A Catholic sta for a Catholic people?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 55 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 55
What do the Irish people want? "If the old Protestant Stormont Parliament, with the full backing of the Protestant Church, but against the united will of the Roman Catholic Church and people, had forced through Parliament a law dealing with some complex moral issue, do you not think that Stormont would have been accused of the vilest form of sectarianism by acting against the united wishes of the Roman Catholic community and by insensitivity to Roman Catholic opinion".
Victor Griffin, dean of St Patrick's, Dublin.
The abortion referendum in the 26 Counties in 1983 led some before the poll to talk of a 'new partition of Ireland'. The result showed they were right.
In a very low turn-out (54%) there was a two-to-one majority to insert into the constitution a ban on abortion (which is already illegal).
For the sponsors of the referendum it wasy one third of the electorate vor yes.
There was a sharp division between Dublin — where half voted no - and the rest of the country. And the senior partner in the coalition government, Fine Gael, was heavily divided.
The youth of Fine Gael campaigned openly for a no vote. At the end prime minister Garret Fitzgerald came out, timidly, for 'no' The Labour Party, junior partner in the coalition, was divided too: half the deputies for yes, half for no.
The supporters of the amendment pulled out all the stops in their campaign, and they had a lot in their favour. The South of Ireland has long been a Catholic, conservative society, where the priests are a tremendous social power. It has been in the grip of a savagely repressive sexual puritanism since the mid-19th century Famine.
Though the society has changed massively in the last 25 years, with industrialisation and urbanisation, the forces of Catholicism and conservatism are still strong. Over 80% of the people still go to Mass regularly.
Those at the top of the Catholic hierarchy made pseudo-liberal statements that people should vote according to their consciences. The lower clergy made every pulpit a political platform for the 'Pro-Life' campaign.
The mass circulation press and the provincial press said vote yes. Behind them they had the Catholic teaching that an embryo has a soul from the beginning, and abortion is therefore infanticide.
Most of the opponents of the amendment are against abortion. Some - like Fitzgerald — argued against the amendment on the grounds that, because of ambiguous wording, it could lead to legalised abortion.
Behind the argument about wording, there was also a more important argument about the role of the Catholic Church in Irish society.
The amendment was tailored to fit Catholic social teaching: The Protestant churches in the South opposed the amendment. They are against abortion, but not as unconditionally or obsessively as the Catholics. Victor Griffin, Dean of St Patrick's, Dublin, put it like this:
«There can be no true Republicanism without equality of recognition, and this implies the toleration of different views and practices in relation to certain moral issues within the framework of an agreed public morality. Such moral issues should be the affair, not of a Republican state, but of the particular Churches, each having the right to exercise its own particular moral discipline and none having the right to enforce theirs on others.
"At present we must admit, however reluctantly, there is no strong commitment in this state to any kind of united Ireland which would involve accommodating the Protestant minority point of view"
A massive blow has been dealt to the pretence that the Southern political parties really want a united Ireland.
The Irish people is divided. Whatever the historical and economic roots, and political/economic underpinnings, this expresses itself in the consciousness of the Catholic and Protestant people as a matter of religion — to which are attachIn opinion poll in February 1988 asked people in Northern Ireland what political solution they wanted.
Among Catholics 31 per cent wanted a home-rule government for Northern Ireland with power-sharing, 25 per cent wanted a united Ireland.
47 per cent of Protestants wanted integra. tion of Northern Ireland with Britain; 17 per cent power-sharing, and 14% Protestant majority rule.
No solution commanded a majority in either community. The only one that had sizeable support in both communities was ed ideas about liberty of conscience, of the relationship of the individual his or her conscience to Church On every count the referendum has been an attempt at a Catholic triumphalist assertion of the dominance of one side over the other. On 7 September 1983 the Irish constitution was explicitly identified with the Catholic church. The nationalist cause was identified with the Catholic cause.
Fianna Fail identified completely with the amendment campaign. After a 20-minute (!) meeting of its parliamentary deputies, Fianna Fail decided to vote yes, and the party's discipline did the rest. Yet Fianna Fail is The Republican Party — and the party which the 'left Republican' IRSP, for example, has supported in elections.
In the North, the SDLP majority was for a yes vote.
Symbolically, even Sean MacBride, founder of Amnesty, son of the 1916 martyr, and Chief of Staff of the IRA in the late '30s, voted yes. It was a repeat of his stance in 1951, when the Fine Gael/Labour Party/Clann na Poblachta government buckled under the pressure of the Catholic hierarchy's opposition to a health scheme for 'Mother and Child". MacBride was then the leader of Clann na Poblachta, and forced the Clann na Poblachta Minister of Health, Noel Browne, to resign.
All this is very relevant to the dispute about 'federalism' in a united Ireland. The fact is that the forces that dominate Southern Irish politics ignored the protests of the Protestants (and Jews). The two-thirds who voted no or refused to rally to the priests are a basis of hope for the future, but the yes vote won.
A fight to ensure the rights of the Protestant minority must be part of the fight for a united Ireland.
power-sharing — a formula that evidently sounds attractive, but which has proved impossible to establish despite repeated efforts by British governments over 16 years. 56% of Protestants and 84% of Catholics said they agreed with the 'principle' of powersharing.
These figures register a political impasse. Bland talk about 'supporting the struggle of the Irish people for a united Ireland' looks very simplistic indeed when you consider that only 10% of the population of Northern Ireland and only 25% of Catholics (fewer than vote Sinn Fein) give 'united Ireland' as their favoured solution.
(Fortnight, April 1988)
Workers' Ireland
Scan page 56
the
----- pull-quotes -----
The Socialist