Do the divisions of the 1980s meet the needs of the 1990s?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
The left is not in good shape to respond to the revived industrial struggle.
committing the car- Turn Turn to pu
WARNING
GUARD DOGS group 4 stones (on strike) over nationalisation - or rationalisation. The employers spent £70 million on Preston docks, only to find the river was silted up. And when the docks closed, a lot of local firms closed, having no direct access to the sea. A similar thing happened to Trafford Park in Manchester when the docks were run down and closed.
Thatcher says they're the green party, yet they're putting everything on the roads — they could put trade on to the water.
They've learned from Ted Heath - he tried to take us all on at the same time. This lot are picking us off, group by group.
I don't know where they get this "jobs for life' from. The Dock Labour Scheme doesn't say anything about jobs for life' They're also saying they can't sack men. There's been more dockers sacked from Manchester than any firm in the country - thousands.
And when you got sacked there, you didn't just get sacked from a job, you got sacked from the industry. You couldn't go down to Liverpool docks and get a job there — no chance. Dock workers were pulled from under the Redundancy Payments Act at the employers' request - because it suited them at the time.
Second printing n out! 60p plus 14g postage from PO 823, London SE1 4NA. A call for left unity The left needs unity. The hard times of the 1980s have fragmented and dispersed our forces. The signs of revival in the struggle for socialism make regroupment possible - and urgent. The industrial struggle On the London buses and Tube, on the railways, on the docks, in local government, in the civil service, the direct industrial class struggle is renewing itself as it has not done since the miners' defeat in 1985. Workers' confidence is reviving.
Yet all these struggles urgently need solidarity. They urgently need rank-and-file links between workplaces and industries. And we have not even the beginnings of a cross-union, cross-industry rank-and-file movement that could organise solidarity and resist the attempts of the trade union bureaucracy to dissipate the fight back. The grouping which was best placed to initiate such a movement, the Broad Left Organising Committee, shows no signs of life at all. It never became more than a series of rallies gathered to listen to speeches from platforms.
We need a united left which fights to build a militant rank-and-file movement in industry. Labour's stampede to the right Neil Kinnock is stampeding the Labour Party to the right. At a time when the only party rapidly gaining votes is the one which clearly supports unilateral nuclear disarmament — the Greens - he wants to scrap Labour's unilateralism. He wants to commit Labour to managing capitalist market economics better, rather than replacing it with a different, socialist, economic system.
Yet the fight back from the left has been dispersed, scrappy, plagued with diversionary Ilationalist ideas like the demand for the repatriation of all British overseas investment.
We need a united response, clearly reaffirming socialism as workers" self-liberation - as different from state-monopoly Stalinism and statist social-democracy as it is from free-market capitalism.
And it must be a united response Within the Labour Party. Like it or not, the Labour Party, Neil Kinnock and all, is the political wing of the mass organisations of the British working class, the trade unions. Voluntarily to abandon the arena of the Labour Party is to abandon the political labour movement that actually exists, as it has developed over 100 years and more, to Kinnock and his co-thinkers.
We need a united left which fights for the politics of working-class self-liberation within the The Eastern Bloc The workers and students of China have shaken one of the world's most despotic and exploitative states. New workers' struggles in Eastern Europe are very likely.
Yet the solidarity mobilised by the left for workers' struggles in the Eastern Bloc remains very feeble compared to what is needed, or FICI even compared to what we have done on South Africa or Chile. The left is still dogged by double standards - the idea that oppressing and exploiting workers is not so bad if done by a regime which runs a nationalised economy.
We have a duty to the workers and students of China and the rest of the Eastern Bloc to boost our solidarity. And this is also a necessary part of the job of explaining to British workers what we mean by socialism and democracy.
'Socialism' , to many workers, still means something like the USSR. The left is unecessarily on the defensive on the issue of democracy. The Tories have been able to appear as the champions of democracy within trade unions. The Charter '88 initiative, with the Social and Liberal Democrats playing a leading role, has thrown many on the left into disarray on the question of democracy.
Socialism is workers' self-liberation - a revolution made by the immense majority in the interests of the immense majority. It is democratic by its very essence. Nationalisation of major enterprises is necessary, but it is only a -means to this end of workers' self-liberation. Nationalisation by a state which is controlled by a privileged minority ruling class is not socialism. Socialism is as distant from the state-monopoly regimes of the Eastern Bloc as it is from Western capitalism.
We need a united left which fights for solidarity with workers' and liberation struggles everywhere, West and East.
1992 and the internationalisation of capital The dispute on the docks highlights the terrible weakness of international links in the left and the working class. The drive to return the docks to casual labour is international. It is especially intense in Europe, where the 1992 reforms will mean that all trade from outside the EEC can be landed at whatever EEC port is cheapest and then moved inside the EEC without barriers.
Spanish and Italian port bosses have already done what the British port bosses are attempting. French port bosses have announced that they want to do the same in the near future. Yet there is no internaDISPUTE tionally co-ordinated workers' fightback — and no left organisation which is anywhere near having sufficient roots among dockworkers to lead such a We need left unity_ on a programme of workers' internationalism. Yet much of the left is defensive or in disarray over the issues raised by 1992 — not daring to continue its agitation for British withdrawal from the EEC, which is now discredited and was always a nationalist diversion, but not daring to decide to drop that demand, either.
The answer to the internationalisation of capital is workers? internationalism. Our answer to the EEC and to 1992 cannot be to look back to the days of more nationallybased capitalism, but to look tor ward to international coordination of workers' struggles.
We need a united left which fights for workers' internationalism as our answer to the growing internationalisation of capital, and the 1992 reforms in particular.
We also need a united left to fight to make the labour movement accessible to, and responsive to the demands of women, black people and lesbians and gays.
We need to develop Women for Socialism into a mass socialist feminist movement based on working class women and their struggles. We need to support black self-organisation and to fight racism at every level. We need to develop a united campaign against Section 28 and to end all discrimination against lesbians and gays.
When we cannot achieve full unity, we need left unity on particular issues and for particular campaigns.
We should support initiatives for coordination and discussion on the left like the Socialist Conference, the Campaign for Socialism and Labour Left Liaison.
We should form united support committees for every major industrial dispute, on the model of the support committees for the miners' strike, We should unite the left in the Labour Party around such rank-and-file initiatives as the Constituency Labour Parties Conference, Whose next gathering this coming autumn has now been sponsored by the Campaign Group.
We should unite with socialists outside the Labour Party in campaigns and support committees.
We should back the China Solidarity Campaign, the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, the Time to Go campaign on Ireland, the Anti-Apartheid movement, and solidarity with the Palestine Liberation Organisation.
Such single issue unity will always be necessary; there will always be groups on the left which have unbridgeable divisions on one issue but need to unite on another, and we need to learn that unbridgeable divisions on one issue should not exclude unity on another. But single-issue unity is a second best.
In Britain, America and some other countries before World War 1, there were socialist movements which consisted of a great variety of groups and factions, often with: overlapping memberships, which collaborated on single issues. Some people see that amiable chaos as a model for today. But it is not. Even before World War 1, the fragmented state of the British and American movements compared to others reflected weakness and immaturity rather than strength. And there is no point pretending that the disputes and divisions in the socialist movement over the last 75 years - over reform and revolution, Stalinism and other issues — just never happened.
We need to fight for unity which means trying to thrash out a political basis for unity by debate and discussion, rather than just agreeing to disagree. Already an important step forward has been made among students, where the recentlyformed Left unity movement unites many of the left on a wide-ranging programme.
That initiative could be a model for other areas. In every area we need to take stock of ourselves, and see whether the divisions of the 1980s really correspond to the needs of the 1990s. Let's start now!
This appeal has been issued by Socialist Organiser. We invite replies, comments, contributions and criticism from other groups and individuals on the left.
Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
----- pull-quotes -----
HOME OFFICE SECTI PASSPORT OFFICE LIVERPO CPSA
CPSA BESPAL