Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A new start on Ireland

Socialist Organiser no. 408, 29 June 1989 · scan p. 5 · Clive Bradley · about 900 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Britain should get out of Ireland, said Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams in a keynote speech at the Time To Go conference on 17-18 June, but "the most likely scenario if withdrawal is not done properly is repartition."

This sober assessment could set the tone for a serious campaign for British withdrawal, if the left allows it to.

About 700 people attended the *Time To Go Show' in London to discuss a wide range of issues. Adams was a popular speaker, reflecting the pro-Republican sentiment of the conference. He described the experiences of repression at the hands of the British army, and argued for a broad campaign in Britain to get the troops out.

Adams' answer to the danger of civil war and repartition was that if the British government made an "irreversible" decision to withdraw on a set date, that would force the Protestants to accept the inevitable and negotiate a united Ireland. Other speakers also recognised the danger — and looked to the British government to deal with it.

Naomi Wayne, speaking on the blood scenario, elaborated a complex series of measures the British government could take to force the Protestants into a united Ireland.

This attempt to discuss the mechanisms of withdrawal is an advance on the dominant left slogan troops out now' • Adams and others recognise that withdrawal alone is not a clear policy and that what goes with withdrawal can be decisive.

Faced with the objection that withdrawal would lead to a bloodbath, it is not adequate to answer that there's already a bloodbath. Casualties over the past 20 years have been horrific - but tiny in comparison to full-scale civil war. We have to face up to the danger of a bloodbath, and that doesn't mean approving or supporting the British troops.

A large part of the conference accepted the reality of these problems and many people were genuinely open-minded. Unfortunately, the main emerging - alternative to 'troops out now' simply creates new problems. Naomi Wayne's strategy, for example, depends on a British government exercising economic and military coercion against the Protestants.

In the first place, this formula depends on trusting the British government. Naomi Wayne and Gerry Adams said it would be disastrous if the British government's stance were not irreversible"!

Ken Livingstone commented that it would only take one minister to seem doubtful for the whole policy to collapse - stoking up Protestant militancy as they believed the government might retreat. But why should we ever believe that the British government's stance would be irreversible? Who would make it irreversible?

The progressive agency in this strategy is the British government! Gerry Adams, referring to the hard left, complained of benign imperialism'. But the WayneRowthorne strategy is about as imperialist as you can get.

The idea that a British government should threaten Protestants with the loss of their jobs (or social security!) if they fight withdrawal is monstrous - not to say completely inoperable as a policy how do you know who has or hasn't accepted withdrawal?)

Behind the economic threats would lie military force to "disband and disarm" the Protestantdominated UDR, RUC and UDA - but this makes the policy a formula not for troops out, but for troops in!

The British army has been trying to disarm the Catholics for 20 years. To disarm the Protestants would take many more troops, many more years, and much more bloodshed.

Significantly, although Irish nationalism was a strong trend at the conference, this kind of "benign' (or indeed rather belligerent) imperialism got off pretty lightly. Naomi Wayne was warmly applauded for declaring that the purpose of her policy was to get Britain out of Ireland to allow the Irish people to decide their own future.

The ideological hard core behind the worst trends in the conference was the Socialist Workers Party. They assured us that the Protestants were a 'caste' , and therefore had no rights, and anyway would never fight. They repeated ad nauseam that there have been many examples of peoples bombing imperialism out of their country, but none of bombing it back in'. Protestant attempts to carve out a separate state are not even a possibility worth discussion.

This vehement Prod-bashing was weirdly combined with calls for Protestant-Catholic workers' unity (to be developed from economic struggles) and assurances that a revolutionary working class is the force for change. In other words, the problems raised by the SWP's gung-ho 'anti-imperialist' pose were glossed over by the assurance that it would all be happening in the context of a socialist revolution which would solve all problems.

Self-consolation was the keynote the Protestant question: instead answers to serious questions, devices to show that the themselves were unreal.!

Throughout, the SWP - who were by far the largest organised group - were utterly incapable of engaging the political issues. The most idiotic demagogy, and sometimes slander, replaced argument. One SO supporter, pointing to the communal divisions in Ireland, was denounced as a "Tory' on the grounds that all divisions are framework in which these different issues can be discussed. It should be built. The August demonstration, commemorating 20 years since the troops went onto the streets, must be made a success.

The ce was less of a success t s organisers had hoped, but it could yet play a role in creating a serious withdrawal movement in Britain.

----- pull-quotes -----

The Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 408

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →