Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How not to argue with- draw

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 63–66 · about 3,610 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 63 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 63

This thin app the things that really matter, and that a positive solution and the avoidance of sectarian civil war within Ireland is a secondary issue.

It is possible to delude oneself with a crude theory of the Protestants as pure pawns of Britain, so that their reactionary ideas would drain away like waters out of a bath once the 'plug' of British troops was pulled out.

But that is not Marxism. It is not serious, honest politics. We will not even be very reliable anti-imperialists if our "anti-imperialism' is only as strong as our ability to use consoling myths to shield our eyes from uncomfortable facts — until they explode in our faces. Such fantasies and evasions will never allow those socialists who poison themselves with them to make any political contribution to the work of uniting the Irish working class.

The federal proposal might not avert sectarian civil war, either. Whether anything short of a mass socialist movement uniting the workers of both communities (or a big section of them) can end the present impasse in a progressive sense is doubtful. Our programme is to develop that socialist movement; seriously, not by empty schematising about the present nationalist struggle becoming socialist if only it is intensified sufficiently, or national/communal issues fading away if only bread-andbutter trade union issues are emphasised loudly enough.

We should not blunt our socialist programme by false 'realism', by getting tied up in working out 'answers' for the present forces in the situation over which we have no control anyway. But a socialist programme needs to include democratic demands, and a possibility of relating to the political situation now, to peter Whether we can have any positive in- more concretely than just by saying that a united class movement would be better.

fluence on the situation within Ireland depends on there being a material force to fight for such a programme. At present there is no such force. But no force can be gathered without first proclaiming a programme. And no adequate programme can be formulated without first coldly 'saying what it is' Our errors summary demonsti k, the consistency 'oach that some of we the ive assessments were correct: but we tended to downplay our own assessments, criticisms and politics in deference to a petty-bourgeois nationalist formation because it was leading the struggle against imperialism'. We should not have been so self-effacing.

Footnote • We tried to bring the national question to the centre in 1969 by posing it like this:

the mainly Catholic areas (about half the land area of Northern Ireland) should secede to the Republic. This was based on the idea that it would make the Northern state unviable.

The belief that secession of the Catholic areas would force the Protestants into a united Ireland was a major reason why the Free State made the deal they did in 1921. Lloyd George promised that a Boundary Commission would in fact redraw the boundaries, thus making Northern Ireland unviable.

In fact secession was anyway the trend in Northern Ireland. Two times before August 1969, Catholic Derry, two miles from the border with the 26 Counties, had set up barricades to keep out Northern Ireland state personnel. In August 1969 Catholic Derry and Catholic West Belfast set up 'free' areas guarded by their own militias. These survived until October 1969.

But in retrospect secession was an artificial way to pose the question of the smashing of the Six County state. In the light of experience since then, there can be no doubt that a Protestant state stripped of the mainly Catholic areas would be viable because the Protestants would make it so.

Some of us were in IS at the time, and our (tentative) proposal about secession was contained in a resolution for IS conference, written in May or June 1969. At the September 1969 IS conference, the leadership used a disloyal misrepresentation of it to distract the discussion. In the meantime they had changed their line from opposition to the British troops to effective support for them, and we were campaigning against this.

The IS leadership said that we wanted the repartition of Ireland. But our resolution explicitly said the goal should be to smash the Northern Ireland state and establish a united Ireland. Because of the weight of the Is/SWP, this misrepresentation of our position is widespread. It is to be found, for example, in the Penguin book "The Left in Britain', edited by David Widgery.

back page 'Counter Blasts' series, of which Foot's book is part, as "Britain's finest writers and thinkers...in the best tradition of pamphleteering...new perspectives... voices of dissent... written to question, to surprise, to stir up debate and to change people's minds."

Given the content of the book, only one conclusion can be drawn — that the series' editors know absolutely nothing about Ireland, past or present. Otherwise they would not have published a book containing such wild inaccuracies and bizarre 'surprises' One of the "surprises' discovered by this 'fine writer and thinker' is that Ireland, contrary to popular belief, has 36 counties (p.10). No wonder Foot is described as aiming to 'stir up debate' Another "new perspective' is the interchangeability of the terms Home Rule and independence. Foot seems to believe they mean the same thing.

Few other 'fine thinkers' share his belief, indeed many people outside the 'best tradition of pamphleteering' would describe this as a criminal mistake leading to distortion and confusion. It may be that Foot genuinely believes that a Home Rule deal which means an oath of allegiance to a foreign monarchy and no power for the Irish government to raise taxes or an army is the same thing as a treaty of independence. Certainly thing.

But even if Foot is confused about Home Rule, and the 36 counties is a typographical error, the following 'new persin ivy sero, barone a sinnie shet was fired by the IRA, British troops imposed a curfew in the Catholic Falls Road in Belfast - but there was no equivalent curfew in the Protestant Shankhill.

Ireland

Scan page 64

For the record The facts, which are presumably available to this 'fine thinker' are these: the curfew was imposed after Protestants attacked a church in the Falls, and three of them were shot dead by the Official IRA. A curfew had been imposed in the Shankhill the previous October. Those facts don't suit Foot's argument so, 'in the best tradition of pamphleteering', he has left them out.

For every accurately recorded fact, there is a piece of nonsense_ like the above. Confusion abounds. How long have the British been oppressing the Irish? a) six centuries or b) since the 16th century or c) 300 years?

When were the B-Specials abolished?

When is a ban (or the Orange ider no?

a ban?

The answers to these and other questions cannot be found in Paul Foot's book - because neither he nor anyone else has bothered to read the manuscript and weed out the inaccuracies, contradictions and other 'surprises'. On average, the reader can find at least one such 'surprise' on each page.

However, this is really nitpicking; even a 'fine writer' like Foot can make mistakes - though this many is indeed a 'surprise'!

The first 50 odd pages of the book are spent establishing what passes for Irish history in Foot's mind, with a selection of quotations from James Connolly and various Orange and British politicians. Foot has obviously had access to a wealth of material, so it is astonishing that he makes such a bad job of it.

He cannot resist hyping up every atrocity, and consequently distorting most of what he relates, until the distortion ruins what, told baldly and without hype, would be a damning tale of British ruling class plunder and oppression in Ireland.

He uses emotive words like 'colony', "imperialism' and so on, over and over again, without serious definition. Ireland's history does not need codifying into left jargon, and it particularly does not need confusing in the process. The truth of Ireland's history does not sustain many left prejudices and 'wisdoms' and it should not be distorted so that it does.

The Republican cause espoused by James Connolly loses absolutely nothing from an honest account of history. It can only gain, because by learning from that history we have the potential to move forward.

The final chapter of lorkers? tain Must Get Out is given over to Foot asking himself four hard questions, and then attempting to answer them - or rather avoiding answering them at all.

The first question concerns the pledges made by Britain to the Protestants that Northern Ireland will remain tied to Britain - "How," asks Foot, "can we break these pledges to them without their agreement?"

He answers the question thus: the British government has broken lots of pledges (not least to the Catholics) John Downes murdered therefore there isn't a problem if another one is broken. The real issue of course is not promises made by British governments - "we" can neither keep nor break those, nor do we identify with or take responsibility for the British state - but the fact that one million Protestants insist they are tied to Britain because they consider themselves British.

The problem is not the pledge - that can be broken at the drop of a hat — but the agreement of the people to whom the pledge was made. All Foot does is say the pledge can be broken, he says nothing about persuading the Protestants to agree to British withdrawal. Does he think that doesn't matter? Apparently.

But he does raise the question of minority rights: "If there is a 'duty' to there is ario a dhy No the on noriand, How true. Does it not therefore follow that the Protestants who would constitute a minority in a united Ireland should be considered in the same way as the current Catholic majority in the North? In other words, is Foot, having raised the idea of minority rights, going to apply it consistently to both communities?

He doesn't say, but he makes another attempt to skate around the issue in his next question: The Protestants are a majority in Northern Ireland - how can any democrat flout the will of a majority? A fair question (though not the really important one). The majority in Northern Ireland don't want to be incorporated into a united Ireland. So what does Foot say?

He says that in a united Ireland the Protestants would not be a majority. In other words if we pretend that Ireland is already united we can safely ignore the wishes of a million of its people and still be democrats. And this from the man who raised the issue of minority rights!

In fact Foot is not in favour of minority rights at all. He simply wishes the current Northern Ireland Catholic minority to become part of an all-Ireland majority, and to hell with the consequences. The question of getting the Protestants to agree to become a minority has now been buried for good, although he does go on to deal with the Protestants' most obvious reason for not agreeing.

Foot asks: if a united Ireland became Catholic state? His answer to this question is essentially Yes, they would, so it's back to 'minority rights' "Protestant fears...have some force. But how best are minority rights protected in any society? Are they best protected by partition, by isolation or ine minority in a separate state of their own? Throughout the world, where these problems of racial and religious minorities are repeated over and over again in a thousand different forms, separation and partition of communities on racial or religious lines merely inflames the differences, institutionalises them in politics and in government, and turns one former minority, fearful of persecution, into a persecuting majority, seeking others to discriminate against, to mock, bully and suppress."

Indeed. Once again Foot creates the illusion that he is in favour of minority rights, this time for the Protestants whose right to agree to what happens to them in the future he has just written off, in answering questions one and two.

What solution does he propose therefore to overcome the unwillingness of the Protestants to be incorporated into a Catholic state — given that he appears to be arguing that they may very well finish up a persecuted group?

'Guarantees of religious and dividual freedoms are what they say they ores to its minorities. The way to socie which every society that the Jewish or black minorities in Britain are safe from persecution is to hold out to them the rights of free citizenship which are available to everyone else; to ensure that there is no privilege afforded to anyone because of their race or religion; and to persecute racial and religous persecutors.

«Wherever such freedoms are upheld they ensure freedom for religious an racial minorities a thousand times more effectively than do separate states whic shore up the political power of gods or skin colour over human beings an: create and persecute other minorities.

Scan page 65

Foot is the author of works on racism including The Rise of Enoch Powell, so he cannot but know that Jews and blacks in Britain "have the rights of free citizenship" — and that isn't enough! Britain, an essentially secular state, does "not ensure that no privilege is afforded to anyone because of their race...etc." Racism, despite 'guarantees' is rampant.

What then does he expect from a determinedly Catholic state? In fact nothing — he does not expect "guarantees' to be kept, as he has said in answering his first question. Pledges can be, and consistently are, broken by governments when it suits them.

All the evidence is that pledges and guarantees to religious and racial minorities are broken the world over. Already in Southern Ireland Jews and Protestants have to abide by Catholic laws on divorce, so why should a 'guarantee' have any effect? And the Protestants obviously don't believe in offers of such 'guarantees' . The essence of Foot's argument is simply this: in an ideal world, everything would be ideal.

Foot misses the point. The danger is not that a Catholic united Ireland would ban Protestant churches or Protestant religious opinion. The Catholics in Northern Ireland have always had freedom to practise their religion and indeed to have separate Catholic schools. They have been oppressed socially, as a minority community with a nationa identity distinct from the majority, not as a religious group. Such oppression is what the Protestants fear from a Catholic united Ireland.

Legal guarantees of individual rights from a state they considered alien could no more satisfy the Protestants than a Bill of Rights could settle the problems of the Catholics in Northern Ireland.

Britain made guarantees to the Northern Ireland Catholics. It didn't keep them. This is Foot's argument in favour of Britain not keeping its pledges to the Protestants.

Why does he therefore assume, as he so blithely does, that Ireland would keep any pledges to the Protestants. He may believe that the Irish state is more honest in its promises than Britain - but the Protestants obviously don't. And that is the point at issue.

Foot has already demonstrated that he believes in majority rule. What he is doing here is covering his back for a British audience, who may be preparea to go along with him for an easy life, and a glib answer. The Southern Ireland state has made vague promises to the Protestants. The Protestants don't want to know. Why? Because they wouldn't be guarantees while majority rule is the only rule, unless the Protestants have some kind of autonomy.

Foot argues that there are two alternatives — majority rule in a united _reland, or the status quo, which for him is the only possible expression of Protestant political rights. Actually the Northern Ireland state is not equivalent to Protestant political rights, and the Protestants have good reason to fear a united Ireland with majority rule only. He won't look at what would really constitute Protestant political rights (local autonomy, a federal system) because a) he doesn't believe in minority rights at all, and b) he thinks. Protestant rights means the current Northern Ireland For Foot, as for most of the British left, if he can solve the problem of the Protestants on paper by repeated use of the word 'guarantees' that is enough. Unfortunately for the British left this is not a logic-problem. The current minority is brutally oppressed because, through no fault of its own, it got trapped in an artificial state. Therefore socialists side with that minority. Therefore also we do not advocate the creation of a situation where one oppressed minority is liberated to be replaced by another twice the size.

Socialists also have a duty not to advocate the signing away of the rights of a million people because we can't be bothered to think things through consistently.

Foot asks his final question, the so-called "bloodbath' question. As with his previous three questions he doesn't answer it. He devotes several pages to debating : whether the Protestants are capable, or willing, to fight to the last drop of blood to defend 'their' state. Then, having concluded, in the teeth of the evidence, that probably they won't, he says that such speculation is anyway not the "chief answer to the bloodbath argument" The 'chief answer' apparently lies in Foot's own speculation, or rather gambling, on the following longshot:

"There is a chance, after withdrawal, that Irish labour, so long truncated by religious feuds between workers, might come together to demand the new Ireland of which Connolly dreamed. In the shock of the collapse of the Old Order, the positive sides of the people of Ireland of both religions could well prevail over the narrow superstitions which have kept them at each other's throats for so long."

Quite apart from the fact that Foot has just reduced centuries of communal conflict, which he spent 60 pages proving had a material base, to 'religious feuds' and 'narrow superstitions' , this boils down to: maybe if you take the troops away everything will be all right.

This is an assertion, not the answer to a very serious question. It is moreover the same assertion Foot made on page 1 of his book: 'There is a way out of the endless cycle of killing and terror. It is for the British government to cut its connection with the state of Northern Ireland and to get out of Ireland." Foot cannot prove this assertion. He does not try. He evades either proving it or answering the 'bloodbath' question by answering another question - why won't Britain withdraw the troops?

He argues that Britain does not keep the troops in Ireland because withdrawal would result in a bloodbath. He says that when Britain withdrew from India and the Central African Federation there were bloodbaths. From this he the does not conclude either that there would be a bloodbath in Ireland or that there wouldn't because things are different in Ireland, but that Britain didn't care that there were bloodbaths in Africa or India, so why should Britain care about a bloodbath in Ireland?

Foot concludes that Britain in fact stays in Ireland because it doesn't want to be 'defeated' by terrorism:

As this is what successive British governments have said openly and repeatedly, it doesn't need a 'fine thinker' like Foot to work it out. Most schoolchildren would come up with the same answer. He couples this conclusion with his original assertion to produce the following:

"As long as...persecution...and [the British] state remain, terrorism and the sectarianism which breeds it, are certain to continue. The fear of 'defeat' therefore is nothing more than political paralysis. It conserves terrorism without ending it. It sustains sectarianism."

Therefore the British people should demand "that the troops come home" The page 1 assertion all over again. The only difference is that 'narrow superstitions' etc. have become "terrorism' and 'sectarianism' , again negating everything previously said about who precisely are the terror merchants in Northern Ireland.

In other words, what Foot is doing is trying to tell us 'Why Britain Must Get Out' by actually telling us 'Why Britain Stays In' — an entirely different question.

Part of the reason this book is so monumentally irritating is that it is so full of inaccuracies, inconsistencies and contradictions that it is extremely difficult to find the politics it is supposed to contain. Foot throws out an argument, a few bits of dodgy history, hypes it up a bit, then concludes that the troops should leave whether or not the original argument supports that conclusion or even has anything to do with it. Foot's arguments and conclusions are entirely unrelated. Consequently, what comes across is that Foot is not particularly convinced himself.

Most rank and file SWP members, who have not been writing about Ireland or involving themselves in Irish politics for as long as Foot has could come up with a more convincing case for withdrawing British troops. Moreover the same rank and filers would talk about socialism as the only 'solution' to Ireland's problems, and would argue 'troops out' as an aid to this goal rather than to assist the Catholics to become Continued on inside back cover, column 3 Ireland

Scan page 66

the In most of the hard left today difficult to get a rational discussion about whenever we should be for or against the immediate and unconditional withdrawal of Socialist

----- pull-quotes -----

The Socialist

a reality, would the Protestants lose their religious and cultural freedoms in a

The Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →