Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

VORKERS' LIBERTY 89 7 Making ideas a real force

Socialist Organiser no. 409, 13 July 1989 · scan p. 7 · Clive Bradley · about 1,106 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Sui Wai the Chinese Solidarity Campaign addresses Workers' Liberty 89 a segment of the Irish people with a distinct identity. They feel that identity, and it's not for anybody else to say they haven't got it or that they are not entitled to it. And that is the element missing in Naomi Wayne's exposition.

People fight for their identities. Maybe they shouldn't rationally, but they still fight for their identities.

Reponican policy in Ireland is a policy that takes account of the ditferent Irish identities and finds a common formula. The only possible framework here is some form of federal Ireland in which the guarantees for the Protestants are not dependant on whether or not the Irish majority is willing at all times in the future to grant them those rights. They have to be guaranteed the right to maintain their own identity.

Obviously, that would have to go together with eradication of all oppression of Catholics inside the mainly-Protestant area. But anything less is not Republican, and antagonistic to any socialist perspective.

We can't look to Britain to deal with the Protestants. We can't look o Britain as the progressive force in his situation.

The British are not the protressive force in this situation. Briain has maintained a situation of immering civil war in Ireland now or 20 odd years. The British ruling lass has done terrible things. Their Jole policy for most of those 20 -ears has been to beat down the Catholics.

The British are not the proTessive force. The Irish working lass is — and that includes the Proestant working class. What ocialists, democrats and lepublicans must do is fight for a tamework in which til Irish work-g class can unite.

There is a Leninist and Marxist madition on this question. Where jere are national antagonisms or communal antagonism, socialists don't respond by saying one side, one people, one community or one fragment of a nation (however you define it, is bad, the other is good, and we take sides with the good. Instead of that, democrats and socialists argue for consistent democracy.

They argue for working class unity on the basis of workers in both communities guaranteeing each other democratic rights; guaranteeing each other that neither will oppress the other; guaranteeing that they will fight together against any oppression of one section.

That is the only way forward to unite the working class. I don't put it forward as something that can be done tomorrow, but in order to even begin to do it you've got to take account of the reality.

There are different segments of the Irish people. Wolfe Tone's objective has not yet been realised, of a sinking of the different identities into the common name of Irish, or a commonly accepted definition of Irish.

We need a democratic programme - that is some variant of a federal Ireland. It will have to be negotiated in its details — it would be utterly futile to try to discuss details now.

If the workers in Ireland, or a segment of them, were to accept such a programme, then the possibility would exist for the workers to relate to each other as people who will guarantee each other democracy, not as people who either threaten or oppress.

At present the Protestants feel threatened, and the Catholics in the North are oppressed. We have to change that.

I doubt it's even possible to conquer the Northern Protestants. But I don't think it's desirable, even if it's possible. The notion of conquering the Protestants is the notion of substituting for one half million oppressed a million oppressed. That's no way forward.

Clive Bradley reports on the "Workers' Liberty 89" summer school The lesson of the past, argued Jean Lane in the closing session of Workers' Liberty. 89, is that militancy is not enough.

The new wave of strikes needs to be linked to a political alternative to the Tories, reaching beyond Neil Kinnock. Socialist Urganiser must be built as a Aunnainau L. L.11L Marxist tendency rooted in the labour movement.

Over 300 people attended this year's Workers' Liberty, organised jointly by Socialist Organiser and the Iranian group Socialism and Revolution. Discussions and debates covered a wide range, from the class nature of the USSR to the Green party, from Jesse Jackson to Marxism Today, from lesbian and gay liberation to Islamic fundamentalism, from Jazz to Marxist philosophy, from permanent revolution to pornography.

The Communist Party, the Green Party, Labour Focus on Eastern Europe and a гертезейtative of the Palestinian Liberation Organisation all attended debates and workshops. In a debate with Marxism Today, Alan Johnson challenged their notion that the working class is finished, and that "old fashioned" class struggle is dead. Times have changed, and we need to relate to the changes, but the working class is still the agent of socialist change.

The school included a series. of workshops on China, and was rounded off by Sui Wai from the Chinese Solidarity Campaign leading the singing of the Internationale in Chinese.

A big part of the weekend was given over to debates, conducted with an openness which contrasted markedly with the Socialist Workers' Party's 'Marxism 89" school the previous week. In the major sessions at "Marxism 89' speakers who would put a dif ferent point of view from the SWP were systematically excluded, or if by chance they did get in, all subsequent speakers would compete to denounce and slander them.

At Workers' Liberty 89, in contrast, we had debates not only with Marxism Today, but also with the Green Party, Charter 88, a campaign to ban pornography, and representatives of a wide range of views on Ireland and on the Eastern Bloc.

The session on the Bloc was particularly and lively.

ORGAVE POUVOR HBE But the weekend was not just about debating theoretical issues. The opening session on "Ten Years of Thatcher" heard activists from major groups of workers now in dispute speak about their struggles, and a trade union forum on Saturday looked at those struggles in more detail.

Summing up, Jean Lane commented that these discussions had shown that Socialist Organiser has the beginnings of an implantation in a wide range of industries. And we have the political ideas to take the struggles forward. What we lack, above all, is the numbers and the resources to make those ideas an effective force.

While continuing our discussions, we also have to build a movement in the day-to-day struggles around us. We came away from the weekend better prepared to do that, and with a number of new comrades who had decided to join us in that effort.

THA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 409

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →