Where now in
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
the Rising Daughter a discussion artin Thomas the options Poland is in greater political disarray than any state-monopoly system has ever been.
General Jaruzelski has announced that he will not run again for president. Semi-free elections last month swept Solidarnosc candidates into almost all the contested seats, and hugely discredited the government, whose members failed to win election even in uncontested seats.
The top bureaucrats, or at least some of them, want a coalition government with Solidarnosc. But there is also talk of Lech Walesa running for president, to create a Solidarnos government.
The right-wing in Solidarnosc wants a coalition government. The centre wants to stand aloof, cooperating with the regime on this or that issue, but maintaining some independence. The left-wing in Solidarnose boycotted the election, and sees its task as organising the rank and file in Solidarnosc against a leadership which is hand-in-hand with the state, coalition or nor coalition.
What should we say? Should we raise the call: All Power to Solidarnosc!? *This would mean calling on the elected Solidarnose deputies to declare themselves the elected representatives of the people and to constitute a new National Assembly, rather as the Third 'Estate did in France in 1789.
That National Assembly should declare itself sovereign, while convening the sort of representative body which Solidarnosc itself demanded back in 1981: workers' self-management parliament.
Any such proposal would have to be linked to proposals to dismantle the existing hierarchies of the state bureaucracy and the army's officer corps, and the militia, replacing them by elected and accountable people. A Solidarnose government which tried to govern with the existing state machine would fare even worse than a Labour government in Britain governing with the existing capitalist state machine here.
Assuming that the bureaucrats and generals allowed Solidarnosc to form a government, such a government, attempting to govern with the existing hierarchies, could only tie Solidarnosc to the bureaucratic state-monopoly system in the same way that a coalition government would.
The system does not allow for independent workers' organisation. The only way that Solidarnosc could become an integral and centransforming itself into a state- the system is by controlled pseudo-union.
Such a thing could be done. After the 1956 upheaval in Poland, workers' councils were formed which at first had some real life but soon became mere agencies of the In the late 1940s the Stalinists constructed their systems in Eastern Europe by more than brute repression. The absorption of the Social Democratic party into the Stalinist party in East Germany was genuiney welcomed by many workers as "workers' unity" '. The completion of Stalinist control in Czechoslovakia, in 1948, was backed up not by Soviet troops but by a workers' uprising. There were sonuine workers' movements which were first duped and then gutted of real life by the Stalinists.
To gut Solidarnosc today would be more difficult: the ruling group is weaker and more divided, and the social model of the USSR inspires hatred and cynicism among workers rather than the respect and admiration it had in the 1940s. But would be foolish to think that gutting Solidarnosc is impossible.
That is the danger most to be avoided. Certainly we must oppose any coalition. But can we best take their Power to Solidarnose and fighting for measures to break up entrenched bureaucratic power, or by fighting for Solidarnosc to stay rigorously independent and aloof until better conditions have matured for an assault on bureaucratic power?
It is difficult to judge at a distance.
Would a call for Solidarnosc to take power, whatever the qualifications and additional slogans, only help to tie Solidarnosc to the state? It would depend on the struggle within Solidarnosc.
The present leaders of Solidarnosc are not willing to take power on their own. Their only options are joining a coalition or remaining aloof. So calling for Solidarnosc to take power would mean struggle inside Solidarnosc, including a struggle to renew the leadership and to construct or reconstruct structures of accountability. 'All Power to Solidarnosc!"
Would an attempt by Solidarnosc to take power only mean provoking a premature and crushing conflict with the Polish army? Certainly there would be conflict; but can we really expect that conflict to be smaller or easier at a future time? The Polish army must be in serious disarray now; it may not stay that way.
What about the danger of a Soviet invasion? An official Soviet representative has said that the USSR would not invade if SolidarNS REGION MAZOWSZE nosc formed a government in Poland. The assurance is not to be trusted; but the fact it was given is significant.
Hungary and Yugoslavia are in ferment, and could well explode into revolution if Solidarnose took power in Poland. The leadership in the USSR is insecure. No-one can be sure, or even confident, that a more favourable international situation for Solidarnosc will arise again in the forseeable future.
But isn't the Polish working SOliDARNOse at a low ebb? Isn't it necessary to wait until the workers are more confident and more mobilised?
As far as can be judged from a distance, the relative apathy of Polish workers is due to the fact that they are beaten down by economic hardship and can see no clear way out of it. Solidarnose no longer seems to propose anything radically different from the government.
If Solidarnosc does not change course boldly, this apathy is likely to increase rather than decrease. But an assault by Solitarnose on the entrenched ruling bureaucrats could revive workers" militancy very fast.