Why bread- and-butter and-butter workers' unity is nor the answer
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 56 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 56
Catholics but alienated the Protestants. After leading Catholics to take a first step of calling for civil rights, the second step had to be to tackle the root reason why they had been deprived of civil rights — partition.
The Workers' Party's solution to the communal divisions in the North is essentially to bury its head in the sand and pretend that this time, despite all previous experience, working class unity can be built on a basis of economic issues neanime is approada is to be a responsible and 'constructive' force in Socialist Workers' The Militant tendency argues that bread-and-butter trade union unity and a drive to form a Labour Party in Northern Ireland show the way to a socialist united Ireland. Why are they wrong?
From a working class point of view, the basic problem about the Six County state is that in that state framework, working class unity, developed on a trade union level, has always shattered at any political test. So long as the 'constitutional question' remains at the heart of political life there, it always will shatter on the rooted communal antagonism between Catholics and Protestants, Nationalists and Unionists.
Trade union unity is possible in struggles like the NHS dispute of 1982. But
Scan page 57
The sectarian divide there is no way that such unity can open the way to solid political working class unity in the sectarian Six County entity. Even spectacular examples of Protestant/Catholic working class unity have proved to be mere episodes.
For example, the well known 'outdoor relief fight in 1932, unity in working class resistance to cuts in social security payments was possible because both Catholics and Protestants were hit impartially. Barricades went up in the Protestant Shankhill Road and in the Catholic Falls Road. Activists went from the Falls to man Shankhill barricades, and from the Shankhill to defend the Falls against the police. (Some on both sides were influenced by the Irish Stalinists.)
Within weeks of this spectacular unity, no less spectacular sectarian rioting had been fomented. There are other examples, both before and after Partition.
The experience of the various incarnations of the Northern Ireland Labour Party runs in parallel to this. Today a very tiny Unionist rump, the NILP has at various times grown to a significant size.
It attempted to confine itself to breadand-butter working class issues, that is, to generalised trade unionism, bargaining in the working class interest on the level of provincial and 'United Kingdom' society. It evaded, hedged and compromised on the issues that divide Northern Ireland's workers.
In the 1940s, for example, NILP speakers on the Falls Road campaigned under the nationalist tricolour. In the "mixed' centre of Belfast they campaigned under the Red Flag; and party leader Harry Midgley campaigned on the Shankhill under the Union Jack (he ended up a Unionist).
Such a balancing act could not get far. Sectarian suspicions soon disrupted the party and scattered its forces.
To reject Militant's view of a Labour Party as the cure-all is not to say that socialists should not work in a Labour Party if it existed. Serious work was done, for example, in the late "60s in the Derry Labour Party, which became cenThaT tral to the civil rights struggie.
Even after it split, Eamonn McCann could get 8,000 votes on a revolutionary socialist platform in the mid-1970 election.
Yet McCann's experience, too, underlines the basic point that simply trying to generalise from trade unionism within the Six County framework is no solution. The Derry Labour Party left wing tended to ignore the national question, and was bypassed by the eruption of the Republican movement. Their forces scattered, too: some went to the Officials and then to the IRSP, one or two to Militant.
Many well-intentioned tricks have been tried to unite Northern Ireland workers. In 1907 Jim Larkin had united Protestant and Catholic workers on a trade union level. When it came to the marching and rioting season, on July 12, he tried to preserve the unity by organising his own united Orange/Catholic working class parade around the walls of Derry.
The Protestant workers, said Larkin, would march in honour of King William who secured their liberty in the 'Glorious Revolution' .. The Catholics would march to honour the Pope, who at that time had taken the Papal States into the international alliance against France of which William was part!
tarian rioting had shattered working class unity.
The inescapable conclusion from history is that general political unity cannot be created on the basis of the trade union ('economic) unity; and that unity in trade union action is not the harbinger of a stable class unity.
Many on the left go on from this basic fact to a general dismissal of any concern for working class unity. The national question, they seem to say, supersedes everything else in Northern Ireland.
The trade union struggle is o f little importance. The Protestant wor' king class - that is, the big majority of the workthe ing class — is of no concern of ours. The struggle for socialism will develop out of the revolt of the oppressed Catholics; even though that revolt fails to mobilise, and indeed antagonises, the Protestant workers.
We concern ourselves only with the 'anti-imperialist' military campaign of organisations representing perhaps half the Catholic third of the Six County population. Only when that campaign is victorious will questions like working class unity be important.
That is the mirror-image of the Militant caricature of socialist and Marxist Militant's approach to Irelana relate nly selectively and arbitrarily to th issues, processes and struggles in Ireland. It pretends that trade union battles involving workers from both commu nities already amount to, or by way of being generalised into a new Northern Ireland Labour Party can be made into, working class political unity.
It goes from this to general socialist propaganda about nationalising the entire economy. Its version of 'socialism' is bureaucratic, statist, and somewhat 1890s-Fabian. As James Connolly put it, "State ownership and control is not necessarily socialist — if it were, then the army and the navy, the police, the judges, the gaolers, the informers and the hangmen would all be socialist functionaries as they are all state officials... To the cry of the middle class reformers, 'Make this or that the property of the government', we reply -"yes, in proportion as the workers are ready to make the government their property'."
But even if Militant's conception of socialism were more revolutionary, there would still be a problem. In between sub-political industrial issues, and the political maximum, the socialist revolution, they leave a great void. The void is what's wrong with their politics, not that they advocate and want to build working class inter-communal unity at any level possible, and not that they make propaganda for socialism.
A working class political party that can really unite the working class in Ireland, specifically in Northern Ireland, will have to be one that can honestly answer all the problems the key sections of the working class face - and in the first place the 'constitutional question' Militant's answer is the same as its answer to every living struggle in Britain or anywhere else — propaganda , for 'socialism, the only road' , combined Workers' Ireland 55
Scan page 58
ilitant's record on For the razard with a routinist and politically accommodationist approach to the basic struggles of the working class and the labour movement. It is a vicious circle: there can be no socialism without the working class, but the working class is deeply divided. To offer 'socialism' as the solution to this division is simply to restate the problem, not to give an answer.
From this general approach has flowed Militant's record over the last 20 years. Initially it opposed the deployment of British troops on the streets after August 1969, and sympathised with the Catholics. It quickly veered (by 1970 or 1971) to an attitude of condemning the "sectionalism' and then the terrorism' of the Catholics. It was like its attitude to the struggles of blacks, women, gays and others in Britain itself: the Catholic revolt in Northern Ireland was a complication which it wished would go away.
Ever since they have not supported the just revolt of the Catholics. Within the labour movement they are among the most vicious opponents of any attempt to get a calm discussion of the rel Militant has a record on Ireland unique on the British left. Since 1968 it has argued for working-class unity and immediate socialism as the answer to the conflicts in Northern Ireland. Support for working class unity is not unique to Militant, nor is the idea that socialism is desirable in Ireland, as everywhere else. What is unique is that Militant says: "unity now and socialism now' • and counterposes more or less general and timeless propaganda for workers' unity and socialism to all partial struggles and particularly to the struggles of the oppressed Catholic minority.
To the problem of communal divisions in the working class, its answer is that the workers should be united. To the problem that the different working-class communities are mobilised around national and communal issues, its answer is that they should be mobilised for socialism. Militant steadfastly refuses to address the situation more concretely or seriously.
For 20 years Militant has stubbornly refused to acknowledge the bitter facts about Northern Ireland.
The unions in Northern Ireland organise a workforce much of which has long been selected on a basis of sectarian job preference for Protestants, and therefore the sectarian Workers' Republicans, their struggle and their objectives. Militant peddles its own curealls and nostrums, the famous trade union defence force' , for example.
A good idea — for a different society. The workforce is heavily stratified as a result of sectarian job preference. This affects the unions, where unity has been possible only on minimal trade union questions and by avoiding politics. The unions reflect the society they exist in. The Protestant UDA is (or at least the mass, 50,000 strong, UDA of 1972 was) the nearest thing to a trade union militia that Northern Ireland will see this side of a revolutionary change of working class consciousness.
Essentially Militant lacks the democratic programme which has to be part of filling the void between trade union minimalism and the socialist revolution. It relates to the political world around it by pretending that the communal divide can be ignored, and that the national question can be pushed aside. It pretends that socialism can be the cure for divisions whose healing is divisions are internalised in the unions. Irrelevant, says Militant. Chronic working class division inevitably paralyses the trade unions, and they would split wide open if they tried to engage in politics in conditions where different sections of their members give radically different answers to the question of Northern Ireland's relationship to Britain and the South of Ireland. Not so, says Militant: the trade unions have Catholic and Protestant members, and therefore they are non-sectarian. They can rise above the little political questions that convulse the Six Counties and lead a united Protestant/Catholic working class to socialism.
The workers of the two communities actively or passively support "their own' paramilitary organisations. No, says Militant. The paramilitaries are tiny grouplets suspended in mid-air. Anyway, if the labour movement were to create a workers' defence force, the workers would support that.
For 15 years Northern Ireland has been torn apart by what the Catholics see as 'the national question'. What answer do Marxists offer to this problem in its peculiar Irish complexities? Socialism is the only answer, says An internationalist would say that the problem in Ireland is a problem of how the Irish minority - the Protestants — can relate to the majority without becoming an oppressed group; and that this basic problem has been snarled up and made septic by the interactioni of the Protestant minority with Britain, because they have "solved' the Irish minority problem by imprisoning within the murderously narrow and artificial Six County state a Catholic minority proportionately bigger than the Protestants would be in a united Ireland. A Marxist internationalist would at least ask the question: does not the Bolshevik teaching that wherever such problems exist we advocate a radical democratic solution, involving maximum autonomy for oppressed or potentially oppressed communities, nathe precondition Ireland.
Militant's policy is a recipe for building a sect in Northern Ireland. It has as little chance of uniting the Six County working class as the previous Labour Party minimalists had. No the Irish national question and to the communal antagonisms in Northern Ireland will even begin to play a positive role in Irish politics.
The best democratic programme is that of a federal united Ireland with as much autonomy for the Protestant community as is compatible with the democratic rights of the majority of the Irish people. An all-Ireland revolutionary movement must be built which integrates this with the direct work of educating and organising the labour movement to fight for workers' power, and which links up with the workers' movement internationally, especially in Britain and in Europe, on the programme of the United States of Europe. tions, fragments of nations, or national minorities, apply? What does Militant say to that! Socialism is the only answer - and anything less is treason to socialism.
Now the elitist armed groups like the Provisional IRA and INLA, much denounced by Militant, can talk about socialism irrespective of the state of the working class, and even against the majority of the working class, without being untrue to themselves. But for Marxists to talk about a socialist solution as the immediate answer to chronic and acute communal division within the working class, whose unity is an irreplaceable precondition for socialism, is nonsense.
For 16 years Militant has advocated 'solutions' for Northern Ireland that just could not happen in the circumstances. It has proposed ideas that are not a guide to any meaningful action, but only consoling phrases, ideological booze. The answer, it says, to the paralysis of the trade unions, is for them immediately to act for socialism and to create a workers' defence force. Until 1974 it advocated the same 'solution' through the agency of the Unionist Northern Ireland Labour Party. Such proposals cannot conceivably bring the 'socialism now' which is supposed to be the 'only solution'; nor can they conceivably assist in doing what can possibly be done in a positive way towards workers' unity and socialism.
Militant's key ideas, summarised above, have been a broad fixed framework within which, over 16 years, it has had a rich and varied series of notions and speculations. In 1969, it speculated, fantastically, about the prospects for a pioneering socialist society in...the Six Counties unit! "If the demands [minimum wage; equal pay, crash building programme; take over big building companies; improved social services] are pressed moone in action, can be lined up one de monopolies and the establishment of a democratic socialist society - which would
Scan page 59
have immediate repercussions in the South, in Britain, and internationally...
May 1969)
Then, responding to the slaughter of 14 Catholics by the British Army in January 1972, Militant waxed eloquent about...organising the British Army for socialism. "A campaign of individual assassinations... of the British soldiers can only provide excuse for further repression...Also it can only reinforce the hostility of the ordinary soldier to the Catholic population...[Rank and file] soldiers could be appealed to on a class basis and won away from the army brass, if a clear socialist alter. native was given to them..." (Militant, 4 Faced with what looked like civil war in mid-'72, Peter Taaffe wrote this: "But, given the failure of the trade union leadership to initiate a trade union defence force, every working class area must have the right to de. fend itself." (Militant no.113, July 1972)
You're on your own boys! In fact, this was to give the seal of Militant's approval to the UDA. It should be remembered that it was the Catholics who were likely to need defending if it came to all out war.
This July 1972 article was unique in Militant, in that it recognised that there might be some problems in the trade unions: "We still believe that this [workers' defence force] could be realised, even at this eleventh hour, despite the relative animosity which has also now !!] affected the trade unions...
Mostly Militant has stuck stubbornly to the trade union defence force demand, as though the communal clashes against which defence must be organised were in a different world from thé trade unions. But occasionally it makes strange sallies. Though venting its implacable hostility to the Provisional IRA, Militant could nevertheless in 1972 make a strange 'call' on the Catholic leaders — including the Provisonals - to create a party of labour!
"Much of the onus for [building the party of Labour] is today on those in the vanguard of the struggle, the leaders of the Catholic workers. Were these people to direct their energies towards the organised labour movement they could pave the way for united action with their Protestant fellow workers." (Militant no. 118; August 1972).
It should be added that the leader of the Northern Ireland Labour Party component in the this ecumenical front, David Bleakley, had been in the government that brought in internment against Catholics - and only against Catholics — in August 1971!
At the same time Militant speculated about the processes going on in the UDA that would produce class consciousness. "The development of the UDA with its veneer of class consciousness shows that Protestants are well aware of their class position..." (ibid)
And during the Orange general strike of 1974 Militant opposed any action by the Labour government to break the reactionary - and even racist — strike, thus telling British workers that the strike was entitled to be treated as a working class action, if not quite a proper or normal one.
In 1980-81 Militant opposed the granting of political status to the Republican hunger strikers.
These are just a few examples of the nonsense that has grown up, at various turning points, under the umbrella of Militant's general ideas. There are many others that could be cited.
This is the record of a tendency that, on Northern Ireland, has not dealt in real politics. It has made socialist propaganda, either very abstract propaganda (but presented as if it is an immediate answer to specific issues) or propaganda in which the socialist message is tied tightly to absurd but supposedly practical proposals.
An example of the latter is its oftenrepeated proposal for a conference of Northern Ireland trade unions and others to launch a Party of Labour which could nationalise the commanding heights of the economy, etc., and thereby solve every problem, including sectarian. divisions in the working class. Think about it. Trade unionists in Northern Ireland vote ToryUnionist or Catholic-Nationalist. A truly representative conference of the trade unions would be at a more backward stage than were the trade unions which founded the British Labour Party in 1900 — and they were at best Liberal. Such a party in Northern Ireland would need time to evolve and develop. But what would Militant do at such a conterence, faced with the trade unions as they are, far from socialism?
Would it do what the sectarian British Marxists, the SDF, did in 1901, that is, move a resolution with a full socialist programme and walk out when it was rejected (as it inevitably would be)? Perhaps not. But then it would accept that the conference could not produce the miracle results claimed for it. In fact it is a certainty that such a conference could not lead to anything like Militant's 'socialist solution' in the short or medium term.
Militant, in essence, has had no policy for Ireland — only timeless propaganda, linked to more or less bizarre and, in the circumstances, impossible 'practical' proposals. What distinguishes Militant on Ireland is not the desire for workers' unity and socialism, which it shares with all socialists, but its stubborn refusal to face the facts about Northern Ireland. For working class Marxists, the facts, not fantasies and wishes, are the necessary starting point.
Workers' Ireland
Scan page 60
ihe
----- pull-quotes -----
They had a successful, and unique, parade around Derry. Within weeks sec-
The Socialist
The Socialist
political formation that does not have in its programme a democratic solution to
ZNCY TARES Tvonw d
The Socialist