Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[ETITERIS Steve Revins (Letters, SO 407), in condemning…]

Socialist Organiser no. 408, 29 June 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 388 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

ETITERIS Steve Revins (Letters, SO 407), in condemning the Chinese bureaucracy, compares Deng Xiaoping to Lenin, and Beijing to Kronstadt.

But Steve is making an extremely unfair comparison. The Bolshevik government in Russia in 1917 was a different beast entirely to the Chinese dictatorship today, Lenin's Bolsheviks were the revolutionary wing of the old European labour movement, who had managed to take power in a big, but backward country. Civil war, external military intervention, and economic blockade, took their toll very heavily on Russian society:

The Bolshevik government became a besieged fortress. Revolutions elsewhere failed. In those dire conditions, the Bolsheviks were faced with a dire choice: surrender, and allow a brutal right-wing government to take power and carry out its revenge on tens of thousands of revolutionary militants; or hold on until a fresh revolutionary victory in Europe or elsewhere ended their isolation.

Their only real choice was to hold on. Certainly, holding on meant taking some desperate measures, and certainly hindsight may show some of those measures to have been unnecessary, or wrong. Kronstadt itself is a subject of much controversy, and it's not at all obvious that the Bolsheviks had better alternatives than to suppress the But they were measures taken by working class revolutionaries interrible conditions.

The Chinese rulers were also once revolutionaries of a sort - but a very different sort. Even in their militant youth, Deng and his associates were Stalinists, with no democratic tradition, let alone concern for workers' democracy. Now they are a class of pampered bureaucrats notorious for their corruption, Lenin for certain would have Tith the students, and against aurderers.

Edward Ellis, Southwark We you think of the most patronising tone (Mrs Thatcher) and the most anti-feminist diatribes (Norman Mailer) you feel pretty sick, yes?

Well not as sick as we felt when we read Jill Mountford's analysis of events in NUS's Women's Campaign.

Any woman who stands for election opens herself to criticism and, often, verbal abuse. Whatever the reasons for Gill Lewis's actions in standing for election and subsequently resigning, there should be no occasion which justifies the use of the word 'sisters' as a derogatory term.

By doing so, Jill Mountford rejects the principle of women working together and in solidarity with women from colleges all over the country Lindsay Judge Jan Taylor Manchester

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 408

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →