Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[• national conference for thi movement organised by…]

Socialist Organiser no. 411, 10 August 1989 · scan p. 4 · Martin Thomas · about 784 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

• national conference for thi movement organised by the ovement organised by Saturday: registration 10.30am, conference 1.00am-5.00pm; Sunday 10.00am-4.00pn ntials: E6 waged, £4 unwaged from The So Conference, 9 Poland St, London W1V 3DG national left in Socialist Conference Saturday 11'and Sunday 12 November Sheffield Polytechnic Students Union Pond St (opposite rail station)

Fidel Castro conference the trade union LETITERS tan Crooke (letters, SO 409) declares that i am "simply wrong"

*One need merely ask the question why workers in capitalism go to work and why workers in the Soviet Union go to work (insofar as they bother to do so) to recognise the qualitative difference between the Soviet economy and a capitalisttype economy."

I think Stan would say that the answer to the question is that in capitalist society we go to work from economic compulsion — we have to sell our labour power in order to be able to buy food, clothes, housing and so on -whereas in the Soviet Union they work because of political compulsion (and, he would presumably argue, the food, clothes, housing, etc are provided politically too.

Political compulsion does play a bigger role in the Soviet Union than in the West. Yet there is a qualitative difference between ordinary workers in the USSR and those in labour camps. For ordinary workers, the major compulsion to work is economic.

If not, then why do the bureaucrats fear workers' resistance to their plans to increase unemployment? Why do the bosses in the USSR and Eastern Europe use piecework pay systems SO much? (See Zbigniew Kowalewski's article in Workers' Liberty 11, for example.

If wages are just a meaningless token, concealing the real business of exploitation through political compulsion, then why do workers like the Soviet miners who struck recently demand pay rises? And sometimes win them? Why do workers in price rises, 1980? in the USSR the Eastern Bloc resist as they did in Poland in Both the bureaucrats' and the workers' actions in the class struggle between them indicate that it really is wage labour in the Eastern Bloc, even though with special teatures.

Stan summarises my argument on the Eastern Bloc like this: "Look, there's a bit of a market in the Soviet Union, so we'll say it's really a kind of state-capitalist economy"

I'm aware that "a bit of a market" , in fact a large sphere of market economy, can exist without capitalism. Whether the Eastern Bloc systems are state-capitalist is determined not only by how the working class is reproduced, but also by how the exploiting class and the whole system of production are reproduced.

On that side things are more complex. Investment is largely still regulated by government decision, not by markets, even bad markets. The question is, how does the Our Labour Party General Committee in mid-Sussex recently presented Margaret Dewar, veteran local Trotskyist, with an ILP plaque and a copy of Jan Valtin's 'Out of the Night' (Fortress), in recognition of her services to Socialism.

Margaret Dewar was a schoolgirl in Russia at the time of the Bolshevik revolution. Her family later moved to Germany, where she was active in Trotsky's Left Opgovernment regulate these matters? Badly, of course - but what is the basic drift of what they do badly?

I submit that an examination of the criteria and patterns of the government regulation show it to be capitalist in type, concerned with expanding the state-owned total capital in competition with other capitals world-wide.

The surplus is pumped from the workers, production is expanded, and the basic social classes are reproduced in a fundamentally capitalist way. It's certainly a "deformed" sort of capitalism, and I can well understand those who argue that it is so "deformed" that we'd best not call it capitalist at all.

Those like Stan, however, who argue that there is no surplus produced, or at least no-one controls it, that there is no regular process of reproduction of the social classes, and indeed that there is no ruling class and not much of a working class either, just do not begin dealing with the central issues.

Martin Thomas Islington position.

Fleeing the Nazis, she eventually came to Britain, and married Hugo Dewar, an ex-member of the pioneer British Trotskyist organisation, the Balham Group!

Her autobiography, "The Quiet Revolutionary' (Bookmarks), is a remarkable life story which concludes: "Obviously I am disappointed that it is taking so long for the revolution to materialise. But come it must, if exploitation of man by man is to end and mankind is to survive. It is now up to the younger generation to give a lead."

Richard Hanford

----- pull-quotes -----

Which way forward for tl

left in the unions?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 411

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →