Soviet workers rise again!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
from page 1 by demonstrating students In Tiananmen Square. The gathering of building workers and others with the miners in the town of Osinniki last week, to protest outside the town hall, was all too reminiscent of Tiananmen for the Soviet authorities.
In imitation of the Tiananmen Square militants, strikers are occupying their local town squares and holding meetings round the clock.
The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race"
Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports: first post As strikes spread to the central industrial zone of the Ukraine, it should not be ruled out that Gorbachev could turn quite as nasty as Deng Xiaoping. The last great reformer in the USSR, Khrushchev, was the man who sent the troops into Hungary in 1956. Gorbachev is a reformer - but if things get out of control, he — or if not him, another representative of the ruling bureaucracy - will do whatever they can to preserve their rule.
Monday or by phone Monday PO Böx 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser.
The almost immediate political focus of the strike is not accidental. Workers' struggles in Eastern Europe have always taken this pattern, because there is so little room for any political expression in those societies. Strikes are the major form of mass political protest.
The rapidly-spreading strikes mean an immense political crisis for Gorbachev. It seems likely, as we go to press, that the crisis will intensify. The USSR could be heading for the sort of pre-revolutionary situation we recently witnessed in Strikes have also been a feature of the various national and ethnic conflicts in the USSR, for the same reason. National oppression is a powerful motor to political protest, and must be so especially in the Ukraine.
Other national or ethnic trouble spots should give socialists less cause for optimism — for example, the current communal conflict in Georgia. But that the miners' strike is spreading beyond the borders of the republics shows it is possible to unite workers of different nationalities.
The miners" strike has scared the Moscow authorities. In the past, strikes have always been isolated and dealt with quickly. In 1962, in Novocherkassk, a workers' uprising was brutally crushed.
Now, a leading Politburo member is trying to negotiate with the strike committee - so far without success. The Soviet media is taking a soft line, repeatedly insisting that the strikers are "beating on an open door."
The strikes follow the recent formation of an independent workers' coordination in the USSR - albeit one closely watched by the authorities.
The labour movement in Britain must be clear whose side it is on. Arthur Scargill, it seems, has been contacted by the striking miners and asked for support. He and others like him must not repeat their shameful failure to support the Polish workers. the middle of last week. First, the Daily Mail carried an NOP opinion poll taken commuters at stations in the South East. showing that 330% of passengers blamed the rail dispute on management, while only 23% blamed the unions. Then, Normal Tebbit gave a press briefing in which he savaged BR management and expressed "every sympathy with the guy on low pay in BR"
This remarkable outburst prominently featured in the Mail and the Sun — the latter adding that, Mr Tebbit's remarks came as it emerged that Mrs Thatcher was furious with BR chiefs for letting peace talks collapse.
Then the Sunday Express earried a front page story headlined "BR bosses face axe after strike fiasco", while the Sunday Times commented that: "Some people wonder whether a BR board that could make Jimmy Knapp, the gruff Scots NUR leader, look statesmanlike were the right people to be running Britain's railways.
In the shadow of the guillotine, can't help feeling just a little sympathy for Ridley and Reid. It has been noted before that when things are going well, Mrs Thatcher claims all the glory for herself, but when things go wrong, , someone else is always to blame, but Citizens Ridley and Reid have, in their different ways, been spectacularly in competent. Perhaps the most propriate epitaph for both of them is the quote from one of Mr Ridley's of ficials" in this Sunday's Observer: •The gods do indeed first drive mad those they shortly intend to destroy."
Scan page 4
Rebel peasant leader Wat Tyler being beheaded - Magna There must be sumething in the shops that people want.
years of odd shoes? Carta wasn't much help to him Margaret Thatcher's M militant philistinism Ion the question of human rights is becoming legendary.
During the French Revolution celebrations, she compared the English feudal barons' charter, the Magna Carta, to the Declaration of the Rights of Man. That was weird enough. Now take a look at her latest human rights appointment.
Step forward Stefan Terlezki, former Tory MP Tor Cardiff West, and champion of the return of hanging, the introduction of birching and the introduction of ID cards, not to mention the wholesale phone-tapping of a range of 'undesirables" from "terrorists" to trade unionists.
Always one to look after her own, Maggie's found him a new job - representing Britain on a Council of Europe human rights commit: tee!
- Is she trying to sort of. point?
After a year of 'discussion' the government has put together a package geared to "alleviating the homelessness problem'* And, true to form, the pro posals define not homelessness as the problem, but the homeless.
So bewarel If you follow Norman Tebbit's advice to "get on your bike" and look for work, you'll run the risk Not only that, but benefits will also be removed from people who leave home to search for work elsewhere.
As for homeless young people, "genuine proof"1 would be demanded of eviction or physical danger at home - an example given would be medical certificate confirming sexual abuse.
Young homeless people would have to go through the degrading ritual ing their sexual abu: bevy of officials in c simply to be put on ing list.
Some "solution"!
he official unemploy ment rate, of 6.3%, masks a rather less ro picture in the north of England.
In the Liverpool area, for instance, male unemployment stands at 19.7%. In Sunderland the figure is 17.7%, and in Barnsley 15.1%.
In many urban areas it is only the women's unemployment rate which is in single figures. That women's rate only includes those women officially available for work. Married women, who do not sign on but who do want to work are not included, nor are many single mothers.
The general picture is that though unemployment does seem to be declining, it is de ing so more slowly and patchily than the official figures would have us believe.
The introduction of privatisation into the NHS has directly led to cases of illness in both workers and patients.
Last March 21 workers employed by Healthtex UK, laundry firm, were rushed to hospital suffering from chest pains and eye irritations.
They had been gassed by incorrectly-mixed cleaning fluids.
At Reading Hospital, the cleaning was taken over by RCO in 1986, who promptly cut staffing levels by 50%J Last year an elderly patient at the hospital died of an infected cut.
An inquiry found that "the standard of cleaning may well have had something to do with it."
Several firms have lost contracts in the NHS due blatant contravention of hygiene regulation.
TAR Photo: Carlos Guarita, Reflex tan Crooke of Birkenhead unscientific thought.
Long after the Soviet Union's system's survival into its eighth decade, long after its expansion across Eastern Europe, China, etc., Crooke insists it is a system with no dynamic at all. Those of us who unscientifically want to call it a class system get short shrift.
But Crooke's scientific argument leaves me a bit bewildered. His argument is, as I understand it:
1. You can't call the statemonopoly system a class system The extent to which the Policy Review document "Meet the Challenge, Make the Change" has misjudged the changed public mood is truly staggering.
Concerned for the NHS, sickened by privatisation, pollution and Poll Tax, more and more people are:
becoming receptive to Socialism.
The 'Cold War' has thawed - yet now we are to keep nuclear weapons! 'Green' consciousness is growing — yet now we are to keep nuclear power!
Incredibly, the Social Democrat leadership of the Labour Party nas now outgrown its obsession with Swedish models only to embrace the corrupt cut-throat capitalism of Japan and South Korea! - nations who apparently exemplify the kind of exploitation with which Labour would train British wage-slaves in our "talent-based economy"
Relying upon 'regulation' by an amazing assortment of quangos, the pian involves using Social Ownership/Share Ownership as a sort of surgical support for the Market System, instead of using Common Ownership as a springboard for Socialism, to replace the Market System.
There is no positive, practical programme to be found in this 88 unless you specify its dynamics it not "every dot and comma"). -2. Those who say it is a class system (a miscrable, descriptive, merely "labelling' task have not specified its dynamics. class 3. (Therefore?) it is not a system. 4. Anyway, it's a waste of time specifying its dynamics because it hasn't got any.
In the process of elaborating this bizarre logical construction, Crooke of Birkenhead spends much time on the concept of 'planning'. I had contended that some form of planning - but not socialist planning - exists in the USSR.
Crooke's riposte is that some kind of planning might exist in capitalism, or even slave society... "But no one in their right page New Agenda for Britain". People will vote against Thatcher, but many are searching for something to vote for. It is comical to see Kinnock parading this pathetic package around, like the Emperor's new clothes. But the consequences could be grave indeed. Hans Richards, policies s a vehicle for Socialism A on the Parliamentary Broad, the Labour Farty was always something of a slowcoach. Now its new model has been triumphantly anvelled, to a fanfare of Meet the Challenge, Make the Change".
But on closer inspection it is revealed to be only the rusty remains of the old clapped-out Keynesian charabanc, with a rose-tinted respray.
Would a majority of the electorate buy a used car from Neil Kinnock?
Richard Handford, Haywards Heath mind would describe capitalism or slave-owning societies as examples of badly planned economies."
Well, no. But suppose someone had argued that capitalism. due to the anarchy of the market, say, had no economic regulator at all. We would say it does have an economic regulator. If our adversary then proudly proclaimed that - aha! -we thought it was enough to describe capitalism as a "badly regulated" economy, we would conclude that this was not a serious I did not and do not and nor, as far as I know, does anyone else in the world, consider it enough to describe the USSR as "badly planned" • I was arguing, against Crooke and his co-thinkers, that it was simply false to describe the USSR as devoid completely of a regulator or dynamic. If this were so, I repeat, it would have collapsed long ago.
To reply, as Crooke does, that it produces two left shoes, wrong-size screws, buckets with holes, etc., is merely to restate uncontentious facts. But look, if all shoes in the USSR were no good, no one would have any shoes, would they? If all screws were the wrong size...I don't need to go on. The simple fact is that things do get made in the USSR, and society does reproduce itself, if hopefully not for much longer.
So Crooke also has no coherent, fully-developed theory. It is true that to a large extent the designation "class society' is arrived at negatively, through criticism of other theories, and it is true that neither state capitalism nor some new class theory in and of themselves are an analysis.
I don't accept that to participate in this discussion, or to criticise rival theories, we have to have a firm opinion. For myself I can see problems with most theories - but Crooke's more than almost all, I object to the implication that Crooke does have an alternative theory, and it's just the rest of us morons who can't work it out. He does not have a theory, indeed in effect rejects the need for such a theory.
By "labelling' the USSR a 'class society' we may not be answering a lot, but at least we are defining the questions.
Edward Ellis Southwark
Scan page 5
GREECE 5
----- pull-quotes -----
Rights? ghts? GRAFFINE
of being labelled "intentional ly homeless" - and so not eligible for council housing.
From Swedi Korea