Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tories back down on free-market reform

Socialist Organiser no. 410, 20 July 1989 · scan pp. 2–3 · about 1,575 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Workers' Ireland forum The Protestants of Ulster: what are their rights, and what are the implications for lan Forsythe looks at the battle between the Tories and the judges One group of militants O struggle against the Tory government. The Tories have backed down substantially on their law reforms.

Some of Thatcher's closest allies from past struggles — the judges — had threatened to strike and denounced the government for introducing an authoritarian state. —What was all the fuss about? Barristers were going to lose their monopoly in the higher courts of the land.

At present the legal profession is divided into two branches. Barristers are a small group of specialist advisers and advocates and they alone have the right to speak in the higher courts. Solicitors are the people you go to see if you have a legal problem. They deal with the case right up to court, and then it will usually be passed onto a barrister.

To let solicitors speak in higher courts is no bad thing. It costs a lot of money to become a barrister, and their world has an ivory tower atmosphere, reeking of snobbish elitism, though, of course, there are exceptions.

The Tories' law reforms also propose taking away the monopoly solicitors have on the legal work in relation to house buying. The philosophy behind the reforms is to make the legal profession more susceptible to market forces.

Since barristers and judges are richer than solicitors, it looks like the removal of the barristers' monopoly won't go through but the removal of the solicitors' monopoly The Tories claimed that their reforms will make the legal system more efficient, competitive, cheap and answerable to the consumer. As usual, what they forgot to add is that you need lots of money to enter the game to begin with.

The main criticism to be levelled at the reforms is that they say nothing about increasing access to legal help from the average working class person.

If you are injured at work, kicked out by your landlord, disabled by a dcotor's negligence, or unfairly dismissed, you will want some sort of legal help. It costs a lot of money. Eligibility for legal aid -the money you can get from the state - has been drastically reduced by this government.

Since 1979 the Tories have failed to raise the legal aid eligibility levels in line with inflation so that today 13 million people are no longer entitled./ After deductions for rent and dependents, £6,035 per year is the maximum you can earn if you want to get legal aid. Even then you will have to contribute some of your costs if you earn more than £2,515.

And if you have capital assets worth more than £6,000 - including, for example, cars and bikes — you won't get anything.

As a result you have to earn below the average income to get any help. People who don't qualify often have to take two jobs or sell houses to pursue claims against rich millionaires and employers who can afford expert legal advice.

Further, access to basic information and initial advice is very restricted. The few Law Centres that exist are short of funds, often dependent on cost-cutting local authorities. Citizens Advice Bureaux are often closed or crowded, staffed by volunteers who are overworked and not paid.

The Tories' babble on about the consumer — what about the people who can't use our limited system of so-called justice because they haven't got the money?

What then should socialists demand? We want to see a decent network of publicly funded Law Centres to provide free advice and assistance to anyone who needs it.

If someone has a case they should be able to take it before a court regardless of how rich they are.

We want to see privilege removed from the judiciary, and proper socialists in Britain?

Chair: Nadine Finch grants and wages for people entering the legal profession so that it is not limited to the rich.

We want more money spent on the court system so that people awaiting trial don't have to cram into overcrowded remand centres for months on end. People who work in the courts should be paid a decent wage.

Ultimately we need to question "whose justice' the courts deliver.

The British justice system reflects a capitalist society and economy and the laws it upholds are capitalist laws. A socialist system of justice would be based on different principles, principles of real equality with Geoff Bell and John O Mahony July, 8pm at the Lucas Arms, Rd, London (near Kings X)

Scan page 3

Solidarity worldwide Dockers lobbying their union Executive Representatives of EuroReen dockers, visiting Britain, yesterday promised support for the British dockers' strike.

This is an important milestone in international workers' solidarity, and while it remains to be seen how effective the promises will be, international solidarity is going to be vital in this - and future -disputes, Belgian dockers, for example, know that what British port bosses are doing today, their Belgian equivalents will do tomorrow. The assault on the National Dock Labour Scheme is part of a European-wide attempt by employers to beat down the unions in preparation for 1992.

Similar attempts have been made elsewhere. In Italy there was a bitter (and unsuccessful) strike against a similar move by the government. Spain has already put dockers on hiring by the day. French employers have announced similar plans. Indeed, the pattern is wider, including India, Australia and many other countries.

Port employers have been fully aware of the international implications of these disputes, and the need for them to co-operate. In January, there was a meeting of British and French bosses to plan their arrangements for a dock strike. French bosses are waiting to see what will happen in Britain.

The method the bosses ing to beat the docks strike is to take goods to continental ports such as Rotterdam or Hamburg, break them into smaller loads, and then ship them to non-Scheme ports in Britain. This is a difficult operation for the bosses, and doesn't always work - this week Felixstowe stewards turned away a ship with 250 containers that had been diverted from Southampton. Felixstowe is a non-Scheme port.

But it is difficult for dockers in Europe to identify the loads. Moreover, in some countries, British-style labour law makes it legally difficult for them to take effective solidarity action.

Stewards in Rotterdam 1 have promised to 'slow down' the shipping of goods to Britain, but not to boycott them.

In fact a boycott will be necessary, as it will be in future docks disputes elsewhere in Europe. The difficulties must be overcome. Of course, the stronger the strike is in Britain, the more likely international solidarity will be. But the better the solidarity, the stronger the strike.

Australian dockers have a good record of international solidarity, for example during the British miners' strike. We need to build on such examples.

The bosses' intention, for 1992, is to make a new Europe in which exploitation of the working class is easier. But that is not guaranteed for them -they have to win a whole series of battles first. If we win, we can use European unity to the advantage of the working class.

Developing the sinews of international solidarity is the precondition for winning those battles.

Despite her sophisticated • critique of the French Revolution, Mrs Thatcher is not above a spot of Revolutionary Terror herself, when the occasion requires it.

And the occasion certainly requires it now, what with the gains of Ten Glorious Years under threat from bolshy unions and ungrateful Greeninfluenced voters.

Make no mistake, heads are going to roll very soon. I can confidently name two dead certs for the guillotine Citizens Reid and Ridley. My confidence is not based upon any special predictive powers, but simply upon reading the newspapers.

Now, I am quite well aware that you can't believe everything you read in the bourgeois press. But when it comes to sustained campaigns against government ministers and heads of nationalised industries, then you know that these stories did not drop out of the sky; they came from "Whitehall sources', which is another way of saying Mr Bernard Ingham...which is another way of saying Mrs Thatcher.

Back in June, in the immediate aftermath of the Euro election fiasco, Peter Jenkins in the Independent urged Mrs Thatcher to "find re-employment" for Nicholas Ridley. "No-one, said Jenkins, "is more reviled throughout the Tory heartland of the south - ask any candidate canvasser in last week's elections.

Towards the end of last week, the vague rumblings against the Environment Secretary began to build up into a crescendo. Papers. as diverse as the Guardian and the Daily Mail bayed for his blood. The Observer described his Plans LO dismember the Nature Conservency Council as "the greatest single act of vandalism in his long mismanagement of the national environment." The final nail in Citizen Nick's coffin was the Sunday Times front page headline: "Ridley must go say Tory MPs', above a story that included a description of Ridley as an "ecological hooligan."

When Rupert Murdoch's most loyal Thatcherite mouthpiece carries stuff like that, who can doubt that it comes with the Thatcher/Ingham seal of approval?

That the unfortunate Ridley will be joined in the tumbril by Sir Bob Reid, chairman of BR, became apparent in

----- pull-quotes -----

le shadow the axe GAN G Daily Express

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 410

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →