Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A victory for gangsters, thugs and bully-boys

Socialist Organiser no. 411, 10 August 1989 · scan p. 6 · about 1,296 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Wise Fart of the labom hat effect will the the rest of the labour movement?

London Port bosses set a new precedent in industrial gangsterism and managerial dictatorship. They sacked 16 stewards at Tilbury, derecognising the union. They issued ultimatums - sign new contracts in 24 hours or you are sacked.

Of course not all of Britain's bosses are in a position to dictate terms that way - but many must have looked on enviously, approvingly and with the thought that they might try the same thing some time if the port bosses succeeded.

In the short term 'non scheme" ports will come into the firing line. Already bosses at Felixstowe and Dover will be planning to undercut wages and conditions in the wake of the strike.

As the port employers federation breaks up, competition will speed up this process. The argument that all Britain's dockers had a common fight is likely to be brought home more concretely.

On a European scale, the defeat of the dockers in Britian will encourage bosses on the continent to stick the boot into their workforces. French port employers already have plans.

Arguably the 'New Realists' in the labour movement will be boosted too. After all they live and breathe off defeat and demoralisation.

Todd is not a typical 'new realist.

The strike was characterised more by blundering and incompetence than a calculated drive for compromise. A new realist, after all, could have made sure no national strike took place at all. And certainly elements within the T&G wanted to have nothing to do with it.

Todd does not easily fit the pattern - he seemed genuinely enraged at the strike Tilbury sackings and did not counsel caution at the Docks Delegate meeting that called to step up the strike.!

Maybe now those who advocate a colder more hard-faced line of dumping supposedly 'unwinnable' struggles will gain ground.

This won't necessarily depress trade union struggle on all fronts. In the current situation of reduced unemployment, skill shortages in many trades, high profits and high inflation, many wages battles are winnable in anybody's terms. Many sections of workers have proved it by winning wage rises way above the odds. The encouraging effects of those victories will not be wiped out by the dockers' defeat.

If we build on that boost to workers' confidence we can offset and overcome the setbacks stemming from the docks defeat. looks at the reasons defeat of the dockers' Three lessons stand out clearly from the 3 week dispute. One is the need for socialists and trade union militants to draw up their own battle plans to take on management and win disputes. Too often we fight on unfamiliar and unfavourable territory.

Linked to this is the need to build up living, breathing, rank and file movements throughout the unions. Once the Port Shops Stewards Committee could take hold of a dispute despite union leaders and carry dockers with them. In this dispute they found themselves too weak to take an independent line and make it stick.

Finally the T&G were hoist by their own petard. From the outset Todd insisted that the law was sacrosanct and he would have to wage a legal strike. He made big mistakes even within the limits of that framework. It was right to try to minimise clashes with the law; but any responsible union leader also had to recognise that at the end of the day dockers would probably have to challenge the laws or succumb quietly.

The union should have built an effective strike and used every opening to get arguments across to 'non-scheme' dockers, transport and other workers.

In this way it should have been preparing the ground for solidarity action so that when shop stewards were picked off at Tilbury and ultimatums fired at rank and file dockers the union too could have stepped up its offensive.

The stronger and more general the solidarity action, the less likely the laws would be used. Midnight 11-12 July: Strike starts. Monday 17 July: European unions pledge support. Rochester votes to go back.

Tuesday 18 July: Poole votes to go back.

Wednesday 19 July: Under the threat of the sack, 350 at Grimsby and Immingham go back. Boston, Hull and Goole go back. Over 200 dockers are sacked at Grimsby and Immingham after returning to work. Monday 24 July: Southampton an Hull vote to stay on strike.

Tuesday 25 July: Dockers are With hindsight the union tional agreement could not be won" argued TGWU leader Ron Todd last Tuesday, 1 August after calling off the national docks strike. *They" said a Tilbury shop steward *have voted for us to get the sack"

The decision by the T&G Executive was a black day for the trade union movement.

It was a betrayal of the Liverpool dockers who had sent pickets across the country to spread and breathe more life into the strike. They were left isolated against the bosses ultimatums to go back 'or else' — "a sugar coated bullet' as one steward put it.

It was a betrayal of those sacked at Tilbury including the 16 shop stewards who were picked out and issued with redundnacies. Dockers at Tilbury now face a battle to reunionise their workforce.

And it was a betrayal of the 70 Tilbury dockers who had rejoined the strike after the docks delegate decision just the Friday before 28 July to step up the action. They were force to go back to work on Wednesday 2nd.

The most astonishing contrast in the 3 week strike was the way in which the two sides had prepared for it.

The T&G leaders bumbled on from one crisis to another without a clear strategy of organising an effective strike, and sinking feelers into the rest of the labour movement to call on their support. But no benefit of hindsight" was necessary sacked at Tilbury, including all 16Tilbury shop stewards. The rest of the workforce are given till 5pm Wednesday to sign new contracts and return. Liverpool dockers also receive threats.

Wednesday 26 July: Some dockers return at Tilbury.

Thursday 27 July: More dockers return at Tilbury. 7 sacked with no compensation. to realise it would nothing dispute.

Port bosses had been planning to scrap the National Dock Labour Scheme for years. They fiercely lobbied back bench Tory MP's. They even drew up a detailed plan 18 months ago, to break a national strike.

They followed those battle tactics to the letter:

• The use of the law:

• Waging a propaganda war.

• Strikebreaking - though in the end they achieved this through ultimatums.

• Contingency plans to move essential supplies in and out of the country.

The T&G leaders knew of this doe enemy. tended to what tactics they failed to develop a strategy for their own side. How many more times must we allow this to happen before learning the lessons?

The sudden about-face by Todd between Friday 28 July and Tuesday 1 August was only the last in a series of crisis reactions to the initiatives of port bosses.

The union must have known the law would become an issue immediately in the case of a strike call. Yet they had made no preparations beforehand to deal with this, nor to think of a way of including 'nonscheme' ports in the action.

It is perfectly reasonable that the unions should try to get round Tory trade union laws. But there were unnecessary delays. It took over a month to organise the first strike ballot. After a month of legal wrangles it took another 3 weeks to ballot fewer than 10,000 dockers.

In the meantime Todd threw his

----- pull-quotes -----

Ray Ferris behind the

bosse he union

HOTELS CROW OFFIGAL STRIKE da The strike

had didn't

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 411

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →