The Workers' Party
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 56 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 56
It the conference (Ard Fheis) where the former Official Republican movement changed its name to The Workers' Party, a Dublin solicitor, Pat McCartan, argued in favour of the name change that it would allow "professional people and tradesmen" to feel at home with the party.
He wasn't making a music hall joke. He knew what he was talking about.
The dropping of the Republican name followed a sweeping repudiation of traditional revolutionary republican attitudes, and the Workers' Party name has not stopped the party voting for Haughey as prime minister and guardedly supporting both the Anglo-Irish Agreement and the Tories' previous 'Prior initiative' for 'do-it-yourself' devolution in Northern Ireland.
The WP calls for the building of a workers' party on an all-Ireland basis. It claims to be recruiting Protestant workers in the North. It bitterly denounces the contention of 'the Fianna Fail/SDLP/Provo axis" that Northern Ireland has failed as a political entity. Its solution to the Northern conflict is "peace, work, democracy and class Now influence has frequently been gained by Labour and socialist parties in Northern Ireland on the shallow ground of trade-union and economic issues, but it has never withstood the disruptive power of communal and sectarian, not to speak of republican, politics.
The leaders of the Workers' Party should have learned this the hard way in the late '60s, when their supposedly untfying civil rights campaign aroused the mainstream politics, putting forward reasonable and balanced proposals on all the issues of the day — within the parameters of the existing system.
Involvement in the Southern political establishment on this basis is already ravaging the Workers' Party's socialist credentials. Its commitment to the existing structures will inevitably mire it completely in the bog of bourgeois, anti-working-class politics.
When they called themselves Republicans, they, used to talk about completing the Irish bourgeois revolution (national independence) as the necessary first stage, before starting on the second stage — the struggle for socialism. They are still trapped in that Stalinist stages theory of revolution.
Now they denounce the Irish bourgeoisie for not having industrialised the country. They say that the immediate task, the task that has to be accomplished before starting a direct struggle for socialism, is the 'Irish industrial revolution' '. And their role in that task is reformist pressure and Parliamentary deals.
There is a precedent. In the 1940s, a regroupment of Republicans, seeking a way out of the blind alley politics of physical force on principle and abstention from the existing political structures, formed a party called Clann Na Poblachta, led by Sean MacBride, a Chief of Staff of the IRA in the 1930s.
It was a mildly reformist organisation. It played a big role in bourgeois politics for a while, holding the balance in the Dail. In 1948 it joined a Fine Gael/Labour coalition government.
When the Catholic Bishops vetoed the establishment of free medical care for pregnant women, mothers and infants, the party repudiated its own Minister of Health, Dr Noel Browne. The coalition collapsed and Clann na Poblachta rapidly fell apart.
History never repeats itself exactly, but the Workers' Party has all the ingredients of a slightly more radical version of Clann na Poblachta.
The additional feature of the Workers' Party is the Stalinist influence. The Workers' Party supported, for example, General Jaruzelski's military coup and the suppression of the workers' movement in Poland.
Workers' Party leader Sean Garland declared: "It was clear that the Polish armed forces had to take action to stop it sliding into anarchy and total chaos and ultimately ending in the hands of imperialism". No-one should accuse these defenders of the Anglo-irish Agreement of forgetting about imperialism!
But quite a few of the Workers' Party's rank and file activists probably think that it is a real working class alternative to traditional Irish nationalist politics. Whether some of them can go on to break with it and help build a real revolutionary socialist working class party must still be an open question.