Some economic facts
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 54 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 54
NORTH AND SOUTH TODAY The South is now slightly more industrialised than the North. This is a big change from the previous pattern.
South North Value added: % industrial 37% 35% Industrial (excluding utilities) % of civilian employment 29% 27% (EEC statistics, 1984).
GDP per head is on average almost exactly the same in the South as in the North. Social benefits are also on similar levels — 1982 figures (from EEC) for social benefits per head of total population were UK £1110, 26 Counties £1040.
Major differences: • Southern industry is much more modern. Electronics accounts for over a third of manufacturing exports. Metals and engineering account for 38% of value added, office and data processing equipment for 19% (Financial Times 8.7.86). Chemicals are now the next major sector.
In the North, 40% of jobs in manufacturing disappeared between 1979 and the mid-'80s. The remaining industry is generally old-fashioned and declining. • The South is still more rural and agricultural. In the North a huge role is played by public service employment — 36% of total employment (Irish Times 26.8.85). With even higher unemployment that the South (arouna 2u per cent), over half the North's population is directly dependent on the British state for income (wage or benefit) (Irish Times 26.8.85). Net subsidy from Britain to Northern Ireland is £1.S billion a year, about 30% of Northern Ireland's total income.
So: economically the North is a drain on British capitalism, which has however been able to establish profitable relations with the independent South.
The condition of the working class is worse in the North than in the South - Northern Ireland is the worse-off region in the EEC after Calabria in Southern Italy.
Protestant workers in the North are slightly better off than Catholic workers — Catholic unemployment is two and a half times Protestant unemployment. The Protestant workers may, therefore, possibly have arkers' al slightly higher average living standard than Southern workers; but to see the Protestant workers as the pampered pets of imperialism and the Southern workers as "Third World' people makes no sense.
THE TRANSFORMATION OF COUNTIES SINCE 1958 Mid-80s % of working in agriculture 35% 17% Urbanisation 46% 56% Manufacturing % of exports 12% 68% % of exports to 72% 35% % of exports to EEC countries 11% 34% (Figures from World Bank and Oxford Economic Atlas of the World. Earlier figure for manufacturing exports is 1955.)
Ireland is now an advanced capitalist country. It is on roughly the same level, as measured by National Income per head, as Southern Europe. In terms of the introduction of modern capitalist relations in the countryside, it has long been in advance of Southern Europe, since the landlords were bought out after 1903. IRELAND AND FOREIGN CAPITAL 80% of the 26 Counties' manufacturing exports are produced by foreign-owned companies, which also employ almost half the country's manufacturing workers — and repatriate 60% of their profits. The 26 Counties also has a huge foreign debt.
But two other facts should be born in mind before this feature is cited as proof that the 26 Counties are still a 'semicolony'.
Most of the foreign-owned companies are not from the country which the 26 Counties would presumably be a semicolony of — Britain. Of about 900 foreign-owned companies, over 300 are US-owned, 130 West German, and only 200 or so UK-owned.
And Ireland has been exporting capital since the 1870s. By 1914 Ireland was a creditor country and Irish capitalists had total investments abroad of £150 million (- M Cullen, An economic history of Ireland since 1000). A survey in 1964 found that Ireland had the fourth highest level of investment income from abroad, per head of population, in the world! Its inflow of investment income was $104 million, its outflow $67 million (Britain's Invisible Earnings, 1967, chapter on World Comparison of Invisibles). Only in more recent years has the inflow of capital to Ireland made it a clear debtor country.
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND At the time of Partition there was a stark contrast between the North and the South. In 1911 Ulster had 48% of all Ireland's industrial workers, and Belfast Ireland: the Orange State). The North exported manufactured goods internationally (a large proportion to the US); the South, agricultural produce, mainly to Britain.
I7th century: The bulk of Ireland's land seized and given to English or Anglo-Irish landlords or farmers. Plans to clear the native Irish from large areas and replace them by settlers generally fail; the only large area when English and Scots settlers become the majority is in the north-east, and that is as much due to free migration as government Semi-feudal land relations, but under the 'Ulster Custom' Protestant tenants in the north-east have more security and a property right on improvements they make to the land. Attempts to clear peasants off land to make room for sheep and cattle. Big outflow of cash to absentee English landlords.
18th century: The 'Protestant Ascendancy' established, with 'Penal Laws' against Catholics. Growth of linen industry, especially in the northeast, as a rural cottage industry. Weaverpeasants do deal with merchant capitalists rather than wage-work for industrial capitalists.
After 1800 (Act of Union): decline of industry in South, rise of Belfast industry (linen, shipbuilding, engineering). Before 1800 most of the linen trade from the north-east had gone through Dublin merchants; after 1800 it goes through Belfast. By 1835 Belfast is a busier port than Dublin. There is no integrated all-Ireland economy.
After Famine of 1840s: massive depopulation - people replaced by sheep and cattle.
After 1885, and especially after Wyndham Land Act of 1903: Britain government decides to 'buy out' landlords to pacify Irish countryside. A "bourgeois revolution' on the land -from above:
1920-1: Partition. Southern Ireland gains partial independence from Britain, which over the following decades it makes complete. Northern Ireland remains attached to Britain, but with home rule as a 'Protestant state for a Protestant people' After 1932: 26 Counties shifts to economic nationalism. 'Economic War' between 26 Counties and Britain. Industrial employment expands by 50% between 1931 and 1938, but at a cost.
From mid-1950s: With the old nationalist policy leading to stagnation, the 26 Counties reopens its economy to the world market. Meanwhile Northern Ireland's industries, founded in the 19th century, are declining.
1972: Ireland joins the EEC. Major benefits for Irish farmers.
Ireland today is highly integrated into international economy. The 26 Counties exports over 50 per cent of what it produces, and is increasingly tied in to the EEC. Any economic policy today seeking to cut Ireland off from the rest of the world economy is utopian and reactionary.
Scan page 55
the
----- pull-quotes -----
The Socialist