Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

NOT ANGELS Because the troops do not have the ingrained Specials, they will not

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 66–68 · about 1,910 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 66 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 66

headline in Socialist Worker in April 1969! In August, when the troops moved centre stage, it was eloquently dropped.

On August 17th 1969, a hastily convened special meeting of members of the two leading comittees of the International Socialists voted by 9 to 3 to drop the Troops Out slogan "as a headline", while the text of articles and editorials would make clear that IS wasn't really siding with the British Army.

But the IS leaders were facing both ways. The decision to approve what the troops were doing had to be defended against the IS leadership's critics from the left, notably the Workers' Fight faction within its ranks.

arkong' behave will lousness -La pogrom.

I Suäno on Already in the very first editorial, which was supposed to put to rights the absence of Troops Out "in the headline" by warning about the army's "long term role", Socialist Worker readers were told that though the callirg earches against Unioniet traitore, the troope ould be forced to act againet Palaley and his supporter he wecting after further diacussion, very olearly held 3 positione. | (1) Cdes. Falser, Cliff, Haran, Harris & Protz ¿ tha ve continue vith our present policios. (2) Cdes. Hallae, Nagliatti, that we should prepare th ground in our editorials to eventually call for the withdrawal of British troopB. (3) Cde. Lindop - that ve call for the eithdravel o Fritish troope now.

specmal IS 17.8.69: IS EC minutes 29.9.69 troops were "not angels" they will not behave with the same viciousness as the RUC and B-Specials "because they do not have the same ingrained hatreds". (A resolation at the Executive Committee to insert & statement

Scan page 67

that the troops' presence was 'in the long term interests of British imperialism" had in fact been voted down by Tony Cliff, John Palmer and Paul Foot.)

The warning seemed to consist of the mildly critical thought that "It should not be thought that the British troops can begin to solve the problems (of the Catholic workers). The role of the British troops is not to bring any real (!!) solution to the problems of the people of Northern Ireland..."

Within a couple of weeks, the main fire was directed at the leadership's critics. (Meanwhile, a Troops Out emergency motion at IS's conference was defeated after the leaders had pulled out a good many demagogic stops to create an atmosphere of hysteria in which those who argued for Troops Out were accused of being "fascists" who "wanted a bloodbath".)

There were constant attacks in Socialist Worker on 'those who call for the immediate withdrawal of British troops", , accompanied by warnings about the horrors of life in Catholic Belfast without British troops. "When the Catholics are armed they can tell the troops to go" , a front page caption in SW generously conceded. But the idea of these armed Catholics using their bullets to tell the troops to go was just unthinkable: " ...they would merely add their bullets to those of the Paisleyites and provoke an immediate clash in a situation which would lead to massacre." And "when the Catholies are armed" they would tell the troops to go because, the assumption went, they wouldn't need them anymore — not because they were and would be the enemy.

The paper had at first presented the issue as a purely internal Northern Ireland one, as if the British ruling class had no interest in the matter. The troops were passive and neutral: "Behind the lines of British troops the repressive apparatus of Stormont remains' - as if the troops were not themselves repressive.

Continuing this line of thought: 'the Special Powers Act, which permits imprisonment without trial, has not been revoked" -presumably, if the troops were really doing a proper job, they might have gone on to revoke the Act. "And when the troops leave..." it will all still be there. It didn't occur to them that the troops might not leave but stay on and themselves imprison people without trial.

The IS leaders concocted an elaborate and convoluted theory of lesser and greater contradictions to justify their position.

The greatest 'contradiction' was between the troops and the Paisleyites, who were thwarting British designs for a bourgeois united Ireland. Meanwhile the 'contradiction' between the troops and the Catholics' barricades, and the Catholic workers' arming and self defence, would only become acute "at some future turn". A centre page article by Stephen Marks presented the case for British troops to stay under the headline: •Fine slogans and grim reality — The contradictory role of British troops gives Catholic workers time to arm against further Orange attacks"

The benefits of the British army in Belfast and Derry were that they were "freezing" the conflict, "buying time" and providing "a breathing space" in which Catholics could prepare to fight the Orange mobs. They could also, apparently, "re-arm politically" in the course of opposing the moderates' calls for reliance on the army — though no thanks to Socialist Worker, which stood four-square with the moderates with its apologetics for the British Army.

The 'contradiction' between the Army the Catholics' barricades and guns was in fact acute from the first day. The army's aim to prevent such self-defence by substituting for it, and by repressing it.

In the very week when the troops were taking down the barricades this same article talked of a "future turn in the situation when the demolition of the barricades may (!) be needed in the interests of British capital itself and not merely of its local retainers"

IS made a big thing of the barricades. Defence of the barricades had been its militant call, substituted for Troops Out as soon as the troops were on the streets. The special issue of SW on Ireland following the change of line had declared in banner headlines: "The barricades must stay until: *B-Specials disbanded *RUC disarmed *Special Powers Act abolished «Political prisoners released" And on 11th September the main headline was "Defend the Barricades — No peace until Stormont goes".

This was in fact a call for British direct rule indefinitely — just as today calls for "Troops Out and Disarm the Protestants" translate in the real world into a demand for more troops not less — for who is going to "Disarm the Protestants"?

But the week the barricades were taken down in Belfast found SW with its main centre page policy article defending SW's failure to call for the troops to go (and in so doing, defending the troops themselves); and the week the barricades were brought down in Derry, as a prelude to the liquidation of 'Free Derry' ' found SW utterly silent on the question.

To continue to call for the defence of the barricades would have meant to call the Catholics into conflict with the troops — which really would have exposed 'the main contradiction' in IS's line.

When IS finally re-adopted Troops Out in May or June of 1970 on a National Committee resolution from Sean Matgamna of Workers' Fight (they had fought tooth and nail to avoid defeat on the question at the Easter conference (wo months earlier) the IS leaders said they had been right all along, and of course they were right now to change. One took one's position 'in response to changes in the immediate role of the troops". It all depended on just what the Army was doing at any particular time, though in fact the decisive change in the relationship of the Catholics to the British soldiers didn't come until later, when the switch from a Labour to a Tory government (June) led to a clumsy 'get tough' attitude to the Catholics, and then to the curfew on the Lower Falls in July 1970.

The IS leaders didn't for long hold to that line that they had been right all along. For many years they have denied they ever argued for the troops to stay, and declare that those who say so are slanderers, "scabs", "proimperialists", 'Zionists" etc.

In true Stalinist fashion they go through the old papers, picking out a quote here and there out of context to support their claim that "week after week after week" they opposed the troops. But there are two simple words that they can never quote after the August of that crucial year, and they are: TROOPS OUT.

contradictory role of British tre gives Catholic workers time to Larm against further Orange attacks TIENTS in Not- tante thost KERF OUT Slogans behind the Protesu hu STE 9.69 part of the majority in a bourgeois united Ireland, which would not fulfil the oft-quoted Connolly's desires one But the real tragedy is that Foot's book does not advance his cause at all. The cause is peace in Ireland, and the unity not of geography but of the Irish working class - Orange and Green. There are real injustices in Northern Ireland, injustices arising out of the artificial state imposed by partition. A minority of Catholics have been imprisoned inside this state, and they are entitled to better treatment than they get at the hands of the British army or Orange bigots. They are entitled to fight back - and Foot can call it terrorism if he wishes, but if he does he panders to the very prejudice he claims to be fighting. The fact remains that it is the Catholics who have been systematically terrorised, and oppressed, and it is with these people that our sympathy should lie.

But the British left has a responsibility to do more than sympathise or to raise the empty cry of 'troops out' in isolation from the other issues.

The question why Britain Must Get Out is easily answered: because Britain has done a lot more harm than good, and cannot aid the Irish working class in their struggle for peace, unity and socialism. But if the British troops left tomorrow, a million people calling themselves British would be left behind They do not want to be incorporated into a Catholic state, and there is far more reason to suppose that they would forcibly resist incorporation than to suppose, as Foot does, that it would all be OK.

The evidence is that the Protestants would fight. The evidence is that there would be a bloody civil war, and that civil war would lead not to unity but to re-partition with, probably, a smaller Protestant state with a smaller Catholic minority. The problem created by the fact that there are two communities in Ireland will not go away with the British troops any more than it can be written away by sleight of hand rhetoric. That problem has to be met head on, confronted, faced up to, not slid round with talk of 'guarantees' The reason the problem must be addressed is not to simply conclude that the Protestants will only accept a continuation of the status quo. The status quo is unacceptable, it does not work, it is an artificial creation and it is not the expression of the Protestants' political rights.

Scan page 68

Protestants clash with the RUC in Por tadown. Photo: John Arthur (Reflex) Liz Millward reviews •Ireland: Why Britain

----- pull-quotes -----

The Socialist

ish troops is short but vital. troops before the men behind the barricades can defend pogrom which will hit first

COCKNASE. Sories Worker- int. 9i 69.= merr tvo, SNY 211.81. 60- SM page 11m9u69 minutes or

from SWis centre KEEP OUT.

The Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →