Poland: socialists and the reforms
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Walesa camnaianina: socialists should have run against his hand-picked candidates the radical left called Jack Allison reviews debate with Polish socialists That was the significance of the recent elections in Poland? And how should socialists have related to them?
These were the issues discussed at a recent public meeting organised by the Polish Socialist Party (Democratic Revolution) [PPS-RD] Support Committee.
Chris Ford, a recently returned eye-witness to the Polish elections, described a surprisingly low level of interest, especially in working class areas. He pointed out the undemcratic method by which Solidarnosc had selected its candidates, through "citizens' committees effectively controlled by Lech Welesa and his supporters.
This theme was also taken up by Tadeusz Rachowski, chair of the PPS-RD, who pointed to the undemocratic actions of the Solidarnosc leadership and the total lack of power for the newly elected Solidarnosc representatives.
Tadeusz supported his party's call for a boycott of the elections, welcomed the low turn-out in the elections (only 62% overall and lower in large cities) and argued that a proportion of these nonvoters could be drawn to the ideas of workers" self-management, that the PPS-RD puts forward.
The PPS-RD are the most advanced political party in Poland and probably the whole Eastern Bloc. Their belief in socialism, and their struggle to overthrough the Stalinist despots in Poland and replace totalitarianism with workers' self-government, makes them central to the future of the Polish working class.
However, I believe that the PPSRD's policy over the elections was wrong. Let's look at the issues point by point.
• The elections were in no way democratic. Free elections were held only for members of the effectively powerless senate and 35% the Sejm (Lower House) which will elect a massively powerful President.
All this is true. Such is the nature of reforms: they always leave effective power in the hands of the ruling class, and in this case the Communist Party' (PZRP). Any reform that leaves the Polish Stalinist state in place, crucially the army and the bureaucracy, is less than full democracy.
The Polish Socialist Party: (Democratic Revolution)
boycotted Poland's elections last month.
We think they were mistaken to do so, but print their statement explaining their position The radical wing of Solidarnose, principally the PPS(RD) and Fighting Solidarnosc, have declared that they will boycott the elections to the Sejm and the Senate.
The elections to the Lower House, or Sejm, are being carried out on a united list, with 35% of the seats offered for contest to the Opposition.
There is indeed a vast difference between a full parliamentary system of government and the current system in Poland. Polish workers still lack civil and democratic rights that Western European workers have won. The demand for a totally free election in Poland is a revolutionary demand.
But then the question, simply put, is this. Do we only involve ourselves in the final victory? Or do we need to be involved at every stage, pushing every small victory on towards the final victory of revolution? Every reform within the system is less than full democracy and temporary, but we can not 1gnore our victories; they must be used to build on.
The round table talks started as a response to a wave of strikes last summer when the Stalinists realised they could not crush Solidarnosc. The talks ended with a major victory — the first free elections in the Eastern Bloc for over 40 years — and a major defeat, the involvement of the leaders of Solidarnosc an economic deal' with the ott This is thoroughly undemocratic.
Meanwhile, the new Senate will have decorative powers only -rather like the British House of Lords.
Moreover, the Walesa team is busy carving up the Senate seats for its supporters - on much the same principle as the Party has for years.
Walesa claimed in a recent interview that manipulation was necessary *to put an end to manipulation'!
PPS(RD) calls for the rebuilding of Solidarnosc in the workplaces; for a democratic congress of Solidarnosc as soon as possible to decide on the union's policies; for full support for the workers' selfmanagement councils and for a Self Management Chamber of Parliament with wide powers to replace the decorative" Senate. Stalinists which includes a wage cut of 20% over a year. Socialists should always fight the defeats and extend the victories.
• The Solidarnosc slate was carved out by Lech Walesa with no democratic procedure. Candidates were not democratically selected. They are a new burcaucracy.
However bureaucratic and undemocratic Solidarnose is, it is not a ruling totalitarian bureaucracy. It has no army, no state, no power other than the support it gets.
The PPS-RD still looks to it as a movement, as do all the most advanced workers. 62% of the Polish population came out and voted almost unanimously for Solidarnosc as the opposition.
That is why the PPS-RD has a definite and correct policy of staying inside Solidarnosc to rebuild it as a workers' movement.
Solidarnosc leaders may have learnt from the anti-democratic methods of the ruling class, they may even share some interests with them; but they are not leading a 12k MILIAN. 10X82 16670 INTERNOWANYCH DBÓZ GRODKOLİ sham savage Stalinist state, they are leading Solidarnosc.
The election was a victory for the Polish people who support Solidarnosc and a disaster for the Polish ruling class.
• Those parties who really want change, the overthrow of the system, could not stand. The election was not truly tree.
Given the totally undemocratic control of Solidarnose selections, the PPS-RD should have stood against the 'official candidates' in as many areas as possible to put across the PPS-RD's ideas and build their support. It could be done. In Cracow a KPN supporter stood against the 'official' Solidarnosc candidate. The KPN are right wing but they are not favoured by the government. Both KPN and PPS-RD have faced repression, but the real block on PPS-RD candidates standing seems to have been the PPS-RD's decision for a boycott, not anything the government did.
• The round table talks were a disaster, a sell-out of the strike wave. They gave no real democracy - only 35% democracy in return for a wage cut. The bureaucrats co-opted the Solidarnosc le dership into the state, making them like the other front organisations for the "Communist Party'. We can not give this package credibility by supporting the elections that have come about as part of the talks.
If we wait for reforms which are not accompanied by any ruling class attempt to recoup, we'll wait a long time. Socialists should not accept the agendas set by others in this way. Faced with "deals' or "packages' from our rulers, we must attack the sell-outs all the way, but support and push forward the gains however small.
The leaders of Solidarnosc are not the same as the front organisations of the PZRP! Solidarnosc is the opposition in Poland. It was founded by a working class revolt in 1980. The front organisations of the PZRP are state-funded, set up under th: direct control of the police st. e machinery.
There aay come a time when Solide sc is so bankrupted that it becor an agency of the Polish state it whatever you think of the They are not that now. They reman independent of the state.
They may share some interests but fundamentally they have different interests. The Solidarnosc leadership have refused to join a coalition with the Stalinists.
The logic of the round table deals does lead down a very dangerous path, but it does not make the Solidarnosc leadership at one with the regime.
• The vote turn out was low, only 62% showing the lack of belief in the reforms and great potential for the PPS-RD with its policy of boycotting the elections.
There certainly can be occasions. when socialists would boycott an election - if the elections are totally discredited as a cover for a hated regime and we can propose some better system as an immediate alternative. That was not the case in Poland's recent elections. Most of the non-voters do not represent a base for socialist ideas. A very small minority were directly involved in the boycott campaign but the vast majority of those who did not vote were less political, more cynical about any change by any method, more defeatist, less defiant, in other words further from socialist ideas, than those who did at least vote to show their anger against the Stalinists.
All this said, the PPS-RD remains the best socialist current inside Poland and retain a real belief in working class self-liberation, showing they are the true heirs of the Solidarnosc of 1980-81. The tactical argument over the boycott is secondary. Tadeusz Rachowski ended his speech by saying that the workers in Poland are now living at subsistence level, and that the turther attacks proposed by the Stalinists on the working class will be met by the united response of the workers in strikes. I have no doubt that he is right.
But the workers can only win it they are led by clear politics. The position of leadership must be won from the current leaders of Solidarnosc both in the political and economic spheres.
The PPS-RD are determined to stay inside' Solidarnose - and they should not abstain from the non-industrial politics of the opposition. They should combine their own full demands with support and use of reforms won by the whole of Solidarnosc.