Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Which side in Afghanistan?

Socialist Organiser no. 408, 29 June 1989 · scan p. 9 · Chris Hobson · about 1,322 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Socialist Organiser opposed the USSR's war in Afghanistan from the start. Since the withdrawal of the USSR's troops, we have argued that socialists should side with the PDP regime, as representing at least limited 20th century progress, against the Islamic rebels. This argument has led to a debate in our letters column, with some readers maintaining that we should back neither side in the Afghan civil war.

Here we print a second extract (abridged) from the debate which the US socialist magazine "Against the Current' is conducting on the same issue.

t's possible that by the time these comment appear, the Najibullah regime will be history.

Or, bloody and discredited, it may still be clinging to power, and David Finkel will be supporting it. Either way, I shall be very glad to have taken, ever since 1979, what I feel is the right stand, one of support for the Afghan resistance and total opposition to the Soviet Union and its agent, the People's Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA).

What I want to do in this comment is to clarify what Finkel's and my conflicting viewpoints mean in practice, not in words.

The first part of Finkel's position is that the left should have given critical support to the PDPA up until the Soviet intervention — not only when it first came to power, but in the pre-Soviet phase of the war, when the PDPA was already waging a ruthless war against the overwhelming majority of the population.

What this means in reality is that - however hard it might have been to see things clearly at the time -now, with ten years of hindsight, Finkel is for supporting a regime whose policies were driving the majority of the population to rebellion and civil war.

Strategically, as a serious politician, what does Finkel think this support would have accomplished? Does he think it would have moderated the Afghan regime in some way? Would it have made the regime even marginally less brutal? If so, how? Or does Finkel think critical support would have changed the regime from a revolution-fromabove' approach to one of "revolution-from-below'? This would be fantasy - the line between the two is fundamental.

I've been using terms Finkel would presumably agree with, but I think my own are clearer: the Afghan regime from the start, in its methods and objectives, was state capitalist and not socialist at all.

Behind this 'strategic' question is a more fundamental one: by what right does this regime impose its rule on the countryside from above and against the people's will, pour napalm over those who resist, and claim our support while doing so? And don't the Afghan people deserve any say whatsoever?

Finkel's answer is to point to the PDPA's progressive programme. On paper, that programme is clear enough: "land reform, literacy, and women's rights' '. But what has this meant in reality?

To narrow things down, let's take the point Finkel rightly regards as a crucial one: women's rights. Finkel fears a catastrophe for women if the Mujahadeen win. This is a real possibility. Unfortunately, the PDPA has made this more likely by linking reforms for women to a war against the majority of the population, a linkage Finkel accepts by retrospectively supporting the PDPA in the pre-Soviet phase of war.

If Finkel wants to argue that resistance to the reforms is what touched off the civil war, one might ask if he believes it's progressive to seize power in a coup d'etat and try to modernise a traditional country by state terror.

In any case, the examples of the regime's accomplishments on women's rights are hardly impressive: 440,000 temale students (in a population of 17 million, inMoments organis on 6.00 n the armed forces — all according to official figures.

How does this stack up against the millions of women killed or made homeless by the same regime? (Recent estimates are that 1.5 million people have been killed and more than six million made refugees or exiles by the war.) Finkel is impressed with the paper programme and the regime's modest accomplishments, but doesn't connect this with the murderous war that has driven a third of the population (women too) out of the country.

And so Finkel starts with the programme and ends by supporting the PDPA in the war. But the war is the PDPA programme; the real programme - in reality, not on paper - is to stay in power by any means necessary. The reality is that since the civil war broke out, the PDPA regime has pursued one aim consistently and unswervingly: not women's rights, not land reforms, but to kill, injure, or maim as many people as necessary to stay in And this is a general problem of the left vis-a-vis the so-called 'socialist' countries and movements, a problem Finkel seems to share: the progressive formal programme, the presumed good intentions of the regime, are given more weight than the real problem, which is to hold onto power. It's high time that the left realised that in dealing with Stalinists we're not dealing with working class revolutionists who differ with us over methods, but with people whose programme is to seize the state and use it to stay in power at all costs.

My own view is that the war has been a national liberation struggle against the Soviet Union and its puppets, the PDPA. Revolutionaries ought to support this struggle without supporting the reactionary policies of its leaders. This includes supporting the right of the Mujahedeen to get arms from the United States - without which the war would have lasted far longer than ten years — while warning against reliance and dependence on the United States.

There are three reasons why revolutionaries should support the resistance despite the ideology of its leaders and many of its activists. First, national independence is a goal we support - I hope I don't have to elaborate on this.

Second, it is impossible to support women's rights or any. other social reform by backing a party that tries to impose them by force and then wages a barbarous war of occupation that has killed and made homeless millions of people. The preeminent issue in people's minds Is that their country is under foreign occupation, that the foreigners and their local henchmen are killing people wholesale. They are not going to accept that in order to get women's rights.

The third reason for supporting the resistance is: if revolutionaries don't do so, there will be no one who is raising support for women's rights, from inside the inevitable, progressive and democratic struggle for national independence.

In fact, with the advantage of hindsight one can draw exactly the opposite conclusion from Finkel's: what revolutionaries inside Afghanistan should have been doing since 1979 was building a secular, democratic, socialist force in the national resistance, so that now there would be such a force in the post-Russian, post-PDPA Today, with the end of Soviet occupation, Finkel thinks war there will ag ain become "primarily a civil war in which we ought to be for the victory of the PDPA." Finkel hopes "the PDPA [government] survives without the Soviet tanks," but he doesn't tell us how it is to disentangle itself materially from Soviet aid and politically from responsibility for ten years of slaughter.

Tanks or no, can the PDPA hold power without Russian arms, "advisers', planes, military intelligence, etc? Leaving aside formulas ('civil war', etc.) how is the PDPA going to regain the slightest degree of popular support? Finkel's perspective amounts to supporting a regime and party correctly hated by the vast majority as Soviet puppets and brual murderers.

Far better to begin from scratch the job of building a revolutionary, Ibertarian socialist movement in Afghanistan that can collaborate with others to fight for a truly free society - however small, isolated and physically endangered such a movement may be at first.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 408

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →