Wipe away the tears!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Of you think of the saddest song (The Little Boy Santa Claus Forgot) and the most tearjerking film (Lassie Come Home) you feel pretty upset, yes?
But neither a child alone at Xmas with no toys nor that special canine friend facing danger can induce the sorrow that will sweep the campuses when the news breaks that Gill Lewis, 'el supremo' of the National Union of Students women's campaign, has resigned only two months after being reelected to the position of NUS women's officer.
Many tears of joy were shed by sisters at NUS women's conference when Gill was overwhelming re-elected, and now so soon after those celebrations the same sisters faces are all red and swollen again, this time with tears of sorrow. "Tis a mournful day.
But there is one consolation. Gill's main task — no, not to lead a campaign to defeat the poll tax, or campaign for creche facilities on all campuses, or even a campaign for tampon machines in all colleges — no, I mean the main task, to stop a Socialist Student supporter from being elected as NUS women's officer, has been achieved.
Gill confessed that she had been pushed into standing again, and that she had suffered ill-health throughout the second and third terms. She said, therefore, that her full commitment could not be guaranteed for the new academic year.
1, for one, am genuinely sorry if Gill is suffering ill health, but I suspect Gill's biggest health problem is her politics. Gill until recently was a member of the Communist Party and a peddler of Marxism Today (she rejoined the Labour Party publicly and immediately after her re-election as women's officer). She is soft on the Stalinist states, consistently voted with the Democratic Left leadership, is noted for her support for the official student unons in the Eastern Bloc and consistently votes against SSiN proposals to support the independent students unions, such as NZS in Poland.
She stands alongside the DL leadership on China — that is, in failing to make solidarity with Chinese students and workers in their fight for democracy and against their slaughter. She is also one of the growing breed of careerists who argue that the working class is dead, that nowadays everyone is sort of middle-class. She is one of that particularly ignorant breed of politicians who cannot picture a worker outside of the stereotype — ie, a man wearing clogs and a cloth cap. Gill's softness on Stalinism allows her to be as unprincipled as necessary, to bureaucratically carve out the hard left in NUS. Gill, like the DL leadership, is a hypocrite and partial to double standards, providing they're her own.
Gill, the greatest feminist to hit NUS since Julie Grant, made no reterence to her party affiliations or politics in her election address, but instead pronounced that she was standing as a woman working for women' and yet at the same tme she played a central role in ensuring the attack on other women, particularly Socialist Student women, for their political affiliations and policies, often distorting and taking out of context articles written by us.] Gill, the greatest feminist to hit NUS since Julie Grant, was party to a particularly foul and disgusting anti-feminist attack on women Socialist Student supporters when Communist Students put out a bulletin proclaiming boldly that women in Socialist Student were merely part of Simon Pottinger's harem.
Gill Lewis and her cohorts tried to make out that they're some sort of pure breed when it comes to women's politics; and that their world political - wommitting the carperspectives stand apart from their feminism, but it's plain that Gill's feminism is contaminated by her Stalinism.
Anyhow, on a lighter note, and putting both me and Gill in a bit of a quandry - imagine Hilary Lucas's face when she finds out that Gill Lewis is resigning! What a picture! After all, the only reason she didn't starfd for the post she so deserved was that sister Gill was standing. It looks like Gill has fouled her own nest a bit here.
As for Maeve, who can she now call upon to make those really vicious antiTrot speeches necessary to whip up the hysteria at NUS Conference when the DL is about to lose a vote? Those speeches really were Gill's forte.
There is some good news in all this. We do have a women's officer for next year. Yes, Maeve and Gill discussed it and decided to ask Natalie Jennings, who was elected to NUS women's committee from the lesbian caucus.
Gill then took it to the women's committee and politely asked everyone if they'd like to stand. Unfortunately for the DL, only Natalie could take on the responsibility of being NUS women's officer at such short notice.
So cheer up sisters, wipe away those tears, put a little make-up on those red eyes. All is not lost.
