Is Sinn Fein socialist?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 48 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 48
the chance came. Nor did he believe that there was such a thing as a ripe revolutionary situation. Revolutionary action would make it ripe.
"An epoch to be truly revolutionary must have a dominating number of men with the revolutionary spirit - ready to dare all and take all risks for the sake of their ideas... Revolutionaries who shrink from giving blow for blow until the great day has arrived and they have every shoestring in its place and every man has got his gun and the enemy has kindly consented to postpone action in order not to needlessly hurry the revolutionaries nor disarray their plans — such revolutionaries only exist in two places: on the comic opera stage and on the stage of Irish national politics." (November 1915)
The plan finally agreed eRs?
The Republican movement was crushed and pulverised in World War 2, subject to terrible repression North and South.
It was discredited by its active alliance with Germany, from which it hoped for aid and favour against Britain.
It began to revive in the '50s, but it had shrunk into a single-issue crusade for a united and independent Ireland -which it proposed to achieve by armed struggle only. The economic and social concerns of workers and farmers on both sides of the Border were held to be no business of pure Republicanism.
Not to go into the partitionist Parliaments was a matter of principle, and so was commitment to the idea that only physical force, not 'politics, would win the Republic.
In practice the movement's prejudices and assumptions reflected right-wing Catholic Ireland at the height of the cold war.
It military ly against customs posts and RUC stations in the North. The activities were very small-scale by the standards of the '70s, but they mobilised a lot of support. Abstentionist deputies were elected not only in the North, but also in the South - something Sinn Fein could not repeat in the '80s even during the hunger strike.
the Border Campaign The Fianna Fail government introduced internment in the South in 1957 to deal with the Republicans. By the end of the '50s the 'Border Campaign' had run out of steam. A formal ceasefire was declared in 1962.
Many activists dropped out. The remainder analysed their defeat, and reached conclusions rather like earlier Republicans of the '20s and '30s and like Gerry Adams and his colleagues today.
Concentration on the Border and on the pure military struggle alone would
Scan page 49
Martin McGuiness and Gerry Adams leading Republicans never call forth and organise the forces to gain a united Ireland. They began to discuss social policies and socialism, and to move botin to the left and away from narrow militarism. Timidly they edged towards a break with the principle of abstention.
The Republicans did this partly under the influence of former (or perhaps undercover) members of the British Communist Party and its Irish 'front' the Connolly. Association - Roy Johnstone and Tony Coughlin. The strong Stalinist coloration in the Workers' Party today dates from this period.
The Republicans turned to housing action committees and agitation over Catholic civil rights in Protestant-ruled Northern Ireland.
They expelled and purged traditionalists throughout the country, evolving a Stalinist regime. Opposition to this turn often took the form of a reflex defence of militarism.
The birth of the Provos In August 1969 anti-Catholic violence erupted in the Six Counties - partly triggered by the success of the Republicans' housing and civil rights agitation in mobilising the Catholics. The Republican movement was unprepared and almost totally disarmed, incapable of defending the Catholic ghettoes. Impatient Republicans blamed this on the turn towards politics, and denounced the Stalinist influence. In December 1969 the Provisional IRA split off.
They denounced the Official Republicans as 'extreme socialists' , seeking to establish a totalitarian dictatorship, and as Marxists.
It is pretty firmly established that the Provisionals, certainly those in the North, had encouragement, includirg money, from elements in the_ruling Fianna Fail party in the South. Until it made a sharp change of policy in April 1970, the 26 Counties government channelled money and other support to the Northern Catholics, and Prime Minister Jack Lynch said that the 26 Counties army "would not stand idly by" and let the Catholics in the North be massacred.
But whatever about that, the Provisional movement soon took on a logic of its own.
It grew very quickly, essentially as a militia of the Catholic ghettoes and initially with a purely defensive concept of its role. In Belfast the Provos numbered a few dozen at the beginning of 1970, and over a thousand by early 1971.
They recruited on a policy of simple opposition to British imperialism - and especially the British Army, present on the streets of Northern Ireland since August 1969.
The British Army's heavy-handed policing of Northern Ireland had brought it more and more into conflict with the Catholics who had initially welcomed it. The Army's role was essentially to keep the balance within the artificial Six Counties state, which had a built-in bias in favour of the Protestants. The Catholics were the troublemakers. The Army responded with CS gas against rioting youths.
And so the Provos grew. Somewhere along the line a decision was taken to go on to the offensive. The first soldiers were killed early in 1971, and there was a spate of bombings.
The Republieans Then in August 1971, internment without charge or trial, and exclusively for Catholics, was introduced. It completed the alienation of the Catholic community.
The Provos grew greatly. Many of the young radicals of 1968-9 joined them. The social reality of the Six Counties, the logic and power of the socialist Republican ideas of James Connolly, and the example of revolutions like those of Cuba and Vietnam, radicalised the Provo rank and file in the North. Under the formally right-wing platform staked out by the Provisional leaders in 1969, militant left wing currents developed.
The split with the Official Republicans was not mended. After mid-1972 the majority of the Officials began to veer towards abandoning Republicanism. Today they are the Workers' Party, venomously antinationalist, denouncing the Provos as And the radicalisation within the Provisionals has remained confined to segments of a politically unclear movement, still essentially bound together by commitment to the military struggle against the British Army in the Six Counties.
The IRSP Another Republican faction emerged from a split in the Officials. At the end of 1974 Seamus Costello led a split which became the Irish Republican Socialist Party. Though he had been one of the foremost advocates of a 'political turn' , Costello opposed and fought the drift of the Officials to exclusive reliance on the ballot box and their abandonment of the goal of Irish national unification and independence.
The IRSP set out to create a revolutionary socialist Republican movement opposing both British imperialism and Irish capitalism on a day-to-day basis, both sides of the Border. It said it would concern itself with the workers' struggles in the South much more seriously than the Provisionals did.
But when Seamus Costello was killed by the Official IRA in 1977, it was a fatal blow to the IRSP. It has since declined and fragmented; its armed wing, the INLA, has become more notoriously reckless and anti-Protestant than the Provos.
The form of 'socialist Republicanism' which the IRSP tried to organise is still Ireland
Scan page 50
Ropullinens The Provos in The Provos fell into the doldrums in late 1973 and early 1974, when a powersharing Executive was being set up and operated in Northern Ireland.
They were pushed very much to the sidelines during the decisive struggle between the Protestants and the British government in May 1974.
Then the IRA's first response to the wreck of Britain's strategy was a surge of energetic militarism, which included a stepped-up campaign in Britain. When things slowed down, it became clear that the Republican movement was seriously disoriented. It must have been pretty clear to many in the movement that they had been decisively checkmated by the Protestant General Strike. The days of 1972, when the Provos were able to get direct talks with the British government, were long past. Prospects for any immediate political change in Ireland were bleak.
For most of 1975 there was an IRA ceasefire in Northern Ireland. This was the year in which Britain's Labour government set up an elected assembly to try to work out an agreed constitution to replace the one that the Protestant workers wrecked in 1974.
Sinn Fein was allowed to set up 'incident centres, recognised by the British authorities, through which a considerable amount of contact and collaboration took place.
In early 1976, the constitutional assembly's Protestant majority reported its conclusions to the British government: that majority (that is, Protestant) rule be restored immediately. Britain rejected this. It decided to make an end to the search for political solutions, and to go all-out to stabilise the Six Counties.
This meant making military defeat of the IRA the central immediate goal. The IRA was both the direct source of the Catholic military offensive against the British Army, and the indirect cause of the Protestant unrest.
Towards the hunger strikes Britain launched a new offensive against the IRA. As always, it translated itself into a savage assault on the Catholic community, a sizeable part of which gives active or passive support to the IRA. This assault massively alienated the Catholic population; the IRA recruited, reorganised itself on a tighter cell structure, and fought back.
ors' In 1976 the Labour government withdrew, for all paramilitaries convicted after April 1976, the 'special status' conceded by the Tories in 1972. Republican prisoners began the 'blanket protest'. They refused to wear prison clothes. When confined to their cells in blankets, they refused to 'slop out' Outside, Relatives Action Committees agitated and built up support. Over five years the Catholic mass movement renewed itself, focusing on the By the time Bobby Sands was elected MP, and died on hunger strike - the first of ten - in 1981, the Catholic mass movement was on a scale not seen since 1972. There were even stirrings in the South, for the first time since 1972.
When the hunger strike was over, the Republican leaders had to decide what to do about the fact that their main gains had been political gains. The feeble state of the SDLP made politics — the chance to become the electorally recognised representative of the Catholic community — irresistible to the Provo leadership.
After years of wasting and going to seed in the no-politics wilderness imposed in Northern Ireland by Britain after 1976, the SDLP had been forced by the feeling in the Catholic community into reluctant, tepid support for the hunger strike. It was pushed into the invidious position of indirectly supporting the Provisionals, thereby conceding a tremendous moral advantage to them.
A new approach rose out of the grave of Bobby Sands MP. 'An armalite in one hand, and a ballot paper in the other', became the self-definition of the radical wing of the Republicans, based in the North. This was the politics that took over the national organisation at the Sinn Fein Ard Fheis (conference) of November 1983.
The contradictions in the radicalisation of Sinn Fein The radicalisation was accompanied by a turn away from any serious notion of conciliating the Protestant workers. In 1972 the Provisionals had adopted the policy of a federal united Ireland which, in however confused a way, did (as one Provo leader put it) "extend the hand of friendship" to the Protestant people of Northern Ireland.
Now federalism was rejected as a sop to 'pro-imperialists' , and implicitly replaced by a perspective of forcing the British state to force the Protestants into a united Ireland. Provo leftists continued to talk about reaching out to the Protestant workers - but said it would be possible only after a united Ireland had been imposed.
There are other contradictions in the radicalisation of the Provos, contradictions rooted deep in the history of Irish Republicanism.
One reason why the Republicans in the '40s and '50s had been so unrelievedly right-wing — in contrast to the '20s and '30s. and earlier — was the thinness of their ranks. Scattered over the surface of Irish society, they lacked organic contact, involvement, or concert, as a political movement, with the social problems of either workers or small farmers.
In the North in the '70s it was different. The Catholics of the cities and semi-permanent sneral ment, sul, in poverty and often in hopelessness.
In addition, the leaders of the Republican movement and its activists saw their own reflection in movements of the oppressed throughout the world, just as the Catholics of Derry in the late '60s saw themselves as the counterparts of the Blacks in the USA.
Apart and aside from all questions of political conviction, a movement like the Provisionals in conditions like Northern Ireland's has an imperious reason to be radical — it needs to attach as many people as possible to its nationalist cause. Social agitation and becoming involved in community politics has the same recommendation to the Irishseparatist physical-force politician in Belfast as to the parliamentary Liberal politician in Liverpool - it builds support, it makes the politician the champion of the community.
The political faction of the Provisionals initially presented their ideas to the movement as an essential part of the social logistics of fighting a prolonged guerilla war which, they said, might last for 20 years.
The turn to politics, to social issues, and to the left, thus is and was compromised by two fatal limitations. It remains subordinate and ancillary to the military campaign, which is still the central unifying principle of the Provos. And it is a turn confined to one community in Northern Ireland's divided working class.
Sinn Fein election candidates will campaign, for example, for better bus services — but for better bus services for Catholic areas.
The left Republican tradition The other strand woven into the Provos' new approach is the powerful historical tradition of left-wing populist Republicanism.
We must turn to the men of no property, said Wolfe Tone in the 1790s, and his words were deliberately picked up and repeated by the socialist Republican Liam Mellowes writing from Mountjoy jail in 1922 about the deal that the southern Irish bourgeoisie had made with the British Empire to subvert and overthrow the Irish Republic. Mellowes was shot by the Free State government in December 1922.
In the aftermath of the defeat of the Republicans and the consolidation of the Free State government, this idea was taken up by George Gilmore and Paedar O'Donnell. Their politics was a genuine populism - radicalism basing itself on 'the people' in general rather than the
Scan page 51
working class in particular.
This native strand of left Republicanism, moving confusedly towards working-class politics, met up with the Stalinists in the 1930s, and had all its nationalist limits reinforced and strengthened. The notion of the two-stage revolution - first complete the "bourgeois revolution', and only then fight for socialism - was translated into "Irish' as the idea that national independence had to be 'completed' as a first stage towards socialism.
'First win the broad common demand for the independent national Republic - and then go for the Workers' Republic' was the slogan of the majority of the left-wing Republican Congress, which included the Stalinists, in 1934.
These ideas gained influence in the 1970s because they seemed to offer a reconciliation of socialist and radical goals with an immediate focus on the nationalist war in the Six Counties -begun by the Provisionals in their rightwing phase.
Abandoning abstentionism In November 1986 the men who founded the Provisionals in 1969-70, Rory O'Brady and David O'Connell, broke away to form a new organisation, Republican Sinn Fein.
They walked out when Sinn Fein voted by the necessary two-thirds majority to end its 64 year-old policy of refusing to take any seats in the Dublin parliament. Sinn Fein had decided three years earlier to take seats if elected to the EEC parliament, but continues to boycott Westminster and will boycott any further Belfast parliament.
O'Brady and O'Connell had also fought against the change of line on federalism. Only 30-odd of the 160 delegates who voted against the change of policy on taking seats in Dublin walked out with them, and Republican Sinn Fein remains a small group. Nevertheless the split was significant.
Republican history has a recurrent pattern of groupings which move away from commitment to physical force on principle towards politics — and become more or less radical bourgeois parliamentary parties.
Such was the origin of Fine Gael, which is the descendant of the party founded by the ex-Republicans who set up the Free State in the 1920s. Such was the origin of Fianna Fail, set up by Republicans who entered Dublin parliamentary politics in the I93Us; ot Clann na Poblachta, a venture into parliamentary politics by left Republicans in the 1940s which quickly collapsed; and of the Workers' Party, which was the Official Republican movement.
Why has there been this pattern? Because the Republican movement is a single-issue movement. Onto the stem of that single issue, radical social politics have been grafted at different times over the decades; but the twin axioms of physical force on principle and abstention from parliamentary politics have remained fundamental, as the guarantees against being distracted, the way to ensure that social questions cut channels to the national question and do not displace it.
Traditional Republicans are intransigent revolutionaries. Their revolutionism consists in a stark rejection of existing political and state structures, and the pursuit of other, ideal, alternative structures.
The goal is 'The Republic' — a slogan which represents a mystical future state of ideal freedom, harmony and prosperity entirely beyond the modest real prospects of a bourgeois-democratic united Ireland. The ideal future Republic represents the ideal will of the people; all existing institutions are the work of traitors and foreign influences. Physical force is the only practical action that is recognised as decisive for the work of substituting the desired ideal for what exists now.
Thus the fetishes of physical force on principle and abstentionism complement and reintorce each other to sustain a sort of revolutionary politics.
But it is not socially revolutionary. And that is why so many Republican groups which moved away from abstentionism have also moved away from any sort of revolutionary politics.
A Marxist working-class organisation can use tactics and techniques in a varied way, working in a bourgeois parliament trade unions or through armed stre -fe ticit. andr mace all tactical fetishes that separated those exRepublican groups from the existing bourgeois and petty-bourgeois order were cleared away, there was nothing solid to maintain their revolutionary stance.
Abstentionist and physical-force-onprinciple Irish Republicanism has many things in common with Spanish anarchism. Its repeated fate in relation to government is similar to that of the anarchists who 'denied' politics and the state for decades, and then during the Spanish Civil War joined the Popular Front government of the Republic (which repressed rank and file anarchists).
The anarchists denied the state; but the state is necessary. It cannot be abolished at this stage of social development. It must be either the bourgeois state or the workers' state.
The Spanish Civil War convinced some of the anarchist leaders that the state was necessary. But then they could only relate to it by betraying themselves. Having no programme capable of dealing with reality, they accepted the existing state and became its prisoners.
That is why the Provos' shift towards participation in parliamentary politics has destabilised their movement and may destabilise it further. For the present their commitment to physical force on principle remains strong, and the traditionalist breakaway small.
The Republicans Are the Provo: socialist?
It is indisputable that many, or even most, of the members of the Republican movement want it to be a left-wing and socialist movement, based upon and championing the working class and working farmers.
Sinn Fein defines itself as based on the 1916 declaration of the Irish Republic and on the 1919 'Democratic Programme' of the Irish parliament, Dail Eireann.
Both those documents had a certain radical edge to them in their own time. The 1919 document was drafted by the Irish labour leaders, and adopted by Dail Eireann in return for the labour movement subordinating itself to the nationalists during the struggle with Britain for independence.
But they are not documents of social radicalism today. They do no more than talk vaguely about the state having social responsibilities, treating 'the children of the nation' equally, and so on. Before the Welfare State that was radical, but today even many Tories would at least pay lip-service to such principles.
The Provos remain a loose populist party which cannot in its present form function as a serious force for socialism in Ireland. Indeed, because of its attitude to the Protestant workers in Northern Ireland, it is bound, despise good intentions, to work working-class socialism.
It remains the military leadership and militia of the oppressed Catholics, and for that reason deserves the support of British socialists against the British state in Northern Ireland. But there should be no illusions about its socialist pretensions.
The Provos Protestants® The populism of the Provos is expressed in the vagueness of their ideas of socialism, but also, and crucially, in their attitude to the Protestant working Since the Protestants include the big majority of the working class in Northern Ireland, an attitude to the Protestants also implies an attitude to the working class, and has decisive implications for the identification and definition of the force that will bring socialism. Whatever the Provos mean by Ireland
Scan page 52
The Ropublicans socialism, it is something to be created by the Catholic community, not by the working class, Catholic and Protestant alike.
Socialism is equated with anti-imperialism, and anti-imperialism with the military struggle in the North. Sectarianism is identified exclusively as a creation of Britain — and the answer to sectarianism, therefore, is once again the military struggle in the North. The Protestant workers are seen not in social, class, terms, but almost exclusively as a catspaw of Britain and as the embodiment of sectarianism.
By a process of redefining terms, therefore, non-sectarian socialism is equated (for immediate activity) with a narrow nationalist militarism. not address their concerns.
But the Provos' politics would still be Catholic communalism even if they got mass support in the South.
It is not only undesirable, but impossible, to press the Northern Protestants into a united Ireland by Catholic military force; a serious drive to do it could only end in civil war and bitter repartition. The Provos' current politics are thus unable even to win a free united Ireland, let alone socialism.
Central to Irish politics is the fact that between a quarter and a fifth of the people of Ireland are the main obstacles to Irish unity. But in Sinn Fein politics, the history of British crimes against Ireland, and the reality of British army brutality in Northern Ireland now, are used to obscure and muddle this = to present the problem of the Protestants as merely a sub-section of the problem of British occupation.
This means evading the nature of the basic problem which any organisation which wants to forge Irish unity - let alone Irish working-class unity - must face and solve.
Irish workers who really want to fight for a socialist Ireland will have to reject and go beyond the politics of Sinn Fein, and take their stand on working-class Marxist socialism.
----- pull-quotes -----
The Socialist
The Socialist AnSW
The Socialist
The Socialist