool, Teesside, Ipswich stay out for local deals. Thursday 3 August: 4 more ports vote to go back. Only Liverpool left out. Port bosses give a deadline of 5pm Friday to sign new contracts, extended till Monday 5pm. Monday 7 August: Todd speaks at a mass meeting in Liverpool, and it votes to return to work. 12%.
Todd himself should have been out on the picket lines of ports where the strike was less solid. Instead rank and file dockers at Liverpool were left trying to hold things together.
The sacking of 140 dockers at Tilbury, picking off stewards and 'ultimatums was clearly a major escalation. By the end of the week 550 had returned and the union had been derecognised.
This undoubtedly helped pull dockers together and led to the call from the docks delegate conference to step up the action.
But then Todd refused to attend mass meetings at Hull and Southampton. Even the bosses' Financial Times asked "If Mr Ron Todd had been intent on mass meetings to stem the return to work why did he not visit Hull or Southampton before vital votes over the weekend?" These votes to return the following Monday were then used by the T&G Executive to call off the strike.
Todd's argument that 'you can only have leadership if you have an army prepared to fight' is an indictment of himself. Twice the dockers voted by 3 to 1 for an all-out strike. Seventy workers at Tilbury came back out on strike, risking their jobs and redundancy pay, when they believed the union was prepared to back them. Faced with such hard nosed managements and massive redundancy payments, what more could be expected of them?
Todd was not denied his army led by the shock battalions of Liverpool. He led them blindly into an ambush without a plan of battle. By a railworker The National Union of suspended its series of 24-hour strikes on 27 July so as to meet British Rail's demand that talks on the negotiating machinery could not be held "with a pistol at their heads".
Meanwhile the 8.8% pay offer was accepted, as it already had been by the leadership of the other rail unions, ASLEF (drivers) and TSSA (clericals).
So did we win or lose? Certainly we got a bigger pay rise than BR intended paying, 8.8% instead of 7% - and even 7% was only coughed up in thè hope of heading off industrial action this year.
The 8.8%, without strings, was won after our fourth one-day strike on 12 July. It was then that ASLEF and TSSA accepted it, leaving the NUR isolated. Many members of both those unions are disgusted at their leaderships' acceptance which made it fairly inevitable that the NUR would be unable to increase the pay deal.
BR were then able to take up their obstinate stance of refusing any further money or any further talks on machinery until the action was called off. Two further 24-hour strikes on 18 and 26 July failed to shift that position.
Certainly BR were emboldened in this by the signals they were receiving. The 18 July strike was only confirmed 90 minutes before it was due to start. Despite the fact that it was as strong among the rank and file as all the others the delay showed evidence of a split among the NUR leadership.
The news that later came out, of a 12 to 8 majority (with one absent) on the union Executive for continuing the action, and Knapp in favour of calling it off was the signal for a media witch-hunt. The hard left it seemed had duped just enough moderates to bring another day of chaos to Britain's hard pressed commuters.
On the Executive, general secretary Jimmy Knapp had talked up BR's concessions on the machinery. But what had been said at talks was not borne out in black and white. When the documents arrived (half an hour after the deadline for accepting them the changes were absolutely minimal.
The National Conference prowould also conduct a 'general pay review", , it would also discuss *industry-wide collective bargaining principles" and London Allowance.
But the five "Functions' into which BR was to be divided would remain crucial. The only other concession was that the machinery could include non-binding arbitration when referred by one side only. And that was it.
There was nothing else. The left had to keep the pressure up and reject the document as grossly inadequate, way below what could have been achieved. Only through outwitting the right-wing who were unable to argue that anything substantial had been gained, was the sixth 24-hour strike called on 26 July.
By then the strike showed signs of fraying at the edges - though nothing of any substance. BR's figures of 12,500 returning to work and 400 trains were wild exaggeraTHE tions; and evenif wholly true, way below anything that they could have expected from their efforts to get people back to work. The sixth 24-hour strike hurt them just as much as the other five.
The few who did refuse to come out on the sixth day did so because of the splits in the leadership. Knapp made it known that he wanted to settle. Kinnock sticking the boot in didn't help, of course.
The national officers of the union didn't do much about the media barrage. The impression given was that the NUR dispute was only about money and since the other unions had accepted the NUR could win no more. Many railworkers tended to agree even while loyally supporting the action.
The fact that there were two issues was lost. The union top officials failed to give replies to this media barrage. Even the newspaper advertisement on the eve of the 26 July strike, good though it was, concentrated on the pay issue.
Knapp thinks he has got what he wanted on the bargaining issue — a role in national negotiations for the general secretary of the NUR -and so union propaganda reflected that.
All of this contributed to a decline in morale among the membership, with some returning, while the activists flooded Head Office with messages and resolutions demanding that the issue of the right to effective negotiations not be forgotten.
The activists are only too aware of the need for national negotiations, but also for local power to back these up, to make national pay and conditions of service only the base line that we can work within. Without local power, effectively recognition of the union at local level, which is policy, BR can divide and rule, making concessions only where 'market forces' dictate they must and so corrode any national concessions from within.
But the issue of local negotiating rights has not even been discussed.
At the meeting that called off the action, the left on the Executive submitted a minority report. It said that the action should be suspended until 16 August, giving BR time to make concessions and the union time to regroup. This was thrown out in favour of accepting BR's terms (though the action has only been 'suspended'), the money taken and talks to be held at ACAS to work out a new Machinery of Negotiation before BR's new abolition date for our current negotiating rights of 31 January 1990. Now the pistol is at our heads.
If our unions leaders are left to themselves now, nothing much will happen. The pressure is off BR and they need concede nothing more, and without pressure from the activists the union leadership won't fight for it.
The government is looking for replacements for its 'hard men' on the BR board who proved foolish and incompetent in their handling of the dispute. The remit of the replacements when they are found won't be to be nice to the unions now that we have shown a little of our potential power, but to undo what concessions have been made. The Tories want to get BR straight back on to the road of privatisation and there's no room for an uppity workforce in that.
The left in the three main rail unions need to spend the next few months working out what we do next. We need to decide exactly what we need to fight for and what doesn't matter. And we need to work out how to make the unions fight for it.
Without pressure and organisation nothing more will be gained on the right to negotiate. BR will concede only where they have to. We need to ensure that the Executive's sentiments agreed on calling off the dispute become reality: that accepting 8.8% is only the prelude to a vigorous campaign against low pay ready for next year and that we really do mean to keep up the pressure on the right to negotiate.
That done, this dispute is not over. We can expect BR's attacks to intensify in the next months now that the Tories have gOt the dockers' dispute out of the way and new hatchet men are brought in. If the NUR is to stay true to its policy then BR will need to be forced to negotiate seriously again.
This task falls to the Broad Left in the NUR. But it will need to build itself as a rank and file movement rather than as a group of people in the know who ensure that the right people get put forward for elections. The strength that a rank and file movement could provide, pEoviding hackbone unionespecially during disputes, could have made the difference this time round. This dispute has been run and settled (so far) according to the needs of the national leadership rather than the needs of the rank and file.
The strike overall has been a success, re-invigorating and uniting the union, winning concessions on negotiating rights and more pay for the membership. But if we remain with what has been gained so far all of of that will be eroded in the not too distant future.
Keeping what we've got and getting back much of what has been lost over the last decade will only be achieved if the union acts in the interests of the rank and file.
Scan page 8
Neil Kinnock may think that the new, ever-sopale-pink Policy Review is the way forward, but Labour activists do not agree.
Of 33 submissions on the Policy Review in the resolution book for this year's Labour Party conference, only two back the Party leadership. 31 criticise the attempt to bypass regular Party policymaking through the Review, and 25 specifically demand that conference decisions should override the Policy Review where there is conflict.
The National Executive is insisting that no amendments to the Policy Review can be debated at the conference.
Green issues, nuclear disarmament, electoral reform and trade union rights also loom large on the agenda.
71 Constituency Labour Parties have sent in motions calling for a stronger environmental policy. Of the 68 motions on armaments, the great majority, including one from the Manufacturing, Science and Finance union MSF, call for unilateral nuclear disarmament and Teject Neil Kinnock's moves to drop that policy.
There are 47 motions about constitutional reform in one way or another. Of those, 37 support a changed voting , system, some specifically favouring proportional representation, single transferable vote, or alternative vote, most just calling for the National Executive to prepare a report.
A number of motions replacement of the House of Lords by an elected chamber, for a Bill of Rights, or for compulsory voting.
The motions favouring electoral reform are from a range of constituencies, both urban and rural, both left and righ. Those on the left who insist on rejecting all forms of proportional representation out of hand are painting themselves into an untenable corner, because the present "first-past-the-post' system in indefensibly arbitrary and undemocratic.
26 Constituency Labour Parties and five trade unions have sent in motions on Rights at Work' all demanding, in one way or another, restoration and improvement of the workers' and trade union rights attacked by this Tory government.
Ten motions specifically demand that the next Labour government legislate a 'Workers' Charter' including the right to strike, the right to picket, the right to organise and so on, and motions from Wallasey, Broxtowe and Sheffield Central spell out a detailed list for this Charter. - There are 25 motions on health, 19 on education, 18 on housing, and 13 on transport - including one from the TGWU which contains a call for the next Labour government to restore the Dock Labour Scheme.
There are ten motions on the Poll Tax. Brighton Kemptown and Liverpool Riverside CLPs (under Militant influence) call for mass non-payment; Glasgow Govan and Bow & Poplar also call for non-cooperation by trade unions and chaos Labour councils.
Nine CLPs have submitted versions of the Black Sections model motion, calling for the party to recognise the Black Sections. Only five CLPs have sent in motions on Northern Ireland (all variants of the "Time To Go' policy), making it unlikely that this issue will reach conference floor.
Perhaps surprisingly, the Common Market looks like being another issue which won't win conference time. Only two CLPs have submitted motions, both calling for the European Parliament to become a sovereign democratic authority. Some other motions on 1992 and the 'Social Charter' have been tucked away in the 'Rights at Work' section of the agenda.
Only one motion has been submitted on China.
Amendments have to be submitted by 18 August and the conference takes place on 1-6 October in Brighton.