Turn to pers
Scan page 10
Belinda Dark' MA Weaver 'A Cry M - Michael and Lindy ention the names of Chamberlain these days, and you're likely to draw a blank. But mention the 'dingo baby' case and you'll probably get a response, even now, even here.
The famous Australian case, which began in August 1980 with the disappearance of baby Azaria from the Chamberlain family's tent at Ayers Rock, has long been a newspaper headliner.
For the Chamberlains, the case was a long nightmare that irrevocably altered their lives. They lost not just their baby daughter, but their privacy and their good names, and their marriage was almost destroyed by the unrelenting pressure of the case.
"A Cry in the Dark' tells the story from the Chamberlains' point of view, and it tells it clearly and dispassionately, separating facts from errors, myths and distortions, something that was impossible in the hysterical atmosphere of the time. The film is on their side.
Based on the book, "Evil Angels', by John Bryson, *A Cry in the Dark' is a very disturbing film, since it indicts not just the media whose persecution of the Chamberlain family reached horrific proportions, but also the entire Australian public who condemned Lindy and Michael unheard.
In tiny snippets throughout the film, different people chat about the case over dinner, in bars, in front of the television. Almost all condemn the Chamberlains. What is so frightening about these casual remarks is how familiar they are, and how seemingly innocent. Yet they all add up to a witch-hunting atmosphere.
The case was impossible to ignore, so it's hardly surprising that speculation and gossip were rife in all sections of the population. The case attracted the usual ghouls who became fixated on the accused in famous trials, but it also caught the imagination of millions of Australians.
In the film, one of Lindy's small sons is accosted in the street by a woman avid for knowledge. When she grabs the boy and demands to know what had really happened to baby Azaria, she is simply asking the question millions wanted to know. What really happened at Botulism breaks Meryl Streep as Lindy Chamberlain Ayers Rock?
Lindy claimed a dingo had taken the baby from the tent, and the first inquest confirmed the findings, and exonerated the Chamberlains from blame. But later, Lindy was accused of murder, and found guilty. Tw appeals failed to overturn the conviction and she spent four years in goal before being released on compassionate grounds. She and her husband were later granted a full pardon.* The film quite clearly shows that Lindy never had the slightest chance of a fair trial. The defence's case was complicated, and largely based on forensic evidence that the jury found hard to understand. The prosecution tried their hardest to demolish the dingo option, but completely failed to make a case for murder.
At no time during the trial did they ever try to establish a motive. In the absence of clear proof either way, the jury opted for a guilty verdict, and Lindy went to jail.
What probably drove them to a guilty verdict, despite a favourable summing up by the judge, and although the prosecution had not proved their case beyond all reasonable doubt, was the intense public dislike of the Chamberlains, which the press had carefully fostered. No jury could fail to be inluenced by the press reports which reated the Chamberlain: with unrelenting hostility and ridicule.
Lindy and Michael were Seventh Day Adventists, and this aroused prejudice. The Chamberlains' statement that their religion had helped them bear their tragedy infuriated the public, always quick to condemn people who were in any way "different'. Lindy's calm demeanour also alienated people. Had she wept, or shown grief, people might have swung behind her. When she refused to be what people expected of her, they turned savagely on her, and she was guilty in the eyes of the public betore she even got to court.
When Lindy appeared, stony faced, at the trial, an observer remarked: "Look at her! Enough to turn the milk sour."
Performances from Meryl Streep as Lindy and Sam Neill as Michael are both excellent. Sam Neill so strikingly evokes Michael Chamberlain that he almost cancels out memories of the real Michael. Meryl Streep on the other hand has no real physical likeness to Lindy, yet she manages to suggest both Lindy's mask-like determination to guard her feelings, and also the tumult of the feelings under the mask. It's her best performance to date, and she wrings a lot of feeling out of her flat, uninflected Australian accent.
Though the Australian public come in for criticism for their preJudices, it is really the press who are indicted in 'A Cry in the Dark'. The foot soldiers of the press waged an almost military campaign against the Chamberlains.
In the movie, microphones and video cameras are the weapons thrust into their faces whenever they step out of doors, the Chamberlain children are no longer able to play outside, and in one horrific scene, Lindy and Michael are menaced by three circling helicopters from the television networks. They no longer have any place to hide.
The vitriolic press campaign almost broke the Chamberlains, nearly destroyed their marriage, and they no longer live in Australia. Media persecution of that type is not unknown in this country, and it has driven many people to breakdown and even suicide. Yet the press rampages on, gleefully destroying lives and reputations as it goes.
The Chamberlains survived, despite a decade in the spotlight, and they had the hollow triumph of seeing the press there to cheer them on at the end when Lindy was released, and later when they were cleared from blame. The press, with complete inconsistency, switched tack after Lindy was convicted. From 'uncaring mother' and 'murderess', she had changed into that other press perennial - the innocent victim of injustice, the underdog.
A free press is an important freedom, yet a free press geared to profit can be a vile and dangerous thing, as cases like the Chamberlains' show. Lindy should have been tried by an unbiased jury of twelve, not by a hostile press concerned only to exploit and distort the tragedy for its own commercial ends. With the press whipping up hysteria, Lindy's trial was a mockery in which, against all rules of justice, she had to try to prove her innocence, rather than have her guilt proven by the prosecution.
Trial by media is an abomination, pandering as it does to bigotry, ignorance and prejudice. Even a guilty person should not be subjected to the kind of persecution the Chamberlains endured. It is simply inhuman.
Ironically Lindy finds greater peace within goal than out in the media spotlights, and her fellow prisoners (mostly aboriginal women and, like Lindy, outsiders in Australian society) are kinder and more understanding than the hostile public outside.
After revealing that Lindy and Michael were pardoned and found innocent, "A Cry in the Dark' ends with the words "The fight to restore their lives goes on." Amen.
It the start of every documentary we should be given short biography of the person who compiled it.
Not of the order of "so-and-so has two children and a dog and spends his time between his house in Dorset and a flat in Bayswater' But, certainly, 'so-and-so gained a diploma in Media Studies at Leeds University in 1960-odd and now contributes regularly to New Statesman/The Spectator'.
Then you could get an idea of where he or she was coming from.
Next, the documentor should be made to say,. 'this is what I think about and this is what I fight for; this is my theory on this particular subject, and this is how I intend to prove my point during this programme'!
Then you could decide if indeed you wanted to watch the programme; look out for the tricks they might use to make their point; and write to the TV companies to ask that, in future, they make programmes which simply tell the truth.
Perhaps 1 do like my documentaries as dry as dust, but the Inside Story Road LO Terror' programme about the Iranian Revolution, hastily put together to commemorate the death of Ayatollah Khomeini, irritated me with its generalisations and gimmicks.
What am I talking about? Things like bursts of religious music, especially towards the end of the programme. For most people in our society, choirs are usually 'heavenly' and this device was used to impress upon the audience that the 'truths' the programme attempted to convey are good for all time and God-given.
The programme-maker pursued the line that all revolutions degenerate into power, struggles between the groups of people who made the revolution and despotic domination of everyone else by the group which gets the upper hand.
So he drew a comparison between the terror after the French Revolution, and the atrocities of Ayatollah Khomeini's regime after the Iranian Revolution.
He carried the comparison to such a ludicrous extent as to imply that there was something of ironic historical significance in the fact that lots of Iranians fleeing Khomeini's own terror went to live in Paris.
What seemed to be reasonable history of the Iranian Revolution and its degeneration was muddied with tedious comparisons of that ilk, and the undaunting pursuit of its maker's hobbyhorse.
Documentary-makers have a duty to let the facts speak for themselves. When they come at a subject with some axe to grind, too often they find facts to fit their model but, although thankfully for the discerning, the framework usually
----- pull-quotes -----
TV By Vicki Morris