We need more analysis
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
ETTERS Long after powered flight had first taken place, Simpn Newcomb, President of the American Astronomical Society, and Vice-President of the US Academy of Sciences, continued to write scientific papers dismissing it as an impossibility.
Edward Ellis (Letters, SO404) performs a comparable feat, albeit in reverse, with regard to the Soviet economy: at a time when Soviet economists themselves recognise that the economy is in a terminal nose-dive and predict the outbreak of large-scale famine sooner rather than later, Ellis assures us all that, whatever its limitations, "plannexists in the Soviet oni nonetheless nonentees It certainly is an odd kind of *planning" which plans the production of shoes for people with two left feet, which plans the production of doors but forgets to plan the production of doorhandles with which to open them, or which plans the import of Western high-tech goods such as soap and toothpaste because the Soviet economy itself cannot generate sufficient production of them.
The basic problem in the approach of Edward Ellis of Southwark is summed up in his statement: *Bourgeois governments — and enterprises — plan. Not all planning is socialist planning. You can call bad planning 'organisation' or 'administration' if you prefer, but we're still talking about the same thing - which is that production in the USSR is not completely anarchic."
This is true enough, in a sense, but it does not get you anywhere in attempting to analyse the nature of the Soviet Union.
You can say that there is some planning in capitalism if you want to, just as you could say that there was some planning in slave-owning societies (how else could the slave owners tell the slaves what to do?) But no-one in their right mind would describe capitalism or slaveowning societies as examples of badly planned economies.
You could pursue the approach of Edward Ellis and come up just as easily with the conclusion that the Soviet Union is a state-capitalist formation. Indeed, this is exactly what Martin Thomas did in an earlier letter in SO: "Bad planning is not the same as no planning...] would add that bad markets are not the same as no markets."
Edward Ellis argues: 'Look, there's a bit of planning in the Soviet Union, so we'll say that it's! really a badly planned economy' "Look, there's a bit of a market in whilst Martin Thomas argues: the Soviet Union, so we'll say it's really a kind of state-capitalist economy'. Neither put forward an analysis of the Soviet economy as a whole.
Martin Thomas is simply wrong. One need merely ask the question why workers in capitalism go to work and why workers in the Soviet Union go to work (insofar as they bother to do so) to recognise the qualitative difference between the Soviet economy and a capitalisttype economy.
In an earlier contribution to the debate on the Soviet Union, Clive Bradley wrote: *The objection that you have to specify all the laws of motion of a system before you can call it a class system at all is silly" It might be a bit pedantic to expect every dot and comma to be explained - but surely it is not too much to expect a basic analysis?
And yet, with the possible exception of a contribution from Barry Finger, the practitioners of the theory of bureaucratic collectivism have yet to even begin to explain their view of the functioning/dysfunctioning of the Soviet economy.
We are told, for example, that the Soviet elite is a ruling class with a distinct relationship to the means of production. But what is that "distinct" relationship (if it exists)? What is the ideology of this ruling class (if it has one)? How does it reproduce itself (insofar as it could be argued that it does so)?
Is it not about time we were offered a serious attempt at analysis by Edward Ellis of Southwark and his co-thinkers, rather than just a name-tag for the Soviet elite (ruling class") and a name-tag for the Soviet economy (**badly planned"), with no other justification' than that the Soviet Union exists, and "therefore' there must be a "ruling class" and a (badly) "planned" economy?
Stan Crooke Birkenhead