How not to argue for withdrawal
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 68 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 68
Must Get Out' by Paul Foot Any consideration of the A political situation in Northern Ireland amongst socialists must be based on three central points - one that the oppression the Catholic minority must be lifted, two that the two segments of the Irish people must be able to live together, and three, that the final goal of any 'solution' must be to unite the Irish working class, Catholic and Protestant, Green and Orange, in a fight for the socialist answer to the ruin, poverty and mass which Irish capitalism imposes on the workers of Ireland, North and South of the partition border.
The British left often loses sight of these goals and becomes fixated on slogans - using the history of Ireland to justify the slogans and distorting it in the process. It would do the left good to forget its slogans for a while, and look at the real situation.
are responsible for maintaining the framework of an ununworkable necessitates the denial of civil liberties to of the community, resulting in deaths, maimings, horrors like strip-searching, non-jury courts and mass denial of human rights. Where that community has fought back it has been "terrorist and the word has been used to justify further oppression: The Northern Ireland state can only be sustained by these methods because it is artificial and unjust by its very nature.
But any attempt to change the situation comes up against the fact that there communities in Northern Ireland. The united Ireland which would satisfy the Catholics is unacceptable to the Protestants, and they have always been prepared to fight to stop a independent Ireland.
When Britain has tried to impose a more equitable framework on an unworkable system the Protestants have fought them - as they fought powersharing in 1974. There is every reason to suppose they would do so again and that they would fight the Catholics as well. So any suggestion of a united Ireland comes into conflict with an apparently immovable obstruction.
The Protestants do not want to be a large minority in a Catholic state. They are a distinct community, considering themselves British or at least different from the Irish majority.
The way to get them to agree to a united Ireland is not to simply pull out British troops and leave them to sink or swim. But it is not reasonable to allow the current situation to continue because the Protestants don't want change.
The Protestants must have rights as a large minority in a united Ireland, and the structure of the new state should be such that the majority cannot remove those rights. The only possible structure which could work is that of a federal united Ireland, freeing the Northern Catholics from their oppression, but giving the Protestants local autonomy in the geographical area where they form the majority (which is not the whole of Northern Ireland by any means).
A solution ensuring the security of both communities gives a real chance that the communal divisions can break down. Just calling for socialism won't suffice, because the working class in Ireland is buth Catholic and Protestant and ony the united working class can make socialism. It is wishful thinking to suppose the working class can be united now, under these conditions, by breadand-butter issues and calls for socialism. Unity may be possible for a short time for a few people, or on a few issues — but such accord swiftly breaks down in a country split by communal tension.
There is no magic slogan which will ensure peace, unity and the potential to build socialism. The debate has been raging on the left for many years with too much hiding behind slogans and far too little honest appraisal of reality.
The blurb on the back of Paul T Foot's offering to the debate on Ireland (Ireland: Why Britain Must Get Out) describes the turn to page 6l