Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

CLR James

Socialist Organiser no. 407, 22 June 1989 · scan p. 5 · about 1,310 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

tempt to divide potential opposition to Soviet rule.

Uzbekistan began to industrialise under Stalin's Five Year Plans, and industrialisation became rapid with the invasion of the Soviet Union by Hitler, as factories were transferred from the path of the advancing Germans and relocated in Uzbekistan and elsewhere.

More recently, the official state sector of the economy has stagnated, while legal and illegal private sector has boomed. Private production is 20 to 30% of total output in Uzbekistan.

50 percent of meat, vegetable and wool production, 62% of milk production, and 41% of egg production come from the private sector.

The Uzbek republic is reckoned to be the most corrupt republic in the Soviet Union after Georgia.

The population of Uzbekistan is a hotch-potch of different ethnic groups, but the private sector of the economy is predominantly in Uzbek hands. Uzbeks are 69% of the population.

The Meskhetians, the victims of the recent pogroms in Uzbekistan, were originally of Georgian descent. In the seventeenth century they were conquered by the Turks and underwent a process of national and religious assimilation. The majority became Shi'ite Moslems and adopted Turkish as their national language.

In 1829 the bulk of Meskhetia was annexed into the Tsarist Empire. The Bolsheviks recognised the Meskhetians as Turks. The 1926 census counted them as Turks, and they were provided with Turkishlanguage schools. In the mid-1930s, however, the Stalinist regime redefined them as Azerbaidjani, and replaced their schools with Azerbaidjani-language ones.

In November 1944 the entire Meskhetian population was deported to Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, and elsewhere. The regime claimed it was evacuating people in case of advance by the German army - but the German army was in full retreat.

In fact, Stalin feared that the Meskhetians might have proTurkish sympathies, at a time when the Soviet Union was about to place a series of territorial demands upon An obituary by Al Richardson LR James, probably the most remarkable all-round intellect to have developed in the British Trotskyist movement, died in his flat in Brixton on 31 May.

Announcements in the media divide into cricket commentators, who do their best to understand his politics, and New Leftists, who do their utmost to misunderstand them. What did he really represent?

Cyril Lionel Robert James, known to him intimates as 'Nello' was born at Tunapuna near Port of Spain, Trinidad, on January 4th, 1901. He came to England with the encouragement of Learie Constantine, and after a brief acquaintance with Labour Party activists in Nelson in Lancashire, joined the Trotskyist movement in the Marxist Group, then undertaking entry work in the Independent Labour Party, where his basic political ideas were formed.

His greatest achievement at this time was to get the ILP conference to support the struggle of Abyssinia against Mussolini's invasion. The policy was reversed by. the leadership by the device of a members' ballot, but his campaign for workers' sanctions - against the League of Nations' sanctions advocated by the Stalinists (during which the USSR obligingly supplied Italy with oil) - influenced several NUR branches to contact the ILP and demand that it organises them.

In partnership with George Padmore, an old boyhood friend, he helped to reorganise the African Bureau and got out the journal International African Opinion, an anti-imperialist journal that -was smuggled into Africa with the help of friendly seamen. A ban on his book World Revolution similarly did not prevent it from circulating in the subcontinent.

It was this book, however, that ilustrated sharply that his views were diverging from those accepted in the Trotskyist movement. Influenced by Field and Weisbord (whose book The Conquest of Power James persuaded Frederick Warburg to publish) he dated the degeneration of the Comintern to an early date, and analysed some of Stalin's earlier actions, which Trotsky regarded as mistakes, as a result of deliberate policy. He similarly disagreed with the entry into the Labour Party, preferring to stay in the ILP to begin with, and then set up an open group.

For these reasons the International Secretariat decided to move him to the USA, both to 'straighten him out' and to give a free hand to his antagonist, Denzil Harber, in the newly (dis)united British Trotskyist group. It was a short-sighted error.

During the war many of the group of colonial students in Britiain met to discuss their struggle for freedom from imperialist rule, and at that conference were several of the heads of state of the countries to become independent of direct colonial rule in the post-war world. Who knows how far revolutionary politics would have shaped the independence movement, James had been left at the hub of the imperialist system to be able to continue to influence these leaders?

Nor did the policy of subordinting the needs of the international movement to the task of building up the SWP among the USA's black population pay off. Apart from the differences in social background, cultural upbringing etc, James joined the split of Max Shachtman's 'Workers' Party' from the SWP less than a year later. There he defended the position that the USSR was a 'state capitalist' society, as opposed to the workers' state position of Martin Abern and Shachtman's own "bureaucratic collectivism'.

Realising, as Lenin had done in the previous imperialist war, that there was a serious theoretical crisis in Marxism, he did what Lenin did, and went back to fundamentals, studying Hegel once again along with Raya Dunayevskaya, the results of which were later published in Notes on Dialectics (1948).

The political failure of the Fourth International's perspectives at the same time led the Socialist Workers Party and the Workers Party into exchanging factions: Goldman and Morrow went over to Shachtman and James ('JR Johnson') and Dunayevskaya ("Freddie Forest') went back to Cannon. But the already sclerotic SWP was not a congenial place for developing new ideas, and he was out in a couple of years.

Hard on this followed his expulsion from the USA in 1953, during the McCarthy years. His refusal to compromise with neo-colonialism led to his being placed under house arrest by Eric Williams, one of his own pupils.

His well-known works on cricket (Beyond a Boundary), on revolutionary history (Black Jacobins and A History of Negro Revolt) on literature and politics (State Capitalism and World Revolution) bear witness, not only to the extraordinary range of his interests, but also to the originality that he brought to them. For the key to James' character was that he refused to be part of anyone else's orthodoxy, and disdained to construct one around himself.

Friday, Saturday, Sunday July 7th, 8th and 9th Caxton House, St John's Way, Archway, North As late as the sixties (at the famous 'Dialectics of Liberation' conference) he opposed black separatism and pointed to the working class as the motor force of socialist revolution; in 1986 he was still opposing the chimera of a separate black 'bantustan' in the USA. His bookshelves were lined with the classics of literature, of Marxism, of cricket and of ancient history; there was nothing trendy or superficial about him. But his life and thought were devoted to the defence of the oppressed, on whatever continent and in whatever society.

James may not have found the answers to all the problems he so bravely confronted. But he dic demonstrate that a Trotskyist training is indispensable for asking the correct questions, and this basic grounding in classical Marxism: formed the real unity behind his thought. His. world view was formed in the movement in this country. and by a strange final twist to the dialectic in his last weeks he was assisting Socialist Platform to bring out again his World Revolution, a task that we now undertake in his memorystudents) or £4 (un Turn

----- pull-quotes -----

Workers' Liberty '89

Register now! £8, £6 (low-waged and

waged) to Workers' Liberty, PO Box 823, London SE 4NA.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 407

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →