Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Worker and Troops Out

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan p. 66 · about 578 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 66 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 66

Belfast on Sunday: when the Catholics are armed they can tell the troops to go British troops. Troops Out is a dogma and a fetish. To question it is to define yourself out of the left. Amongst the most dogmatic and least thoughtful on this question is the SWP — whose members reflexively shout abuse at those who question the wisdom of Troops Out without a political settlement.

Yet, back in 1969 when the British army was first put on the streets in Northern Ireland, the SWP refused to call for their withdrawal. Members of the SWP (IS) who wanted to call for Troops Out were denounced as "blood-thirsty fascists" . The leadership kept up an unprincipled common front against the opposition. For example, Duncan Hallas was in agreement with the opposition, but he either kept his mouth shut or backed Tony Cliff in the debates. For nearly a year IS maintained the position.

Today they deny that they ever had it, and say it is slander to say they did. In the interests of clean living and in the hope of shocking comrades miseducated by the SWP's current line on Ireland - that "Troops Out Now' is a matter of basic principle which only "scabs", "proimperialists" and "Zionists" question — into thinking about the issue, we print this count of what happened in IS in 1969.

In August 1969 the major group on the far left in Britain, panicked by the pogroms in Belfast and Derry, were so relieved to see the British troops go into action that for nearly a whole year they dropped the slogan British Troops Out'.

For months before August, when the British troops had no role in Northern Ireland affaifs, they had made Troops Out one of their main slogans. It was a front page Tie pollo.

A vote was taken 38 to whether ve should British troope as a headiine.

For: odes, Hallas, "rot», Hagliatti Against: edes. Iooker, Earin, ClIff, Osborne, Milson, I. Lindop as head that we eit carolies to the Northern people. The intervention of the British troops only allows a temporthe defences of the Catholic community can be strengthen In Derry in narticular the :31 •ld do sper •re followed & fengthy discussion on the s1tuation 'elan and our attitude to Britiah troops. hiist there appeared to be general agreewent on the ro df Si editorials in atatine the roactionary role of the arltiah troopa of the role of British Government, the urgument atill vaged over the putting of the slogan now "withdraw British troops".

Cdes. Cliff & Falmer had said ve wust emphasiee workin Catholica in the Nerth wanted British troope to. remain. Cde. Hallas aaid that it vas incompatible to support mrking class action in the South and yet accept troope n the North aince the role of troope 1a to protect fartttion. however unpalatible, ve have to tell the tru;

Frleer & Cliff pointed out that ve heve • the objestive situat on in Vorthern Ireland. to take asking the Britiah troope to withdr Catholics are not If they did, the troops vould go and the Catholies murdered. The B-Specials hal not noticeably responded 11cenced guns (how many urili senced?) and the Catholic adn't got them. At the same time, the troops vere not here, cde. Falmer pointed out, to protect Paialey, but co consolidate the Stormont regime, and with Paisley

----- pull-quotes -----

thought that the presence of British troops can begin to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →