Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Ireland: where is the force for progress?

Socialist Organiser no. 409, 13 July 1989 · scan p. 6 · about 1,668 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The Protestant 'marching season' in Northern Ireland is beginning, As in previous years, there are conflicts between Protestants who want to take their traditional triumphal sectarian marches through Catholic areas and the police trying to re-route marches. Underlying it all is the bitter, tense division between Protastant and Catholic in Northern Ireland, which the Anglo-Irish Agreement has only reinforced.

At the "Time To Go Show' on 27-28 May, a major session discussed the 'Bloodbath Scenario'. If we call for British troops out of Northern Ireland, how do we avoid that leading to bloody civil war?

Naomi Wayne presented the argument of her recent book, written jointly with Bob Rowthorne ('Northern. Ireland: the political economy of conflict). Withdrawal could be linked with peaceful progrese to s united Ireland, she said, if Britain would use its economic and military strength to apply pressure to the Protestants.

Sean Matgamna from Socialist Organiser put an alternative view. We cannot look to the British stat to solve the conflict between the communities in Ireland. Instead we should look to the Irish working class. We must develop a democratic programme — a federal united Ireland, giving regional autonomy to the Protestant-majority area - which would enable Protestant and Catholic workers to join a common fight against discrimination.

Such of what's said on L the left gives the impression that we imagine that things are actually falling apart for Britain, or might not be too far from falling apart. My picture is very different.

Over the last three years in Northern Ireland, the British government has had a pretty substantial series of successes. The Anglo-Irish Ly by not doing a great deal on the deal has held. It has done that partground, and that's one reason why it's avoided a much bigger Protestant backlash than there might have been. Nevertheless, the Anglo-Irish Agreement is in place. The British and Irish bourgeois strategy for Ireland is relatively healthy. So the framework, that has existed for a long time is holding, and Britain has carried through quite serious measures to strengthen it.

What London and Dublin are doing with the Anglo-Irish Agreement is best understood in terms of the analogy of the Common Market. After the Second World War the West European bourgeoisies needed to unite their economies. They couldn't do that because of the ingrained national antagonisms. So, in a series of measures, beginning in 1951 with the creation of the Coal and Steel Community, they began to create supra-national structures. They've put aside the national antagonisms and begun to unite the European economy. And they have been enormously successful in do. ing that. In Northern Ireland, London and Dublin are putting aside or trying to put aside all the vexed questions of sovereignty, and they have begun to create, gingerly and tentatively, structures which they hope will grow and take on a role.

The whole notion that Britain is soon going to start looking for ways out is nonsense. That's not what is happening. That is not the stage we are at at all.

Terry Adams said in response Go a cumine that t British Trade of mine that if British withdrawal was done badly, would probably lead to repartition, rather than to a united Ireland. ] think that's true. I think it's central.

It's quite possible that the people who set out to create a united Ireland will in fact create two Irelands, but a repartitioned Irelands - not the present two Ireland.

And a repartitioned Ireland with the Protestant community establishing a state on some smaller territory would be the end of all aspirations for a united Ireland.

So when Gerry Adams also dismissed the idea of a bloodbath by saying there is a bloodbath already, it struck me as entirely light minded.

At present the level of casualties in Northern Ireland is lower than the usual rate of violent death in some American cities. A bloodbath is very different. A sectarian civil war is very different. And I believe that a sectarian civil war is a real danger.

What Naomi Wayne has said seems a very reasonable, rational, sensible way of looking at it. But it's a picture of reality that is like a watch without a spring.

In reality, if Britain decided to withdraw, there would be a vast alarm among the Protestant population. It wouldn't just be fear of some future laws passed by ar all-Ireland majority, it would be fear of the IRA, for example. Ir that atmosphere of alarm and insecurity, the initiative would not belong to the rational reasonable people who would draw up a halance sheet and calculate the economic prospects.

The extremists, the intransigents, the Protestant militants, the people who go in for sectarian assassination, would set the tone. And actions by a hardline minority could in fact control, to a large extent, what happened.

For a parallel, think back to what happened in 1968/9. lived in Derry in the crucial period in 1969 In 1969 in Derry and in Belfast the Republicans were virtually попThe marching season has begun existent. They had virtually disarmed and they played no role in defending the ghettoes except as individuals.

Yet, within 18 months the Provos had split from the Official IRA, they had reorganised, they had recruited the raw youth, and they had launched a big military offensive. All that within 18 months.

In situations of insecurity, the initiative belongs to people who know their own minds, who are determined, and who are reckless. That was one of the decisive things about the Provos - recklessness. Many of the left-wing Republicans would have hesitated to start the war because of the Protestant antagonism. But the Provos struck out boldly - they grabbed the initiative.

The main storm of sectarían assassinations in the 1970s was the work of Protestant militants, though there were terrible acts of Catholic sectarianism too. Such people would set the tone when the British decision to withdraw was announced. Rational calculations, balancing things nicely, would not actually determine what happened.

We don't have to speculate. We can look back in history. There is an obvious parallel — what happened when the British decided to abdicate power in Palestine in 1947. What happened wasn't people getting round the table and being reasonable and rational. Jews ana Arabs in the towns and villages and the hills competed to control commanding positions and drive out people of the other community:

You may think it was a good thing that Britain withdrew, but what you got was not a reasonable putting together of two communities, or even agreement to stick by the position that the UN had decreed (unjust as that was), but war between Jews and Arabs, and the Arabs being driven out.

Northern Ireland would be similar. Rationalistic economic calculations would not decide. If they did, the problem would not exist in the first place.

Why do such community conflicts exist? Are the Lebanese, for example, irrational people? Are the Lebanese the equivalent of music hall joke Irish people? Lunatics, crazies, irrational people?

Or take the communal conflicts between Sinhalese and Tamils in Sri Lanka. That conflict is a clear refutation of the argument that if you have a united Ireland on the basis of something like the conquest of the Protestants (whether conquest by threats or by direct military force), then the Protestants would not be likely to have an IRA of their own because they wouldn't have an objective to fight for.

In Sri Lanka there is a Tamil minority. The Tamils are a minority in Sri Lanka, but just over the sea in India there is a Tamil state, Tamil Nadu, with about 50 million people.

Under the British, some of the Tamils were privileged people. The Tamil elite agreed with tne Sinhalese bourgeoisie to have a secular independent state. For a few years it went all right. But then discrimination began against the Tamils.

Conflict escalated, and the result now is that the Tamils fight for independence in a tiny part of Sri Lanka.

There is no reason why you would not get that sort of situation developing in Ireland if the Protestants were in a united Ireland feeling alienated like the Catholics in Northern Ireland feel now. W socialists? I object to the hat is the objective of idea that people in Britain, whether English or, like myself, Irish, do not have the right to discuss the affairs of Ireland. I reject that for several reasons, and one of them is that there are a million people in Ireland who say they are British.

They say other define it ariously, it comes down to the belief they are British.

Those people have rights. I consider myself to be an Irish Republican, and I don't think that it's possible to be a Republican and have the attitude that you can simply conquer the Northern Ireland Protestants.

Any talk of solving the existing antagonisms by changing the situation where half a million Catholics are oppressed into one where a million Protestants would feel oppressed inside a united Ireland, is no solution at all. *Gerry Adams said that if withdrawal lead to repartition rather than to a united Ireland. I think that's true"

In practical realpolitik, it is probably not workable, and above all it is not a Republican solution, still less a sociali: solution.

Wolfe Tone set out to eradicate the old denominational emphases and to unite the Protestants (the Anglicans), the Catholics and the Dissenters (the Presbyterians) under the common name of Irish.

The previous history of Ireland had been a history of wars between these denominations. The Catholics were usually underneath, but sometimes en the top, as under King James's parliament of 1689.

Wolfe Ton. argued for forgetting such divis ns, for renouncing revenge, abs for accepting rights for all the various identities and thus merging into a common Irish identity.

The Protestants cannot be just defined as pro-imperialist. They are

----- pull-quotes -----

was done badly, it would probably

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 409

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →