Our record on Ireland
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 60 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 60
Socialist Organiser traces its attitude on Ireland back to the small group of socialists who produced the journal An Solas/ Workers Republic in 1966-7, under the umbrella of the Irish Workers Group.
We believed that traditional Republicanism was not and could not be a consistently anti-imperialist force; that it was, by its ideas, goals and methods a petty-bourgeois movement; that its petty-bourgeois nationalism was a barrier to working-class unity; that its little Irelandism' cut in the opposite direction to the interests of the Irish working We believed - in the mid-'60s - that the adoption of a socialist coloration and the brand name 'Connolly socialism' by that movement was not progressive but confusing, and coula only produce a populist mish-mash like the Russian Socialist Revolutionary Party.
...the IRA is just not revolutionary in relation to the objective needs of the only possible Irish Revolution.
"The same is no less true if 'left' slogans are grafted onto the old base, and a Workerg, Mominal For Connolly's Republic' pinned to the masthead. Such talk of a socialist programme, a Bolshevik party, a workers' republic, demands a proper appreciation of the relationship between the party and the working class...It demands a sharply critical approach to the traditional republican conceptions of revolutionary activity. Otherwise these slogans combined with a largely military idea of the struggle against imperialism and the Irish bourgeoisie, will not produce a revolutionary Marxist party, but an abortion similar to the Socialist Revolutionary Party in Russia, against which the Bolsheviks fought bitterly."
We believed that though there was national oppression — especially and directly against the Northern Ireland Catholics — this was in part the product of a split in the Irish bourgeoisie, and not simply a matter of 'British-occupied Ireland' "A division of the Irish bourgeoisie, originating in economic differences, led to a split which was then manipulated by British imperialism, according to its practice of divide and rule. The Norirkers' political autonomy, kept close links with this imperialism; the Southern section being dominated according to the logic of modern imperialism [ie. economic weight within more or less free market relations.
"In maintaining their closer links with Britain, the Northern capitalists were aided by British troops, who also assist in holding sufficient people to make the state viabie. Despite this, talk of 'British-occupied Ireland' obscures the real identity of the garrison in Ireland -the Northern Ireland bourgeoisie."
(Editorial of Irish Militant, paper of the IWG, Febrary 1967. Irish Militant was loosely associated with the British Militant until about 1966 and thereafter had no connection with it.)
Basing ourselves on Lenin's 'Imperialism' and such documents of the Communist International as the "Theses on the National and Colonial Question' (1920) we believed that the economic domination over Ireland by Britain and other great powers could not be eliminated except by the reorganisation of the world economy through the international socialist revolution.
•The IWG stands against the divided Irish bourgeoisie, Green, Orange and Green-White-and-Orange, and for the revolutionary unity of the workers of all Ireland in a struggle for state power.
"We stand for the revolutionary combat against imperialism and national oppression in every form, whether that of garrison-imperialism, neo-colonialism, or the glaring economic domination of the small nations by the super-powers which is inevitable where the capitalist world market remains as the sole regulator of relationships. But we denounce those who, in the name of 'Republicanism' and 'anti-imperialism' attempt to subordinate the working class to any section of the bourgeoisie, and who counterpose a defunct petty-bourgeois nationalist narrow-mindedness to the socialist struggle of the workers for power. National unity will be achieved, if not by the coming together of the Irish capitalist class under the auspices of the British imperialist state and the capitalist drive towards West European federation, then as an incidental in the proletarian revolution.
«The possibility of any other revolutionary reunification is long since past. The only revolutionary Republicanism is the international socialist Republicanism of the proletariat."
('Towards an Irish October', preamble to the constitution of the IWG.) and right. focus on ganang reat int We thought that the nationalist dependence was both meaningless for the 26 Counties and confusing from the point of view of the Irish working class. We rejected economic nationalism as being no more than the discarded and discredited former economic policy of the 26 County bourgeoisie (1932-58). It was a reactionary petty-bourgeois programme counterposed to the necessary — and, in so far as it was developing and augmenting the frish working class, progressive - integration of Ireland into the existing world economic system. It was a backward-looking utopia, counterposed to the economic programme of the Irish working class, for whom there could be no purely Irish solution.
"The one serious progressive act of imperialism and Irish capitalism has been the creation of an Irish proletariat capable of putting an end to capitalism's futile existence, and capable, as part of a world revolutionary class, of realising the age-old dream of the people of Ireland for freedom. The best traditions of the old, bourgeois, Republicanism have passed to the socialist working class, the only class in Ireland today capable of transforming society and the subordinate relation with Great Britain - the only unconditionally revolutionary class. The only genuine liberation of Ireland will be from the inexorable - uncontrolled — pressures of international capitalism. All the essential goals of all the past defeated and deflated struggles of the Irish people over the centuries against oppression and for freedom of development and freedom from exploitation, can now only be realised in a Republic of the working people, as part of the Socialist United States of Europe and the world."
("Towards an Irish October'.)
We naturally rejected the MenshevikStalinist notion that there had to be a two-stage revolution in Ireland - first 'the Republic' (independence) and then 'the workers' Republic' • We rejected the hybrid 'populist Republicanism' — a fusion of the Stalinist two-stage theory with 'native' Republicans who were leftwing but put 'the national queston' first - represented historically by Paedar O'Donnell, George Gilmore and the Republican Congress of the 1930s, and in the mid-'60s by the 'left' of the Republican movement, the future Official IRA and Workers' Party.
We rejected the kitsch "Trotskyist' response to the stages theories and the populists - the reflex invocation of ¡Permanent Revolution' . The job was not to match texts with texts, ours against theirs, permanent revolution against stages theories, as in a card game. Instead we had to analyse reality concretely. On this approach, the conclusion was inescapable.
Ireland had had its "bourgeois revolution'. In the North, bourgeois relations had been established by extension from
Scan page 61
Britain after its bourgeois revolution in the 17th century. In the South, land For the
----- pull-quotes -----
thern section, having a measure of The Socialist