Workers Liberty
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
willing to collaborate in this government, it was necessary to work with the government of Tzannis Tzannetakis in order to ensure that the process of 'catharsis' was set in motion.
At present it is too early to guage the effect of this betrayal on the supporters of the Left Coalition. Certainly some will refuse to vote for the Left Coalition in the fortheoming elections because they reject the argument that the Left Coalition is not actually collaborating with a New Democracy government. But the demand for 'catharsis' is very strong and many supporters of the left may be prepared to tolerate this arrangement is it does lead to greater democratisation of, in particular, the mass media. Also, the only voice raising any criticism at all of the new coalition government is that of the now very discredited Pasok party.
But the biggest The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction a or race"
Become a supporter of Workers' Liberty! You pay contribution to help us publish the magazine; we send you the magazine and mailings about Workers" Liberty activities and events Supporter's contribution: Marx minimum £25 waged, E12.50 unwaged per yearwhich includes the next 4 issues of Workers' Liberty.
Write to Workers' Liberty, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Phone: 01 639 7965
Scan page 6
Rosa Luxembura and Lenin - leaders of the left wing of the Second International joint meeting of British and French Social-Democratic Party. (Social trade unionists launched the Inter- Democratic then meant Marxist).
Marx was able to play a big role more and more votes - from in this movement, but it was never 102,000 in 1871 to 1,787,000 in Marxist. The main forces involved 1893. "If [the growth] continues in were Proudhonists in France, who this fashion, by the end of the cenadvocated a sort of socialism based tury we shall conquer the greater on small worker cooperatives, and part of the middle strata of societhe still fairly conservative British ty...and grow into the decisive After the Paris workers' uprising growth going without interruption of 1871, the First International fell until it of itself gets beyond the conanart. torn two wavs. A sizeable trol of the nrevailing governmental Karl Kautsky, the main theorist of the Second International Martin Thomas looks at the history of the Socialist International which was founded 100 years ago this month and remained movement until One hundred years ago this month the Socialist International was founded in Paris.
The 25 years after that, from 1889 to 1914, were, or at least seemed to be, a golden age for Marxist working-class politics. The world labour movement grew steadily, united under Marxist banners.
Socialism had first emerged as an organised political movement almost 100 years before 1889. The French Revolution of 1788-94 had proclaimed the goal of liberty, fraternity and equality. The bourgeois leaders of the Revolution, however, saw equality only as formal equality before the law.
Some radicals talked about dividing up all the land equally, so that every tamily could have a little plot. One revolutionary, Gracchus Babeuf, came to understand that not even that division could create real equality in a system based on private property and free trade.
In the competition between producers, inevitably, some would win and some would lose; society would divide into those who owned the land, factories and mines and those who could live by selling only Labour power.
Babeuf resolved to fight for common ownership of the wealth of society. He organised a 'Conspiracy of Equals'. The police broke it up and arrested Babeuf before they could do anything, but Babeuf's ideas lived on, inspiring a whole current of socialist activity.
In 1847 Marx and Engels joined a group which was part of that current, the Communist League. They wrote the Communist Manifesto, which redefined socialist politics on a new basis.
Instead of secret societies, organising underground until they would be strong enough to launch a coup and establish a revolutionary dictatorship which would implement their socialist blueprint, they looked to the mass struggle of the growing industrial working class.
In 1848 revolutions exploded across Europe. They were middle-class revolutions, for democracy, national unity, and national freedom; but in the course of them, in France especially, the workers came forward with their own demands.
After the revolutions subsided, mostly defeated, many members of the Communist League continued to talk feverishly about organising new uprisings. Marx told them they were dreaming. The working class would have to learn and develop over decades of struggle before it could take power.
Marx and Engels found themselves isolated, while the first mass workers' movement, the Chartists in Britain, dwindled and collapsed, capitalism boomed, and conservative bread-and-butter trade unionists took the leadership of the British working class.
A new beginning came in 1864. A national Working Men's Association, or First International.
trade union leaders.
contingent of anarchists rebelled against Marx's "authoritarianism" and the British trade union leaders recoiled in horror from Marx's vigorous defence of the revolution in Paris.
But the industrial working class was now becoming a sizeable force in countries outside Britain. Workers' parties developed in Germany and France. The 1889 congress brought them together.
In fact there were two socialist congresses in Paris in 1889, one hosted by the French comrades of Marx and Engels, the other by the so-called "Possibilist" party, so called because of their emphasis on going for WIdE galls were possible" within capitalism, especially through trying to get positions in local government.
After much frantic factionalising, the "Marxist" congress turned out to be the stronger, and the "Possibilist" international faded In 1895 Engels wrote his last major political article before he died, an introduction to a pamphlet of Marx's. He could rejoice at the steady and, it seemed, unbeatable progress of what was now the strongest contingent of the world labour movement, the German Steadily since 1871, the Social-Democratic Party (SPD) had won power in the land...To keep this system, that is the main task."
But the way this very article was published signalled ruinous problems ahead. The editors of the German Social-Democrats' magazine cut out passages where Engels indicated that he expected the ruling class to break its own laws to check the rise of the workers' party, and talked of the workers taking to the streets with arms in response. Of course, the editors explained privately, they agreed with Engels; but it was not wise to say such things openly.
In its published version, Engels' article seemed to advocate a purely parliamentary, step-by-step strategy. One leader of the SPD, Eduard Bernstein, drew the conclusion. Around the turn of the century, he started arguing that the SPD should renounce all ideas of revolution and the breakdown of capitalism, and declare itself to be a party of gradual reform.
He had no quarrel, he explained, with the SPD's day-to-day tactics; only with the fact that the SPD leaders continued to talk about that steady day-to-day work somehow leading to a drastic and sudden social overturn some time in the future.
Indeed, trade who sympathised with Bernstein nevertheless told him that he considered all the theoretical argument a waste of time. "One does not say such things, dear Ede. One does them."
On the face of it, Bernstein was roundly rebuffed by successive Party congresses. The Socialist International, with the Germans in the leading role, held to class-struggle principles against all the challenges.
In 1904 it condemned a French socialist, Millerand, who had joined a capitalist government. and reaffirmed its principle "Not a man, not a penny, for this system."
In 1907 right-wingers who reckoned there could be something progressive about European powers holding colonies in Africa and Asia were defeated. In 1912 the International congress passed a stirring resolution against war, committing all socialist parties in the event of war to use the crisis to help bring down capitalism.
All these debates and declarations were more than empty words and wasted ink. They inspired and educated hundreds of thousands of worker revolutionaries.
The Bolshevik party, which was to lead the Russian workers to power in 1917, learned much of its Marxism from those debates. In France, Germany, and Italy, majorities or substantial sections of the socialist parties and their leaders were to rally after 1917 to the struggle to spread the Russian Revolution to other countries.
But in the leading circles of most parties it was different. For them, the revolutionary declarations were mostly empty words.
In 1907 the German SPD had a crisis because, for the first time since the German government had banned the SPD outright in 1878,
Scan page 7
manoeuvres against PLO vote fell. The bourgeois parties d used a colonial war in South est Africa to whip up chauvinism. The SPD right-wing, the Neil nnocks of the day, argued that e party should drop its damaging position to colonialism. The left ng said that, on the contrary, the rty should increase its agitation ainst imperialism, militarism and e drive towards world war. The central party leadership comomised. They kept the left wing ilicy of opposition to imperialism but barely mentioned it in the rty's agitation, concentrating incad on domestic bread-and-butter rues.
In 1911 a new storm blew up in e SPD over whether it should itate for political mass strikes to orkers militancy. The left wing id yes. The right wing said General strike is general insense" • The centre said yes, in inciple, but not now.
The Party congress passed volution adopting the political ass strike. as a possible tactic ider certain circumstances - and e central party leaders secretly sured the alarmed trade union aders that under no circumstances suld they actually use this tactic. Those central party leaders, peoe like August Bebel, were not Neil nnocks. Their sympathies were ostly with the left. But their cenal, all-consuming, overwhelming ncern was to keep the party gether and keep it going forards.
In one country - Russia — the irty leaders had a different atude. Lenin approached every gument over strategy and tactics ith the aim of not smoothing it er but of reaching political clarity id uniting the/movement round that clarity. People like Bebel saw Lenin as an irresponsible splitter, an impractical dogmatist.] History soon proved that Lenin was the practical one. World War I broke out in 1914. Even before the SPD had taken a position, the SPD trade union leaders had met with the German government and agreed to suspend class struggle for the duration in return for a promise by the government not to touch the unions' funds.
The ambiguities in the SPD were blown wide open. For years the party leaders had balanced uneasily between its formal revolutionary politics and the reformist practice of the SPD trade union leaders, men who had a substantial stake in the existing system and were committed to working within it. Now they had to choose.
Bebel had died shortly before the outbreak of war. His successors went with the trade union leaders. They voted in parliament for the government's war budget.
Almost all the parties of the Second International went the same way. Only the Bolsheviks and a couple of others stood firm for class struggle and workers' internationalism.
The Bolsheviks' tireless fight for political clarity made them into a party able to lead the Russian workers to power in 1917. Elsewhere there were no such parties, and the revolutionary upheavals after World War I ended in defeats for the workers.
The Communist Parties formed after World War I continued the struggle for Marxist politics. They hoped by intelligent tactics and tireless struggle to reduce the traitor Social-Democratic parties to tiny cliques and reunite the militant sections of the working class.
They might have done it — except that within a few years of their founding CPs were already being corrupted and derailed by Stalinism. The Social-Democratic parties revived on an openly reformist basis. The CPs were soon no better.
Before 1914 Britain had been the exception among developed capitalist countries, having a sizeable workers' party (the Labour Party) which was openly committed to piecemeal reform within the existing system rather than to Marxist ideas. By the 1940s that exception was the rule.
Since World War Il working-class organisation, as measured by trade union membership and votes for workers' parties, has expanded in a way that the activists of the Socialist International would hardly have believed possible. But the trade untons and parties are almost all reformist, bureaucratic and tied to capitalism.
In a way, we're back to the early 1850s. Both the capitalist classes and the workers' movement have grown a lot and learned a great deal in between times. The working class and its struggles are far more developed - and far more hopeful - today than in the 1850s.
But socialists today do need the tenacity and clarity which enabled Marx and Engels to continue the fight for working-class socialism through decades when the only sizeable industrial working class in the world at the time, the British, showed no inclination for socialism at all.
A renewal of the workers' movement will come in our time, as it came in 1889. And if we have learned the lessons from our forerunners, we can make sure this renewal ends in victory.
*Peace Plan' presented tr it by Prime Minister Shamir and Defence Minister Rabin, whose core is the holding of elections in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Shamir is officially committed to this plan, which bears his name; yet he would shed few tears should the envisaged elections never take place.
Shamir's hope is that the plan will be rejected by the Palestinians, such a rejection would put the Israeli government in strong siplomatic poser in selles the support wavering allies Washington and in the Diaspora Jewish communities. It would also free the government's hands to implement brutal measures of oppression in the Occupied Territories.
No effort was spared in order to make the proposed plan unacceptable to the Palestinians.
It regards the elected Palestinian leaders as a substitute negotiating partner, and explicitly excludes the possibility of negotiations with the PLO. Also excluded is the creation of an independent Palestinian state.
On many other vital points the plan is totally silent. No provision is made for the Palestinians living utside the Occupied Territories who constitute half of the Palestinian people, and who are, in effect, doomed to eternal homelessness. Nor is there any mention of the Palestinian residents. East Jerusalem (which was annexed to Israel) and of their right to participate in the elections.
The holding of free and secret democratic elections' is promised but the plan does not mention any kind of international monitoring, nor does it guarantee the freedom of expression or association during or after the election campaign.] No promise is made to release the thousands of Palestinians incarcerated in Israeli detention camps, who include many leading members of all the Palestinian political factions. Nor is there anything in the plan to prevent the Israeli authorities from arresting candidates for election or the elected representatives themselves as already happened to the Palestinian mayors who were democratically elected in 1976.
Indeed, Shamir explicitly stated that 'if it turns out that the elected Palestinian leaders are accepting instructions from the PLO, we will stop the negotiations and put the leaders in prison'.
After the elections, the plan envisages a five-year interim period in which the Palestinians will exercise *self-administration' of 'their internal affairs' - with the Israeli government maintaining its monopoly over 'defence and security'. It could thus continue to employ its full panoply of repression.
(Even the Camp David agreements provided for the 'redeployment of Israeli forces outside the population centres and the creation of 'a strong Palestinian police force'. Nothing of the kind could be found in the Shamir Plan.)
After the interim period, the plan envisions the opening of peace negotiations between Israel and Jordan; Palestinian representatives are invited to join in - provided they accept the agenda of negotiations, in which the creation of a Yitzhak Shamir Palestinian state will, of course, not be included.
In spite of all the anti-Palestinian stipulations in Shamir's plan, Israel's rightist hardliners became quite alarmed when it was adopted by the cabinet.
The settlers in the Occupied Territories expressed their opposition through violent anti-Arab provocations; Ariel Sharon has started to mobilise a considerable internal opposition to Shamir inside the Likud party; the extreme right Tehiya party stated: "Yitzchak Shamir has laid the cornerstone of the Palestinian state, with East Jerusalem for its capital." (Hadashot, 15.5.89)
Clearly, these opponents are not reacting to the Shamir Plan as it now stands, but rather to the potential shape into which it might be transformed at the end of a long negotiating process - especially since these negotiations would take place under conditions of ongoing Intifada.
On the other side of the political spectrum, the moderate peace camp - Mapam, Ratz, Shinuy and Peace Now - decided to give the plan the benefit of the doubt, hoping that it would eventually develop in the very direction that the extreme right is afraid of.
Similar considerations also prevail in extensive parts of the international arena.
In London, Madrid and Brussels, the Israeli government's proposals were not rejected out of hand; the US administration welcomed the Shamir Plan, while asking for explanations' and 'clarifications' in order to present these clarifications in Tunis.
For its part, the PLO leadership though emphatically rejecting Shamir's terms for elections - has shown itself willing to continue negotiations, in order to achieve more acceptable terms.
One thing should be clear, even to the more optimistic supporters of Israeli-Palestinian peace: whichever scenario materialises, a hard strug gle still lies ahead.
• Taken from The Other Israel.
Since this article was written, Yitzhak Shamir has made important concessions to the Likud hard right, led by former Defence Minister Ariel Sharon. These are:
• non-participation of East Jerusalem residents in any elections in the Occupied Territories;
• elimination of violent Palestinian attacks before any elections;
• the continuation of settlements, • no Palestinian state.
These points are all Likud
Scan page 8
78 80 • TIERTY WASTER YEARS * I
----- pull-quotes -----
an avowedly Marxist mass workers"
• May 14, the Israeli peace i approved the