Socialism the agenda
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-07-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Soviet central Asian republic of Uzbekistan seem to have died down, for the time being at least, ethnic unrest has now surfaced in the neighbouring republic of Kazakhstan, and is threatening to do so in Moldavia.
In Uzbekistan a series of bloody clashes last month between native Uzbeks and the Turkish Meskhetian minority (deported to the republic by Stalin in 1944) resulted in a hundred deaths, over a thousand people injured, 300 milion rubles worth of damage, and the evacuation of 15,000 Meskhetians, Then clashes broke out in Kazakhstan. Indigenous Kazaks attacked immigrants from the Transcaucasus (itself recently the scene of ethnic clashes). The deployment of troops and imposition of a curfew gradually restored order, but only after four deaths and over fifty injured.
At the same time up to 40,000 people marched in the Moldavian capital of Kishinev, "mourning" the creation of their republic (consisting largely of land seized from Rumania by Stalin in 1940), and demanding the use of Moldavian as the official republican language and the replacement of the Cyrillic script (as used in Russian) by the Latin script.
Ethnic hostilities were clearly one factor behind the clashes Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan. In Kazakhstan the targets of the pogroms were mainly Armenians and Azeris (from Azerbaidzhan) who are disproportionately represented in the more privilegec jobs in the oil sector and in the "cooperative sector" of the economy which, being effectively privatised, is notorious for charging high prices.
But the ethnic hostility is also closely related to more general economic and social problems in the two republics.
Uzbekistan's economy is based on cotton, which has flourished at the expense of the cultivation of fruit and vegetables. Recent mechanisation of the cotton industry has resulted in a high level of unemployment. Chemical fertilisers used in the cotton plantations are also blamed for the high level of infant mortality in the republic.
Kazakhstan likewise suffers from a series of economic imbalances, resulting in poor food supplies and frequent rationing, poor social operate new industries.
Corruption is also a prominent feature of both Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, even by Soviet standards. Uzbekistan has the reputation of being the most corrupt republic in the Soviet Union after Georgia. Kazakhstan was the scene of widespread rioting in 1986 when a local leading bureaucrat was removed and replaced by a Russian as part of Gorbachey's "clean-up" campaign, Various explanations have been put forward as to the more precise reasons for the sudden upsurge of violence in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan at this moment in time.
Reports in the Soviet press, for example, have claimed that a "Pan Islamic" front in Uzbekistan laun ched the attacks on the Meskhetians after the latter had refused to throw their lot in with the front in a united effort to drive Russians out of the According to Pulatov, a leader of the unofficial Birlik movement in Uzbekistan, on the other hand, the unrest was organised and financed by local mafioso leaders who have seen their ill-gotten gains falling off in value as a result of successive anti-corruption drives.
Other explanations have attributed the unrest to the influence of Khomeini-style Islamic fundamentalism, whilst some coverage in the Soviet press has also wheeled out the standard references to "nationalist extremists" and "drunks, drug-addicts and hooligans" (which, in fact, explains nothing at all).
The precise combination of factors - it seems fair enough to assume that more than one factor was involved - which produced the recent clashes in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan remains unclear, but the basic trend of the events is clearer: towards the break up of the Soviet Union. Since Gorbachev came to power and reduced the level of repression, waves of discontent, pushing for more autonomy from the central government in Moscow, have swept through the country, from the Baltic states through the Transcaucasus to Central Asia.
Although the Soviet Union" is held together only by bonds of national oppression, its collapse into a myriad of mutually hostile principalities would hardly be a step forward. But in the absence of the emergence of a genuinely socialist movement in the Soviet Union, this is the price which will end up being paid for the rule of Stalinism. Moses Mayekiso is genaral sacretary of the matalworkers" union NUMSA in South Africa. He has racantly been ralsass from jail after being put on trial for "treason' because of his part in organising the black township of Alexandra, near Joha-nasburg.
TH view with him is abridged from the South African magazine Work in Progress' Dio mitary occupation of uring the uprisings in to military occupation of the townships and declared a state of emergency.
This action went hand in glove with police brutality, restrictions, banning orders, the murder of activists by unknown murder squads, vigilante activities and other repressive measures which enabled the state to crush the organs of people's power.
But the revolutionary spirit of the working class is still very much alive. The welcome we received by the people in Alex and their enthusiasm to start building again has proved this.
Prior to our detention, Cosatu was still new and finding its feet. Things were not clear on which direction to take. Now we have resolutions on how to practically move forward, to restructure community organisations and build alliances. Also, political organisations and trade unions are coming together in a more non-sectarian spirit. We must be careful this time to move slowly and build firmly:
The state is using the Brazilian option - taking leaders out of communities, trying to buy the hearts and minds of people by pumping money in and trying to improve living conditions - trying to bribe the community.
But this has not worked. Living conditions in the community as a whole have not changed. The shanty dwellers are still there they have no taps, toilets or electricity.
They are also selling stands to whoever is prepared to buy them.
The yard where I lived in Alex has been sold and the room I was occupying for R7 a month is going for R35 a month.
The state has seen that it cannot force high rents on people so it has thrown the ball in the stand-owners' court. We are worried that the stand-owners and the tenants will not see eye to eye in rent boycotts. Conditions are in fact worse. Previously we co-operated with each other and organised ourselves to improve the situation. But now there is no immediate resistance.
When we were acquitted, people expected us to go back to Alex immediately, and start forming the Alexandra Action Committee (AAC) and embark on radical action. But we now prefer to crawl before we can walk.
We are definitely going back there. But for my part, it is obviously not wise for me to just jump into an open house and make myself vulnerable to attacks. Although we could be killed anywhere, we would still like to feel secure, especially to feel a bit relaxed when we sleep at night. So our houses must be secure before we move in.
We are already involved in a process of reviving the AAC. But as I said, we must move slowly and more steadily.
Like it or not, negotiations are taking place in some form at different levels, and there are feelers on negotiations on a broader level. As yet there is no set programme around this. But a process is taking place.
In our situation I don't think will ever be able to march Pretoria with arms and take over. We have to be realistic.
The Thatchers and the Reagans. together with the SADF, will not make a revolutionary takeover possible. The frontline states and even the Soviets are backing a negotiated settlement for South Africa.
But what type of negotiations, and on what conditions, are things we have to think about carefully. Our situation is similar to the Namibian situation, except maybe we won't be as disadvantaged as the Namibians, who did not even participate in the negotiation process.
We must go to the negotiating table from a position of power, with all our organisations they have to be unbanned first.
It will be a battle to even go to the negotiating table. We will have to pressurise them (the state).
In all class struggles you will find people who are enemies but who pretend to be our friends and have their own tactics to buy the working If we want to undercut the power of the state we might be forced to make tactical alliances with other classes and other people closely linked to some state structures. But in doing so we must not compromise our principles.
If we go into these alliances ignorant, we could betray the class struggle and socialism. Therefore we must clearly state our interests, the interests of the working class -that is, socialism. To shy away from talking about socialism because we might alienate some people is hypocrisy. To say socialism is not on the agenda, that the youth and workers are not ready for socialism, is a betrayal of the working class.
As I see it, and as the National Union of Metalworkers (NUMSA) sees it, the way forward is to build solid organisations with a centralised structure. We must not use western or eastern models of socialism - our conditions are different. The working class here must lead the struggle and decide what kind of socialism they want. As I said earlier, negotiations should only taken place on our terms, taking into account the class struggle.
Scan page 3
lelegates: £15 union branches; £5 smaller ganisations. One delegate plus one or two details of your delegation and fee/donation CSC, 68 Shaftesbury Ave, London W1 The Protestants of Ulster: what are their rights, and what are the implications for Women march on Versailles, 1789 1789 In 14 July 1789 the people Olate, the saring the Bastille, thus starting the French Revolution. -In 1889 socialists from many countries used the celebrations of the 100th anniversary of the Revolution as the occasion for meeting in Paris and setting up a great world association of workers' parties, the Socialist International.
That International helped to organise and educate millions of workers before it collapsed, each national party supporting its own' ruling class, at the start of World War I in 1914.
As part of the celebrations of 1889, the French government made two Statues of Liberty. One was sent to New York, in acknowledgement of the American War of Indpendence of 1775-81 which had helped inspire the French Revolution; the other remains in Paris.
In 1989, students in Beijing symbolised their fight for democracy against China's ruling bureaucracy by erecting their own Statue of Liberty. •That Statue of Liberty in Beijing symbolised more than illusions in the West which the students who erected it might have. True, the Statues of Liberty in the West look like monuments of hypocrisy today. They are the property of governments which preside over the exploitation of the working class, The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports! first post mass unemployment, racism, sexism and imperialist oppression.
But the French Revolution did proclaim and establish a new concept of liberty. Under the old regime, before the Revolution, "liberty' meant hereditary, entrenc ed privilege.
Society was a hierarchy. Such rights as people had were not human rights or citizens rights, belonging to everyone automatically. A person's rights depended on and belonged to his or her slot in the social hierarchy. Peasants had rights as peasants; aristocrats had (more) rights as aristocrats. Merchants and craft workers had rights through their guilds; priests had rights as priests.
All law was based on tradition and custom, in a crazy patchwork of parallel and overlapping jurisdictions. Taxes, tariffs, and regulations varied from district to district, governed by the authority of the local lord.
To defend "liberty' was to defend the traditional prerogatives of your caste, estate or guild against the claims of the increasingly centralised, powerful and bureaucratic monarchy.
But the Revolution proclaimed liberty' as the companion of fraternity and equality — as a human right belonging automatically and uniformly to all citizens. It declared that government must be based on the will of the nation, not on the authority of god.
The great philosopher Hegel summed it up like this: "...Not until now had man advanced to the For by phone PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Presslink International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. recognition of the principle that Thought ought to govern spiritual reality. This was accordingly glorious mental dawn. All thinking beings shared in the jublilation or this epoch.
*The halo which has surrounded the leading oppressors and gods of the earth has disappeared. Philosophers demonstrate the dignity of man; the people will learn to feel it and will not merely demand their rights, which have been trampled in the dust, but will themselves take them - make them their own."
The new concept of liberty was an epoch-making advance over the old feudal concept. But from the start it had within it the limitations that make America's and France's Statues of Liberty look so hypocritical today.
In the new world of free trade, equality before the law, an‹ 'career open to talents' • WC and bosses were formally equal. The contract between worker and boss was, on the face of it, a free agreement between equal individuals. The worker sold his or her labour power at the going rate, the boss bought it.
But in selling labour power, a worker is selling not this or that particular useful item, but the general capacity to produce new value. The value produced by a week's work is greater than the value paid for that week. The difference makes profits — and profits make a new privileged class, owing its wealth and power not to traditions, customs, laws and religious authority but to the impersonal workings of the market.
That is why we fight for a new concept of liberty - workers' liberty, which means the workers controlling the machinery of production rather than being controlled by it.
Yet workers' liberty expands and subsumes the bourgeois liberty proclaimed by the French Revolution, rather than simply negating it. And in much of the world today, including the countries which falsely call themselves socialist, even that bourgeois liberty still fought for, The French Revolution was also the starting point for the modern socialist movement. Dreams of socialism, and even sporadic practical attempts to create crude communist utopias, had existed long before then. But it is from 1795-6 that we can trace a continuous thread of sustained political organising for socialism.
Frustrated by the inability of the French Revolution to meet its proWorkers' Ireland mise of equality, Babeuf organised a group called the 'Conspiracy of Equals'. , with the aim of seizing all property and putting it into common ownership. The group was tracked down by the police and arrested before it could do anything.
But its ideas lived on. The Communist League, the group for which Marx and Engels wrote the Communist Manifesto, was a direct descendant of that Conspiracy of Equals.
Saturday 29 July 10.30-5.00 County Hall, London union branch, Labour Party or Union etc. to delegate you chasivers per organisation phone 01 836 8291 socialists in Britain? with Geoff Bell and John O'Mahony Chair: Nadine Finch July, 8pm at the Lucas Arms, Rd, London (near Kings X)
Scan page 4
Two of Britain's top directors, Sir Terence Conran and Anit Roddick - laughing all the way to the bank