Ron Todd and the dock
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
dispute is largely the responsibility of Ron Todd and his supporters in the leadership of the TGWU. miserable performance and — more im- What is the explanation for Todd's portantly - what can we do about it? The first thing that needs to be said is that we are not talking here about individual cowardice or corruption. In fact, Todd's personal record is somewhat better than that of most trade union leaders. He started out as a fairly militant Fords shop steward at Walthamstow and, later, Dagenham. As the TGWU's chief negotiator, he gave some real strike. At the 1987 TUC Congress he denounced Eric Hammond as a "jackal' over the EETPU's scabbing at Wapping. To date, Todd has continued to defend the T&G's long-standing policy of unilateral disarmament.
No, Todd is not a gaffer's man and he is not a blind follower of the 'New Realism' that now dominates both the TUC and the Labour Party. But he is a reformist and a bureaucrat - terms that are not on this occasion intended as insults, but as a straightforward description of the political tradition he stands in and the role he plays within the trade union movement. For all his past willpredecessors, Moss Evans, Jack Jones and Frank Cousins. Like them he stands on the left' of the movement; like them he is not without personal integrity and even courage; like them he is a machine man for whom the union structures take priority over class struggles.
When in 1972, militant dockers defied the Heath, government's National Industrial Relations Court (NIRC) and waged a campaign of secondary action and picketing against containerisation, Jack Jones was quite prepared to face arrest and jail rather than recognise the NIRC. But when the NIRC proved (in Jones' words) "to clever to find that course!* and instead hit the union with E55,000 in fines and the threat of losing another £100,000 in damages, Jones fell over himself to disown the action — even to the point of threatening to withdraw the credentials of militant stewards.
This is precisely the tradition Todd stands in. The present docks dispute has shown up the limitations of Todd and his supporters with brutal clarity. No-one blames Todd for taking some precautions to protect the union's funds. But against the present government and its panoply of anti-union legislation any serious fight will eventually come up against the law one way or the other. Militants in the TGWU need to set about building a rank and file movement that puts the requirements of the struggle first. Immediately, tht means fighting for all-out action in the docks before the Scheme officially finishes at the end of this month: we should demand that Todd give such a lead, but recent events have shown that we can place no reliance on him.