Workers Fight Aldershot
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 61 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 61
reform was organised 'from above' by Britain in the late 19th/early 20th century, under pressure of a mass revolt. The national division was not pre-capitalist. The basic problem was the split bourgeoisie and the varying links of its different parts with the British ruling class; and the fact that the bourgeoisie, North and South of the Border, could command the allegiance of the working Ireland was a relatively advanced bourgeois country, integrated into European capitalism, albeit as a weaker capitalism. That the 26 Counties was really independent politically -independent to the degree possible under capitalist world market economic relations - was shown by its neutrality in World War II.
"The division [in the Irish bourgeoisie] prevented the accomplishment of one of the major tasks of the traditional bourgeois revolution — national unification. However, if history and the relationship to Britain make the two statelets peculiarly deformed, they are nonetheless undeniably bourgeois, as a glance at the social organisation and relations of production makes obvious... "We who fight for the workers' international Republic know that the present Irish capitalists are the only ones we will get. Calling them traitors is useless -they are not traitors to their class, the only sphere in which real loyalty, as opposed to,, demagogic talk of loyalty, counts...
[(Editorial, Irish Militant, February 1967) Irish Militant was not linked politically to the existing Militant group.] FORMERLY AN SOLAS LISHED BY THE IRISH WORKERS' GROUP rxist
Mumber 3
Saturdey 26th February 1972 nIs 2Il 1 INC. of 5 ortere of indiret ar hablash, thes portualte selle, "tranch tulichi Mund cons ou atars ol contre de teral. 1961 Texan freminuir minas carpeta tra than ed dir Batesh sindieg • Atllam srif ot, And Mons.
darut to wipe Hay Larik, homer life raus tor of Marzis res Isledr fart Proteca simbina elen del in. velaling hair al burber Presa tren deces on or anti-163 sate uraciner H42-5 fans ni seteta ases tesseters Ta a dichar str le tard, en lanoe dars.
Par ss burces ja-t etated. einer * in dr - Pour ner Irene cadie le peran indel inner ese aber ite, tras. some per Gravese idual erronse ser pose lern 335-20 •ste of a cáte. he 1917 an .- Prattie decil aum of the Sus ar prat, sens all, under ht restre Arisk worter Ther Ial in trab.e the efer airatele Our political forerunners refused to join tt outcry against 'terrorism' in the early '70s The massive revolt of the Catholics in 1969 and after, and then the rapid growth of a new IRA after 1970, torced us to reconsider ano modity these assessments, and to respond politically to new facts.
wẹ were the first on the left to point to tional question boldly.
But we did not forget what we had learned. We did not go in for romanticism and flights of fantasy, in the style of Socialist Action - then IMG - or Briefing, about the Catholic revolt being the socialist revolution. Even when the "The Northern Ireland Catholics fight in isolation, in the most unfavourable conditions imaginable. The rearguard of the Irish fight for national freedom, they are betrayed and abandoned by the 'leaders' of the Irish nation, and are simultaneously cut off from the allies who would make an advance on a socialist basis possible - the Orange majority of the Northern Ireland working class...
(Workers' Fight, July 23 1972)
We defined what was happening as primarily a Catholic revolt with a limited potential of solving the national question. It was the revolt of the Six County Catholics, not a rebirth of the 1918 all-Ireland nationalist upsurge. It was limited as an anti-imperialist movement because it was confined to the Six Counties, and because of the split working class there. Nevertheless, it had to be supported.
When the Catholic civil rights agitation got underway in 1968-9, we supported it, but criticised it on three counts.
(1) Logically the central issue was the national question, and events would inexorably force it to the fore. The basic underlying civil right the Catholics lacked was the right to national self-determination. We said in early 1969 and long before the Republican movement, some of whose members were leading he civil rights struggles, said it: the goal has to be to smash the Six County state.
(2) At the same time, because of its petty-bourgeois, Stalinist and populistRepublican leadership, the entire civil rights movement was needlessly divisive. The demands one man (sic) one house, one man one job, one man one vote, were inevitably seen by Protestants as a desire to re-divide and share what little there was. The issue could have been dynamically and progressively posed in these (transitional demand) terms: build more houses, thus creating more jobs, etc., etc.
(3) We criticised the civil rights movement (including such of its leaders as the then IS/SWP supporters in Northern Ireland, like Michael Farrell, who has since become a political satellite of the Provisionals) for political confusion on the national question and on the need to try to unite the working class around the Catholic movement (they wanted to play down the national question in the cause of uniting the working class in the Six Counties around civil rights and socialist propaganda). We also criticised them for organising provocative marches and demonstrations in Protestant areas which were helping stoke up a sectarian explosion.
When the Provisional IRA launched its military offensive in 1971, we critically supported their right to fight against the British government in that way. We defended it outspokenly in the British labour movement.
We did not use our previous assessment of the improbability of a revolutionary reunification of Ireland short of a socialist revolution to draw sectarian and abstentionist conclusions about the actual struggle that had erupted. But we did not forget that assessment. In fact the 20 years of war have in their own way established very clearly the truth of that assessment.
Me tantained critical police tance towards the IRA Workers' Ireland 59
Scan page 62
For the razard '70s, when such a thing existed, we reprinted Irish socialist criticisms of the IRA from People's Democracy and from the League for a Workers' Republic. We never had other than derision and scorn for the wild Third-Worldist fantasies and incredible 'permanent revolution' scenarios which the IMG - the closest group to us in its political responses in the early '70s -spun around the Catholic revolt.
At best we believed that the Catholic and IRA revolt would force Britain and the Irish bourgeoisie into a radical reorganisation of the Irish state system. Of course it did: Protestant Stormont was abolished in March 1972 and direct rule substituted. In November 1985 Dublin and London signed the Anglo-Irish Agreement, giving Dublin a share in the political decision-making in Northern Ireland.
Since 1972, despite many import(ant twists and turio, facts of the situation have remained unchanged, in stalemate. The British Army cannot defeat the IRA; the Catholics cannot defeat the combined forces of the British Army and the Protestants; the British government is not sufficiently energetic or sufficiently driven, to impose a rearrangement on the Protestants.
In the 26 Counties, there have been some impressive one-off waves of solidarity action - after Bloody Sunday in 1972, and during the hunger strikes.
But the basic facts of the political set-up have not changed. The two Green Tory parties, Fine Gael and Fianna Fail, remain dominant — as they were in the '60s. The Irish Labour Party remains a tail of Fine Gael — as it was in the '60s.
Thus the Irish national struggle remains essentially confined to 10% of the Irish nation - the Northern Catholics.
That does not detract from the justice of their fight. It does limit its prospects.
It is possible that the situation in the North may be transformed by something from outside it — for example, by a revolutionary upsurge of working class struggle in the South, creating a new basis for workers' unity in the North.
Socialists should do all we can to help such a possibility emerge. But we cannot guarantee it at will; and in the meantime we have to formulate ideas showing some way forward from the situation as 'orkong" day.
We advocated a federal arrangement within Ireland from as early as 1969, but the importance of this element in our politics has increased with the 20 year stalemate.
In this and other aspects of the IrishBritish question we differ from other Marxists. Militant has long refused to campaign in any way for British troops out of Ireland, instead they use general propaganda about the need for socialism to evade the issue. That is contemptible. Set who are dear that more and the But the attitude of those many on the defeat of British imperialism' are the crux of the Irish question, and al! else is pettifogging and probably 'capitulation mongering and in its own way just as to imperialism' is empty phraseshameful as Militant's evasions.
"Troops out' is a good slogan. But it is not sufficient. In most national liberation struggles we can say simply: the imperialist power should get out and hand over to the local nationalist movement. There is no all-Ireland nationalist movement. There is a nationalist movement of the Northern Catholics (10% of the population of the island) which is regarded with bitter hostility by the Northern Protestants (20%) and sporadic sympathy, but some alarm, by the Southern Catholics (70%). The situation is further complicated by the political split in the 10% of Ireland's people who are the half million Catholics in the Six Counties. According to election results, only about 1 in 3 of Northern Ireland's Catholics positively support the Provisional IRA or Sinn Fein.
Lenin argued:
"There is not, nor can there be, such a thing as a 'negative' Social-Democratic slogan that serves only to 'sharpen proletarian consciousness against imperialism' without at the same time offering a positive answer to the question of how Social Democracy will solve the problem when it assumes power. A "negative' slogan unconnected with a dearpen, out dull busio sess, for definite such a slogan is a hollow phrase, mere shouting, meaningless declamation."
Nowhere is this more true than on the slogan 'Troops out of Ireland'. In early 1969 some of us argued against IS/SWP's almost-exclusive concentration on "Troops out' (until the troops went on the streets, in August 1969, and IS dropped the call!). We criticised the implied illusion that the Catholic civil rights movement would organically 'grow over' into socialism; and argued for propaganda for the workers' In the mid-'70s we argued against the notion (put forward by the IMG - now divided into Socialist Action and Briefing - and others) that a mass movement could be built in Britain on the single slogan, "Troops out' We use "Troops out' as one means of focusing the issue in Britain. It is not a full programme, though some on the left sometimes talk and act as if it is. Even the Provisionals, more serious than their less thoughtful British admirers, put precise demands on the way Britain should get out.
If British troops quit Ireland tomorrow, it is quite likely that there would be a sectarian civil war, leading to repartition.
Self-determination? Unify Ireland? The Provisionals are not strong enough to do it. The Northern Protestants are actively hostile to it. The 26 County ruling class has no real wish for it.
The scene would be set for a section of the Protestants to make a drive for the current UDA policy of an 'independent Ulster'. This drive would involve at least a massive crackdown on the Republicans, and, probably, the mass slaughter, rounding-up and driving-out the Catholics. The Northern Catholics would, naturally, resist violently. Dublin would give some token assistance to the Catholics but do nothing decisive. There would be mass population movements, a repartition: İreland would be irrevocably and bitterly split into Orange and Green states. There would be a bloodbath.
The conventional left answer to this, that 'there's already a bloodbath', is no answer. Simmering war with hundreds of casualties is different from all-out war with thousands. Different not only in immediate human terms, but also in terms of the implications for the future possibilities of socialism — ie. of the Catholic and Protestant workers.
The other answer, 'revolutions always involve bloodshed' , Is no better. There is no comparison between the revolutionary violence of the working class against its exploiters, or of a subject nation against a conquering army, and the violence of two working-classcommunities slaughtering each other.
All this does not mean that we should fail to support troops out. That the situation and the prospects now are so bleak is in large part Britain's work.
But it does mean that we should couple the call for troops out with politically adequate proposals for a solution within Ireland - and condemn those who call for troops out without such a proposal as mindless phrasemongers.
The only conceivable solution given the present facts of the situation or anything resembling them is a united Ireland with federalism: ie. an attempt to negotiate between the sections of the Irish people and to conciliate the Protestants. This would probably involve the recreation of closer British-Irish ties so that the two islands would provide the broader framework within which the intra-Irish conflicts can be resolved.
The conciliation, realistically, would be backed up with a certain element of coercion — ie. strong indications to the Protestants that prospects for an alternative to a united Ireland were pretty bleak — and would involve some repression against die-hard Protestant groups. But that is different from straight conquest of the Protestants. Logically, conquest is the only alternative to such conciliation, given the Protestants' titudes. But it not possible - who
Scan page 63
would conquer them? desirable either, from any point of view.
It is possible to evade these issues by wishful thinking. It is possible to fantasise that at the crucial point, the national struggle would magically 'grow over' into socialism, and in some 'dialectical' leap the Protestants would be converted to Republicanism. It is possible to remain blinkered in a sort of inverted British nationalism, saying that 'the defeat of British imperialism' and its effect on the "balance of world forces' are had since well before the beginnin g of the Catholic revolt. Whatever in consistencies may be found in this or that detail, the fundamental approach is cOrrect.
That does not mean, however, that our politics have been completely adequate. Even in the early '70s, when we put most stress on solidarity with the Catholic revolt, we were critical of the IRA: on the whole, however, we tended to suppress criticism as much as we decently could - and that was too much. The basic principles, views and the The Socialist
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKER REPUBLI
Many Irish socialists responded in- itially with a "socialism-is-the-only- answer' message, neglecting the national question. We did not. On the contrary,
the nationalist logic of the civil rights struggle, and to argue for raising the na-
Catholic revolt was apparently most suc- cessful, we pointed to its limitations.
The Socialist
it is now, not as we hope it will be some- The Socialist